F
fourthwatch96822
Has any of you told your family doctor/internist that you were applyiing to medical school? If you did, does he/she bring the topic up at all? Just curious.
Originally posted by serpiente:
•4th watch, maybe your doc is jaded and disillusioned with the medical field. Many older docs that I've talked to, say stuff like they wish they'd never become a doctor with the way things are now, why would you want to become a doctor these days, etc. So I wouldn't take it personally.•••
Thank you very much your response. I think you really have a point.
peace
Originally posted by reesie0726:
•That's true. I cant tell you how many doctors have told me the same thing. That makes me so mad when they want to be discouraging like that. There are a number of doctors who are disillusioned like that and you cant pay any attention to them.•••
Thank you for your response too. I think you guys are really on to something.
Originally posted by katiep:
•What school was that, Wahoo?•••
That was at Stanford. It was definitely my weirdest interview experience. All the other applicants that were with me that day had antagonistic interviewers, but at least they got antagonistic questions rather than just an antagonistic rant. But I can't complain tooo much, because they accepted me
Originally posted by fiammarosa:
•I loved my personal doctor. She was the nicest doctor I have ever had - I remember the first time I saw her in winter 1999, she spent an hour with me. Now I know she was taking a history, but then I was impressed (I am on an HMO, so she is technically only supposed to spend 20 minutes with me). She always remembered me and her nurses always remembered my name and what I did for a living. Interestingly, she had also done the Harvard post-bacc program (which I am in right now) and finished her IM residency in the late 1990s.
I had an appointment in November with her. I was pretty stressed: hmm, let's see what was going on...My first major car accident was in the beginning of the month, where my two driver's side doors were torn off but I was somehow uninjured. My grandfather died and I was faced with seeing my father for the first time in 14 years. I moved from one apartment to another, which is a stressful event in itself. I was taking these classes, commuting an hour each way, and keeping up with work.
When she came in the door, she asked how I was. And I told her how I was - stressed - and I made my little list of all the things I was stressed about. She turned to me and said, "If you can't handle one month of bad luck, then you should really reconsider med school. You'll be wasting your time because you'll get kicked out. You can't complain as a doctor." Blah blah blah. She spoke from her personal experience and said I should take next semester off and think about whether I'm really suited to medicine, etc etc. She compared me to some other patient of hers that day, who was a woman with three kids under 5. This woman had asked for sleeping pills. I must point out that I was NOT asking for medication - just answering her question (and maybe hoping for a little sympathy ). The medical reason for the visit was totally unrelated (yearly gyno exam). I just sat there shocked.
I haven't gone back since, because I feel it was an overreaction on her part (hey, I wound up doing fine and got straight As). I had an exam that night and I left her office feeling so low and stupid and awful. Part of me wants to go back and tell her how great I am doing now (really, who wouldn't be stressed after all that?) but another part just wants to find a new doctor who might be a little supportive in my next two years before I apply.
Maybe she was almost kicked out of med school herself! Maybe she was trying to scare me or see how I would react. But in any case, she totally alienated me, and I don't even want to see her again because I don't want her "tsk, tsk" when I tell her I haven't given up.•••
I am sorry that your grandfather died and sorry that you had such a bad experience with your doctor.
When I read your message, I was almost speechless. Anyone would be depressed by what you went through. You are human and need the time to grieve. If she can't understand that, she shouldn't be in any healthcare field at all. Apparently, she feels that doctors are not human and shouldn't be grieving. Her statement about your stress now and the stress in medical school is ridiculous.
Also, it is extremely unprofessional of her to be comparing you with another patient.
I would go and talk to her about your visit. You may want to tell her how she made you feel. It is really pathetic how she continues to practice medicine with her EGOCENTRIC ATTITUDE.
Originally posted by snowballz:
•I think the older physicians would know more about being a physician than a premed or medical student. I would value their opinions a great deal. I have gotten opinions from a physician of mine and a acquaintance of my fathers. He also told me not to do it. It's not a fun job anymore, he says. They are not trying to discourage us, but letting us in on reality.
Alicia•••
Her physician was being judgemental. She had no place to make statements like she did. Having the need to grieve, has nothing to do with what profession you are in, but being a human being.