Inpatient consult during residency

Started by DrProtonX
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

DrProtonX

Full Member
2+ Year Member
How did your residency program handle inpatient consults? How busy was it? How often was each resident on call? Were you seeing regular clinic patients when you were on call?
 
During my residency (2007-2011):

1. The Chief Resident was basically on the receiving end of all inpatient consult requests
2. On paper, we also had an Attending on call but the Chief had to beg them to take the consult and, of course, they could always say no.
3. If they refused, the Chief would go down the list of attendings and beg each one to staff the consult until one of them consented. As with most things in life, it is generally the most junior people who were handed the short-end of the stick.
4. Whichever Resident was attached to that attending was responsible for staffing the consult

Recently, I understand that my residency now has an inpatient consult service so I think the above old school model is now void.
 
During my residency (2007-2011):

1. The Chief Resident was basically on the receiving end of all inpatient consult requests
2. On paper, we also had an Attending on call but the Chief had to beg them to take the consult and, of course, they could always say no.
3. If they refused, the Chief would go down the list of attendings and beg each one to staff the consult until one of them consented. As with most things in life, it is generally the most junior people who were handed the short-end of the stick.
4. Whichever Resident was attached to that attending was responsible for staffing the consult

Recently, I understand that my residency now has an inpatient consult service so I think the above old school model is now void.
This is horrible.
I distribute the inpatient consults to my residents myself. If anyone complains about getting one, he/she get's two.
 
I find that the reason for doing an inpatient radiation oncology consult is to make absolutely sure that said inpatient does not need inpatient radiotherapy. And also to make sure they get an appointment card for an outpatient visit. I would think there would have to be some addressable issues at hand if the inpatient consult service was constantly “busy.” Ideally a resident would be on call no more than 1/Nth of the time (N=total number of PGY 3/4/5s in the program); in my residency we didn’t think PGY2s should take call.
 
During my residency (2007-2011):

1. The Chief Resident was basically on the receiving end of all inpatient consult requests
2. On paper, we also had an Attending on call but the Chief had to beg them to take the consult and, of course, they could always say no.
3. If they refused, the Chief would go down the list of attendings and beg each one to staff the consult until one of them consented. As with most things in life, it is generally the most junior people who were handed the short-end of the stick.
4. Whichever Resident was attached to that attending was responsible for staffing the consult

Recently, I understand that my residency now has an inpatient consult service so I think the above old school model is now void.
My residency had this system as well, including the begging.
 
many programs now have an APP that handles inpatient consults; there is also an attending “doctor of the day” to okay their work


Seth Meyers Lol GIF by Late Night with Seth Meyers
 
Percentage of inpatients treated alive at 60-90 days? Someone should do that study across institutions and see what pans out

We used to do a few every year, ambulanced out to our center a few blocks from the major hospital in town and it felt like the mortality was 100% 4-6 weeks out

one thing though - in a situation like you are in you are only bringing the people who need emergent emergent treatment over. in many hospitals since it is easy for us we have more inpatients we are brining down and treating, not just those on death's door. so it's biased by selection in your setting a bit
 
Where I trained was unique. From 8:00-5:00, an attending was assigned doc of the day. Them and their resident covered inpatient consults. After hours and weekends went to the on call resident. If the doc of the day didn’t have a resident on their service, it was assigned (in advance) to a resident who was not in clinic that day. This arrangement made life way more predictable for us as residents than any other system I’ve seen.

Both places I’ve worked since had systems like what GFunk described. If you have a conscience, it looks even worse from the attending perspective. It shouldn’t be up to the resident to find an attending to do their job.
 
. If you have a conscience, it looks even worse from the attending perspective. It shouldn’t be up to the resident to find an attending to do their job.
💯
Attendings get paid to do their job (and bring revenue to the Dept)



(Edit: and to be honest, this one of the things that pissed me off about the peak rad onc era. The idea that every pt had to be seen by a resident and scut etc flowed downhill, now it's a very different story in many places I bet).
 
Last edited:
You guys are jogging my memory back to a distant point in time when I was checking out rad onc residencies and the Vanderbilt Rad Onc page used to state this:

The primary focus of the Radiation Oncology Residency Training Program is education in radiation medicine including oncology, tissue ablation, benign diseases and intravascular brachytherapy. The secondary goal is training in cancer research. The residents will be trained in tumor biology, physiology and the study of novel targets for cancer treatment. The residents will not be considered providers of service to Radiation Oncologists or any other attendings at Vanderbilt University. The residents will be considered trainees and not service providers. This is especially exemplified at Vanderbilt University where the Radiation Oncology attendings presently provide all of the service to referring physicians and patients. Therefore, our workload is presently structured so that the attendings are considered the service providers.

Oh those were the days. My sneaky suspicion back then was that Hallahan was trying to make the program look super desirable to med students.

FWIW, I think that the education in "oncology, tissue ablation, benign diseases and intravascular brachytherapy" went a little sigogglin' as they say in Tennessee. We get called to do tissue ablation... never? Benign disease, and fetch, keep trying to happen; fetch seems like a safer bet. And how 'bout that intravascular brachy. Some day in the not so distant future there will be as many cervical brachy cases in a day in the US as vascular brachy cases 😉
 
Some day in the not so distant future there will be as many cervical brachy cases in a day in the US as vascular brachy cases 😉
ummm, no. Vaccine skepticism and access issues for the highest risk SES are making cervical cancer great again. I suspect places with the right patient mix will see it soon(ish). Urban centers like mine? No chance.

💯
Attendings get paid to do their job (and bring revenue to the Dept)
The biggest red flag to me are the people that throw a tantrum about going uncovered. With the exception of very good senior residents, if you think having a resident makes your job easier, you are only kind of doing your job.
 
You guys are jogging my memory back to a distant point in time when I was checking out rad onc residencies and the Vanderbilt Rad Onc page used to state this:

The primary focus of the Radiation Oncology Residency Training Program is education in radiation medicine including oncology, tissue ablation, benign diseases and intravascular brachytherapy. The secondary goal is training in cancer research. The residents will be trained in tumor biology, physiology and the study of novel targets for cancer treatment. The residents will not be considered providers of service to Radiation Oncologists or any other attendings at Vanderbilt University. The residents will be considered trainees and not service providers. This is especially exemplified at Vanderbilt University where the Radiation Oncology attendings presently provide all of the service to referring physicians and patients. Therefore, our workload is presently structured so that the attendings are considered the service providers.

Oh those were the days. My sneaky suspicion back then was that Hallahan was trying to make the program look super desirable to med students.

FWIW, I think that the education in "oncology, tissue ablation, benign diseases and intravascular brachytherapy" went a little sigogglin' as they say in Tennessee. We get called to do tissue ablation... never? Benign disease, and fetch, keep trying to happen; fetch seems like a safer bet. And how 'bout that intravascular brachy. Some day in the not so distant future there will be as many cervical brachy cases in a day in the US as vascular brachy cases 😉
Well “ablation” is now allowed to come with a 30% local failure rate at least per BR-002 so maybe we have been “ablating” everything all along?
 
Well “ablation” is now allowed to come with a 30% local failure rate at least per BR-002 so maybe we have been “ablating” everything all along?
Yeah what was with that? So strange and unexpected. Really need the fine details there to better understand that.
 
Yeah what was with that? So strange and unexpected. Really need the fine details there to better understand that.
So “unexpected”? MISSILE had a ~40% lack of local control. Sure we can poop on MISSILE's pCR measurement methods. I just don’t think we should be shocked with 20-30% local failure rates especially given what I suspect is alpha beta heterogeneity amongst breast cancer metastases (ie SABR almost can become dose de-escalation with higher alpha beta... and as we know we don't measure alpha beta before irradiating patients so we really don't ever have any idea what a specific Rx will provide in terms of LC probability for any given SPECIFIC patient).*

But specifically for NRG BR002 the PFS was 70%, and PFS *does not* equal local control. (And by definition PFS will always be worse/equal, but never better, than LC.**) A drop on a KM graph of PFS represents either a death **OR** a local failure or a progression (and a censor, i.e. the graph line keeps running out horizontally, means the patient was both alive and non-progressed). So be careful not to conflate LC and PFS.

AND BEYOND ALL THAT... arguing about PFS in NRG BR002 misses the plot imho. SABR is never really going to be sensible here unless there is an OS effect.

* The mean salary for a Miami Heat player is $2m; about 3 people on the team make more than that and about 12 people make less. If you joined the Miami Heat it would likely be incorrect to guess you'd make $2m a year even though the data would suggest you would.

** 100 people get lung cancer. We irradiate all 100 with SABR. We have all 100 patients get a PET 3 months later; everyone is deemed to be locally controlled. The next day all 100 get on a plane and it crashes. The local control for the group will be 100% one billion years from now; the overall survival, and progression free survival, is 0% today (and one billion years from now). This is why PFS is a better measure than LC.
 
Last edited:
Let's try to stay.... somewhat on topic, folks.

In residency the inpatient consults 8-5 were automatically assigned by the chair to the attending (inpatient consults were spilt up between the attendings available in clinic), who would then have their service resident be involved. Consults outside of that were staffed by resident on call and attending on call. Can't speak to # of consults per day

Now, the inpt service has a NP who covers from 8-5 and staffs inpatient consults with that day's inpatient attending or, as necessary, the assigned doc of the day. Consults received outside of tha titme frame are covered by resident on call and either doc of the day or the on-call doc for the week, depending on urgency.
 
Let's try to stay.... somewhat on topic, folks.

In residency the inpatient consults 8-5 were automatically assigned by the chair to the attending (inpatient consults were spilt up between the attendings available in clinic), who would then have their service resident be involved. Consults outside of that were staffed by resident on call and attending on call. Can't speak to # of consults per day

Now, the inpt service has a NP who covers from 8-5 and staffs inpatient consults with that day's inpatient attending or, as necessary, the assigned doc of the day. Consults received outside of tha titme frame are covered by resident on call and either doc of the day or the on-call doc for the week, depending on urgency.
That is a chair with a lot of time on their hands! In every department I've worked in, inpatients were either assigned by the resident on call or the doc of the day.

Also why not spin off a thread about when an ablation is not really an ablation? Many such cases. Call it "Ceci n'est pas une ablation"
 
Last edited:
Resident from 2015-2019
Residents and attendings were on call one week at a time, PGY2s had a few months before call started
Residents would get the consult then find an attending to staff it. Unfortunately it was rare the resident and attending were paired together
It was like pulling teeth to get them to do the consult, maybe slightly better PGY4-5 when we could do most things ourselves
Just a huge PITA
None of the attendings had any spine to pushback on ridiculous unncessary consults either, that was the most frustrating part
Someone went in on Easter to treat an HO once - pathetic
 
Chief Resident carried day time pager for 6 months. Got all daytime calls, and doled them out to fellow residents based on disease site and who was available.

Tried to keep breast primaries with breast service, prostate with GU, brain mets with neuro, etc....

Lot's of post-op day zero "consults" just to get an outpatient appointment after discharge.

Consult Note:
Patient still intubated. Acute post-op care per primary surgical team. Radiation recommendations to be determined by final pathology. Patient's family and RN given appointment card to be included in discharge paperwork. Follow up scheduled for DATE/TIME.

That's it. Spend no more time on those.
 
That is a chair with a lot of time on their hands! In every department I've worked in, inpatients were either assigned by the resident on call or the doc of the day.

Also why not spin off a thread about when an ablation is not really an ablation? Many such cases. Call it "Ceci n'est pas une ablation"

Bolded sounds like a great idea - Feel free to start the thread
 
2016-2020

On call resident fielded all inpatient consults during business hours and routed to the appropriate service (eg. SCLC went to lung attending/resident, breast mets went to breast attending/resident). After hours/weekends the on call person took everything. We always tried to go over the case with the attending, but more often than not just ended up making recs ourselves because the attendings didn't want to be bothered.