Bumping this because it remains one of my weaknesses as well. I've gone through the FA section, and have gone through a Kaplan review on behavioral science, and still just score "average" here.
I know that some questions I miss I think are more pharm than behavioral (well, at least according to Kaplan they are behavioral), such as antipsychotic drug side effects, mechanisms, etc. I haven't really hit pharm hard yet so that doesn't bother me. With the NBME (only taken form 1 so far) I don't know what questions were included in behavioral and which in pharm or other areas, so I only know that my behavioral bar was borderline/average/whatever you consider the center of the graph to be.
But I do keep missing questions on "what should you do/say" situations. Any advice? I know the WWJD strategy, but the ones I miss usually come down to two answers that I can justify almost equally well. So I miss about half of those (maybe 1 out of ever 4 or 5 situational questions, which is too much when these should be gimmies). The question is usually a choice between a blunt/direct approach or a tangential/ease-into-it approach. Do you say "I see something is bothering you, do you mind talking about that" or "what brings you in today." I can see both being appropriate given a particular patient, which I never feel is detailed well enough to know which is a better course.
I haven't picked up any HY/roadmap etc. yet for behavioral/psychiatry, so maybe that will help more. I'm looking for a pretty succint list of "rules" that you should always follow to reach the correct answer for board purposes. I don't care if I agree or not, I just want to know how to get to the right answer. My people skills are fine, I have no concerns there... I just don't want to lose points on a written exam due to "not knowing the 'rules' of the game."