Which specialty is best for me?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

bobthesun

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2010
Messages
128
Reaction score
5
So i know i really want to work with athletes or patients in the 15-40 age range. Don't like working with old people at all and am a male so ob/gyn is probably not for me. I heard most sports medicine doctors usually do the "sports medicine" gig on the side and i HATE primary care. I want to do some sort of procedural stuff and a field in which technology is advancing and the field advancing as well. I'm thinking physical rehab or sports othro or something like that. my board scores will probably be low however as I am not the greatest test taker. probably 200 not more than 205. I was a college d3 athlete so will that help me get into ortho? I'm kinda a jock... besides ortho and physiatry any other recommendations for me?

pathology is an option but uncle is a pathologist and he does not recommend the field. he says the future technologies in my lifetime will ultimately make pathologist obsolete. and he says its very difficult to find a job.

pain seems interesting to me same with anesthesiology...but do pain management physicians work with old people?

Members don't see this ad.
 
Last edited:
Cart ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Horse.

Settle down, man. Have you even gotten into medical school yet? Focus on getting into school, then doing well once you're in so you have as many options as possible. It's cool to have ideas but the fact of the matter is that many of us will change our minds once we actually do clerkships in 3rd and 4th year.
 
So i know i really want to work with athletes or patients in the 15-40 age range. Don't like working with old people at all and am a male so ob/gyn is probably not for me. I heard most sports medicine doctors usually do the "sports medicine" gig on the side and i HATE primary care. I want to do some sort of procedural stuff and a field in which technology is advancing and the field advancing as well. I'm thinking physical rehab or sports othro or something like that. my board scores will probably be low however as I am not the greatest test taker. probably 200 not more than 205. I was a college d3 athlete so will that help me get into ortho? I'm kinda a jock... besides ortho and physiatry any other recommendations for me?

pathology is an option but uncle is a pathologist and he does not recommend the field. he says the future technologies in my lifetime will ultimately make pathologist obsolete. and he says its very difficult to find a job.

pain seems interesting to me same with anesthesiology...but do pain management physicians work with old people?

I agree with the first response to this post. However, how do you know your likes and dislikes? Have you had a lot of clinical experience working with old people? Bolded text add for emphasis:

Being a male has nothing to do with ob/gyn being "probably not for me." You may think most women prefer a female ob/gyn, and maybe that's true, I really have no idea, but I think first and foremost most patients want a competent doctor that they like, i.e. has good bedside manner. There are definitely reasons to like ob/gyn that maybe you aren't considering: it has both medical and surgical components, some procedures, and plenty of areas to specialize in: gyn/onc, maternal/fetal medicine, urogyn, among others. So you get to do surgery and some procedures, possibly deliver babies if you do obstetrics, etc. Being male does not exclude you from being a successful ob/gyn physician.

How do you know you don't like working with old people? What's the bias? Have you worked in some capacity with old people, or are you just basing it off "old people" you've encountered including your relatives and not considering geriatric needs? Maybe "I don't like wrinkles" is an acceptable answer, I don't know, I'm just curious about your rationale.

Being a jock won't help you get into ortho. You won't put together your CV, audition rotation or interviews and say, "Well, I was a D3 athlete so why don't we just shake on it here, I mean do you really have to interview me? I'll see you in July." There is some small truth in the ortho stereotype though, a lot of the orthopods I've met have been very athletic and played sports their whole lives.

Pain management physicians work with people with pain, typically chronic pain, which can include "old people." In fact, I'd say a good part of their patient census is probably "old people" or at least middle-aged people and upward.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
So i know i really want to work with athletes or patients in the 15-40 age range. Don't like working with old people at all and am a male so ob/gyn is probably not for me. I heard most sports medicine doctors usually do the "sports medicine" gig on the side and i HATE primary care. I want to do some sort of procedural stuff and a field in which technology is advancing and the field advancing as well. I'm thinking physical rehab or sports othro or something like that. my board scores will probably be low however as I am not the greatest test taker. probably 200 not more than 205. I was a college d3 athlete so will that help me get into ortho? I'm kinda a jock... besides ortho and physiatry any other recommendations for me?

pathology is an option but uncle is a pathologist and he does not recommend the field. he says the future technologies in my lifetime will ultimately make pathologist obsolete. and he says its very difficult to find a job.

pain seems interesting to me same with anesthesiology...but do pain management physicians work with old people?

The two most common ways to get into "sports medicine" are family medicine and ortho. They vary in a number of ways, competition being the prominent one that you mentioned. Ortho requires high board scores and oftentimes research; being an athlete in and of itself will not help you. Otherwise, it is a question of surgical vs non-surgical.

Don't know a lot about the PM&R route, but it's not a competitive residency to get into. Like family medicine, it is non-surgical. Although, if you think you won't like going through a primary care residency first (and if you don't like old people), you probably won't like going through a PM&R residency first, either.

Don't not go into a field (pathology) because of anecdotal evidence. You can find someone in every field to say something negative about their career.

Pain specialists definitely work with old people. Every field except pediatrics works with old people, in fact.

But most importantly, don't worry about it until your 3rd year of medical school. You won't really know what you like/dislike until you actually start doing it.
 
So i know i really want to work with athletes or patients in the 15-40 age range. Don't like working with old people at all and am a male so ob/gyn is probably not for me. I heard most sports medicine doctors usually do the "sports medicine" gig on the side and i HATE primary care. I want to do some sort of procedural stuff and a field in which technology is advancing and the field advancing as well. I'm thinking physical rehab or sports othro or something like that. my board scores will probably be low however as I am not the greatest test taker. probably 200 not more than 205. I was a college d3 athlete so will that help me get into ortho? I'm kinda a jock... besides ortho and physiatry any other recommendations for me?

pathology is an option but uncle is a pathologist and he does not recommend the field. he says the future technologies in my lifetime will ultimately make pathologist obsolete. and he says its very difficult to find a job.

pain seems interesting to me same with anesthesiology...but do pain management physicians work with old people?



1. Unless you do pediatrics, most of your patient will be old, any specialty you do. Young people typically don't get sick. Old people do, a lot. Physiatry (PM&R) means you will be seeing a lot of stroke patients, most of them old. Ortho... similar drawback.

2. You hate primary care... many specialties fall under this umbrella term.

3. If you are not a great test taker, you will have a hard time doing anything in medicine, and definitely anything competitive like ortho.

4. Pathologists are not going to become 'obsolete' because of new technologies. There are many many problems with the specialty (extremely poor job market is one of them), but a threat of being replaced by an automated procedure is not one of them.
 
Is that your professional opinion as someone with a PhD in Bastardology? :D

Yes it is. With my 20 years of on the job training in bastardology, I feel that it allows me to confidently make that call.

I'm 100% sure that is the best profession for the OP. That is my professional opinion :D
 
How medicine has changed over the years.

Back in the day, specializing actually came after med school, not before.
 
So i know i really want to work with athletes or patients in the 15-40 age range. Don't like working with old people at all and am a male so ob/gyn is probably not for me. I heard most sports medicine doctors usually do the "sports medicine" gig on the side and i HATE primary care. I want to do some sort of procedural stuff and a field in which technology is advancing and the field advancing as well. I'm thinking physical rehab or sports othro or something like that. my board scores will probably be low however as I am not the greatest test taker. probably 200 not more than 205. I was a college d3 athlete so will that help me get into ortho? I'm kinda a jock... besides ortho and physiatry any other recommendations for me?

pathology is an option but uncle is a pathologist and he does not recommend the field. he says the future technologies in my lifetime will ultimately make pathologist obsolete. and he says its very difficult to find a job.

pain seems interesting to me same with anesthesiology...but do pain management physicians work with old people?
lots of troll here.
 
I'm going to hope your not a troll and give you a real response.

You can get into sports med from many different tracts. Ortho, FM, IM, Peds, PMR are the general ones (there are fellowships in MSK from radiology, but it's not quite the same as sports med). However, with a score of 200-205 you would be severely limited - in 2009, PMR average was 214, FM was 214, Peds was 219, IM was 225, and Ortho around 238 (http://www.nrmp.org/data/chartingoutcomes2009v3.pdf).

If you don't want to do primary care, then PMR seems to be the best fit. You might need to boost your step 1 score.

However, since your posting this is Pre-Allo, I'm going to assume that you are not in medical school yet. Once (read: if) you get there, you might change your mind about many of your absolute ideas.
 
I didn't read the OP's post, but the answer to his question is urology.

I only tell you because I'm qualified to tell you.
 
If you like working with young, healthy people, you'd think ob/gyn would be on your list.
 
like ortho and sports, but non-competitive as applicant (low board scores) = PM&R
 
Top