Navy Pilot with Pectus Excavatum?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

bobchinn

New Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2012
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
I am a 20 year old, 6'2" male in the Naval Reserve Officer Training Corps (NROTC) at college. It has always been my dream to become a Naval Pilot, but I am worried that I will be disqualified for my Pectus Excavatum.

I believe my case is mild/moderate, because I have never been officially diagnosed with it by a physician. I am of quite athletic build, so it may be hard to discern with my pecs and abs. Nevertheless, I am sure I suffer from the condition.

When I was applying for the NROTC scholarship, I had to go to a DoD facility for a lung spirometry because I "had asthma" when I was younger. I used an inhaler at about the age of 12 (very rarely) before physical activity. (Looking back at it now, I think my lungs were probably just out of shape 😛 or it had something to do with my pectus excavatum.) I had a doctor send a letter to the Department of Defense review board to say that I did not have asthma and it may have been a misdiagnosis. The results of the spirometry showed that I had healthy lungs, though my lung capacity was under average for a male of my height and age.

Now I am a sophomore in the NROTC program, and as I approach service assignment selection and commissioning, I am getting more worried that my condition, if discovered by DoD/Navy physicians, will not allow me to become a pilot. I have some friends in the NROTC Unit who are seniors and are selected to be pilots, so I know all about the physicals they need to have before going to flight school, which includes a chest xray (I'm not sure if I have ever had one done).

Is just having this condition going to disqualify me medically? Would they try to treat my condition? Currently it does not bother me much, except it definitely makes me self-conscious. I would not oppose the procedure, purely out of personal cosmetic reasons. I would do it but I don't know if having that procedure would disqualify me either. And if I am not a good candidate for the procedure, I would regret bringing it up and making my condition known to the doctors who could disqualify me.

I really think it would be a mistake of their part if they disqualified me. I have flown in trainer airplanes before and I seem to have a knack for flying. I was a varsity athlete in track and football in high school and I went to state for track in a few sprint and jump events. I can also run about a 5:10 mile, and get nearly perfect score on the NROTC fitness tests. So clearly I am in good shape and the condition doesn't affect me (even if it does, I have worked hard to overcome it).

If anyone could help me figure out what to do with this issue or if anyone has a personal experience regarding the topic, your help would be greatly appreciated.

Let me know if you think you need anymore information about it. Thanks!

Members don't see this ad.
 
So in your infinite wisdom and extensive aeromedical physiology experience, disqualification would be a "really bad idea." Perhaps you can see why they don't give a **** what you think.

Lie at your own risk. Get medical advice elsewhere shipmate.
 
By no means am I saying that I am an expert on the topic. I really don't want to be disqualified, but if I am there is nothing I can do. I haven't ever lied to any physicians about my health in any way. I'm just saying if they haven't caught it yet, will they later and will it be a big deal?

I am asking if anybody actually knows something about this topic and can shed some light on what may be to come for me in my preflight physicals.

Thanks for your input.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
If they catch it in the physical, is a disqualifying condition? Can it be waived?
 
There is no "if they catch it." You do realize that they will make you take your shirt off, right? And what Lee said cannot be overstated. Your commissioning physical is potentially the second most thorough physical you will ever get in your life. The first most is the NOMI/NAMI whammy you'll get in Pensacola if you actually are selected for aviation. Waivers are extremely rare before you get your wings. There are always more than enough willing, want to be fighter pilots than there are slots available. Having said that I have no idea if it is disqualifying or not.
 
The relevant references are the MANMED and the Aeromedical Waiver Guide. Both available online with a little google-fu. It all comes down to severity/symptoms and is, therefore, subjective and unpredictable.
 
Funny you should ask...

I did a long form with a guy today who has a waiver for pectus excavatum. I am sure he didn't just contract it suddenly so it was obviously granted during his applicant physical.

That said, the aeromedical waiver and reference guide makes no specific comment, so as with the majority of medical conditions you are subject to the whims of NAMI. As suggested by gastropathy, NAMI will do what it wants when it wants.

I will also caution that while I waiver may be granted, what about the kid who has the same application sitting next to you with no waivers. If there's a crunch I know who I am betting on.

Which leads me to my final advice, if it isn't obvious (taking your word here) it all depends on who does your physical. Like any other physician, some flight surgeons wants to write waivers and others don't.
 
Top