•••quote:•••Originally posted by Careofme:
•Dr. Maxy,
I must be dense or something but I can never seem to find the Osteopathic Medical School rankings on US News and World Report. Can you help?
Thanks,
Careofme•••••Please do not simply base your choice of schools on the ranking of a mere magazine. I mean, where inthe purpose or title of a news rag is an implied or real extpertise in the rankings of medical schools? Last time I perused their "rankings" (please correct me if this has changed)school rank was largely assigned based upont he %-age of graduates that match into "primary care" specialties.
There is far more that goes into judging the level of quality of a school than how many primary care practitioners it can churn out. Not to metion the fact that US News includes everyone entering a Peds, IM, FP, OB/Gyn...as primary care docs-to-be. There is no mention that to subspecialize in virtually all adult or pediatric disciplines (cardiology, interventional cardio, peds ICU, peds cardio...) that a doc must first do a Peds or IM residency -- this means there is inherent error in saying all of these folks are headed to primary care.
In my humble opinion, the most critical element in your success as a medical student and, hopefully, as a physician is how well you, as a person, fit into the school -- its students, faculty & staff. If you get into a top 20 school and hate the entire process -- are you still successful? Or, might you have been better off in a different school, selected because you loved the environment/school/people, and received an equal or even better education, since you were happier?
Yes, in some instances, having that top 20 name on your wall is a major advantage. If your passion is research or to enter an exquisitely competitive field, then it might be worth the effort you expend. But, if you're planning on entering general practice or focusing on clinical medicine like the rest of us...then there is only questionable benefit to the high-powered name. Remember that even in the most competitive of fields...there are many many practitioners who did not come from the top 20 schools. Also, if you're not happy, it is unlikely that you will perform to your best capability for 4 years...thereby lessening your chances at that highly competitive slot.
My $0.02 worth on the topic!