Your thoughts on the value of APA membership

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Joined
Jul 15, 2014
Messages
2,197
Reaction score
2,966
It's September so naturally I'm getting spammed by APA to renew my membership. I am, however, on the fence about doing so. I used the ethics consult service this past year who just referred me to my liability insurance carrier (despite the question had nothing to do with my own practice) and APA has staked out so pretty far left positions recently that I as a center-left moderate don't really support. I also have journal access through my AMC affiliation. That said, I do want to participate in advocacy for my profession and since I have funds to cover my membership fees its not a question of personal finance. It's more a question of whether my resources are better spent on say, an ABCT membership, or paying for training in CPT. Also, I'm already a member of my state org so I am participating in advocacy at the local level.

Members don't see this ad.
 
I have never been a member so maybe I don't know what I'm missing, but I have never felt the need. I have spent my membership dues on more niche (inter)national orgs, such as AABT/ABCT, as well as local and regional organizations, such as state psych, neuropsych, and ABA organizations. As a student and young career professional,, I found the networking opportunities at the local and niche organization conferences to be invaluable.. I access journals though my institution. Local organizations (especially ABA) have done some pretty amazing lobbying for good legislation. While I've never really considered APA membership, their recent endorsements of questionable training training programs and models would keep me from doing so. It's always seemed more of a guild aiming to protect all dues paying members- no matter the cost-than a professional organization aiming to protect the science and integrity of the field.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Members don't see this ad :)
I keep an active membership and contribute to their PAC as well. It a relatively small sum of money and much like voting, you can't really complain everything is going to hell if you are part of the problem.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
I stopped joining after graduate school. I don't agree with many of their positions, and I would rather my money go elsewhere.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
Regardless of some of their more questionable advocacy issues, a bulk of their advocacy is still on reimbursement and practice issues. So, if you're not supplementing that somehow, you have no reason to bitch about lowered reimbursements.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6 users
Regardless of some of their more questionable advocacy issues, a bulk of their advocacy is still on reimbursement and practice issues. So, if you're not supplementing that somehow, you have no reason to bitch about lowered reimbursements.
Yeah, and they actually do really active, connected advocacy for psychology reimbursement.
 
Has APA's advocacy on reimbursement resulted in any deliverables?

As was pointed out, yes. Unfortunately, some of the efforts are hampered by apathy and lack of investment from psychologists as a whole. It's a pitifully low number of folks who will spend 5 minutes sending a pre-constructed form letter to their representatives when asked. Likewise when asked to submit a form letter when CMS changes come around.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
I belong to some of the subdivisions but that's it. There are other professional organizations that I value more (e.g., ISTSS)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
APA is morally and ethically bankrupt. Good enough reason to avoid it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
They are the only organization that negotiates for our CPT codes. Absent the APA, there is no testing CPT code, no H&B CPT codes, no group therapy CPT codes, no feedback CPT codes, etc.

You can either have someone represent your financial interests, or have no one represent your financial interests.
 
  • Like
  • Hmm
Reactions: 8 users
They are the only organization that negotiates for our CPT codes. Absent the APA, there is no testing CPT code, no H&B CPT codes, no group therapy CPT codes, no feedback CPT codes, etc.

You can either have someone represent your financial interests, or have no one represent your financial interests.

some people are big fans of cutting off their noses, to spite their face
 
As has been said, they're the only major player negotiating and advocating for us on a national level. I don't agree with all of their semi-political (or outright political) stances and past actions, but change is more effective from within than without. And I haven't seen much in the way of their lobbying efforts that I've disagreed with. I regularly donate to their PAC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
The Fielding lady was elected for APA president in 2026. I'm all for payor advocacy, but her platform seems ultra political, if you ask me.

 
Honestly I think, and this is more recently, they provide more value and benefit than my state psychological association. The only reason to really keep paying my state membership is they do have deeply discounted CEs for members and do advocate on the state level, but their cons is the membership costs more than APA, their annual convention costs double the APA, they are getting rid of list servs in lieu of an app. I get more value out of my APA membership lately.

Went to my first APA convention this year (had been to other APA events and meetings as a graduate student) and it really opened my eyes to just how large and involved the APA is across the board and across the world. As others said the APA advocates and pushes for CPT reimbursement increases and advocates for our work. They also are the gold standard in accrediting and reviewing doctoral training programs and internships. Despite their flaw of still supporting some known diploma mill, they do ensure and regulate standards of education and training. The membership also offers some free CEs and I've gotten some deep discounts on CE bundles as well as discounted access to convention and the included live CEs.
 
Top