-
CycleTrack and SDN are teaming up to make medical school admissions more transparent and accessible! Read the announcement to learn how we’re supporting the future of CycleTrack’s free application-tracking tools .
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
AI threat to rad onc
Started by DrProtonX
Get help with your application
Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.
Rads at 96%. They can't find enough of them. Not worried about rads at allView attachment 426613
“62% subsitutable by AI” … what do you guys think? Is future of rad onc in danger?
Our undoing will be the oversupplied job market not AI
So 62% of radiation oncology payments are classified as "nonphysical," and therefore 62% of our specialty is potentially replaceable by AI? That's quite the intellectual leap, even by SDN standards. AI will absolutely (and already has, in some cases) automate substantial portions of our workflow. Contouring, treatment planning, documentation, image review, plan QA, etc. Frankly, bring it on. I didn't spend half my adult life in training to spend my days drawing parotid glands and clicking through MOSAIQ.
But there's a rather significant difference between automating a task and replacing the physician responsible for the clinical decisions. Someone still has to decide whether the patient should receive radiation in the first place, what to treat, what not to treat, how to balance competing risks, and what to do when the patient has already received three courses of radiation and the spinal cord has approximately 0.2 Gy of remaining tolerance. The legitimate concern is economic. If AI allows one RO to do the work previously requiring two, that has obvious implications for physician demand and compensation. Pretending otherwise would be foolish.
That said, I'd still rank CMS reimbursement, hypofractionation, payer shenanigans, and our profession's remarkable enthusiasm for producing more graduates than available jobs considerably higher on my list of existential threats.
But there's a rather significant difference between automating a task and replacing the physician responsible for the clinical decisions. Someone still has to decide whether the patient should receive radiation in the first place, what to treat, what not to treat, how to balance competing risks, and what to do when the patient has already received three courses of radiation and the spinal cord has approximately 0.2 Gy of remaining tolerance. The legitimate concern is economic. If AI allows one RO to do the work previously requiring two, that has obvious implications for physician demand and compensation. Pretending otherwise would be foolish.
That said, I'd still rank CMS reimbursement, hypofractionation, payer shenanigans, and our profession's remarkable enthusiasm for producing more graduates than available jobs considerably higher on my list of existential threats.
Mind the gap
Funny enough if you think about it if we had not gone to computerized planning and were still using china markers on films and spending an hour or more in the simulator for each sim and hand drawing blocks ... we'd be A.I. untouchable. In fact, now that I think about it, a pure benign RT practice could be A.I. untouchable if it wanted to set itself up to be so, and the plan and RT quality would be totally fine. A pure brachy practice would be pretty A.I. untouchable.So 62% of radiation oncology payments are classified as "nonphysical," and therefore 62% of our specialty is potentially replaceable by AI? That's quite the intellectual leap, even by SDN standards. AI will absolutely (and already has, in some cases) automate substantial portions of our workflow. Contouring, treatment planning, documentation, image review, plan QA, etc. Frankly, bring it on. I didn't spend half my adult life in training to spend my days drawing parotid glands and clicking through MOSAIQ.
But there's a rather significant difference between automating a task and replacing the physician responsible for the clinical decisions. Someone still has to decide whether the patient should receive radiation in the first place, what to treat, what not to treat, how to balance competing risks, and what to do when the patient has already received three courses of radiation and the spinal cord has approximately 0.2 Gy of remaining tolerance. The legitimate concern is economic. If AI allows one RO to do the work previously requiring two, that has obvious implications for physician demand and compensation. Pretending otherwise would be foolish.
That said, I'd still rank CMS reimbursement, hypofractionation, payer shenanigans, and our profession's remarkable enthusiasm for producing more graduates than available jobs considerably higher on my list of existential threats.
FletchersGarb
Full Member
Diagnostic Rads will be an example to watch; AI assist is going well for them, but perhaps inflection will come sooner than people realize
Still will need a doc to sign off on readsDiagnostic Rads will be an example to watch; AI assist is going well for them, but perhaps inflection will come sooner than people realize
This graph also has a substantial problem in terms of discounting hospital technical, which theoretically is entirely AI immune because you need a human to at least generally supervise. And that would arguably be the biggest chunk of national Medicare rad onc spend overall.Still will need a doc to sign off on reads
The table is obviously not complete.
I do wonder however, how the jobs of
- intensive care physicians
- oncologists
- infectiologists
will change, just to name a few.
Yes, ICU physicians still have to do all the manual stuff, like inserting tubes and so on. But alot of their medical decisions, esp. concerning circulation and ventilation are exactly the stuff that AI can perform in an excellent manner. The ICU is the optimal enviroment for that: an ICU is monitored more than any other patient 24/7 and all those values are there. Wouldn't AI do a better job than an ICU doctor in deciding stuff like: "should we lover O2 today", " what dose of catecholamines does the patient need today", etc.
Yes, oncologists still have to talk to patients and so on (pretty much like we have to do), and may do an actual procedure now and then, like a bone marrow biopsy. But wouldn't AI make a better judgement on what drug to propose as next line of treatment or what dose, having access to all the molecular, pathology, radiology data and the patient's lab values. No, if the nurse has actually put in the patients CTCAE toxicities in a chart, or (God forbid!) the patient has actually done that from home on his phone with the PROMs-app, who is actually making decisions?
Yes, infectiologists still have to go on rounds and discuss with the internal medicine physicians about the patients. But, can't AI actually judge better, what antibiotics a patient needs, based on all the lab values, antibiograms and vital parameters, which are all on the EMR?
I do wonder however, how the jobs of
- intensive care physicians
- oncologists
- infectiologists
will change, just to name a few.
Yes, ICU physicians still have to do all the manual stuff, like inserting tubes and so on. But alot of their medical decisions, esp. concerning circulation and ventilation are exactly the stuff that AI can perform in an excellent manner. The ICU is the optimal enviroment for that: an ICU is monitored more than any other patient 24/7 and all those values are there. Wouldn't AI do a better job than an ICU doctor in deciding stuff like: "should we lover O2 today", " what dose of catecholamines does the patient need today", etc.
Yes, oncologists still have to talk to patients and so on (pretty much like we have to do), and may do an actual procedure now and then, like a bone marrow biopsy. But wouldn't AI make a better judgement on what drug to propose as next line of treatment or what dose, having access to all the molecular, pathology, radiology data and the patient's lab values. No, if the nurse has actually put in the patients CTCAE toxicities in a chart, or (God forbid!) the patient has actually done that from home on his phone with the PROMs-app, who is actually making decisions?
Yes, infectiologists still have to go on rounds and discuss with the internal medicine physicians about the patients. But, can't AI actually judge better, what antibiotics a patient needs, based on all the lab values, antibiograms and vital parameters, which are all on the EMR?
The USMLE literally can’t write a question AI gets wrong last I heardThe table is obviously not complete.
I do wonder however, how the jobs of
- intensive care physicians
- oncologists
- infectiologists
will change, just to name a few.
Yes, ICU physicians still have to do all the manual stuff, like inserting tubes and so on. But alot of their medical decisions, esp. concerning circulation and ventilation are exactly the stuff that AI can perform in an excellent manner. The ICU is the optimal enviroment for that: an ICU is monitored more than any other patient 24/7 and all those values are there. Wouldn't AI do a better job than an ICU doctor in deciding stuff like: "should we lover O2 today", " what dose of catecholamines does the patient need today", etc.
Yes, oncologists still have to talk to patients and so on (pretty much like we have to do), and may do an actual procedure now and then, like a bone marrow biopsy. But wouldn't AI make a better judgement on what drug to propose as next line of treatment or what dose, having access to all the molecular, pathology, radiology data and the patient's lab values. No, if the nurse has actually put in the patients CTCAE toxicities in a chart, or (God forbid!) the patient has actually done that from home on his phone with the PROMs-app, who is actually making decisions?
Yes, infectiologists still have to go on rounds and discuss with the internal medicine physicians about the patients. But, can't AI actually judge better, what antibiotics a patient needs, based on all the lab values, antibiograms and vital parameters, which are all on the EMR?
Electrons, my friend. Electrons are still A.I.-untouchable.Funny enough if you think about it if we had not gone to computerized planning and were still using china markers on films and spending an hour or more in the simulator for each sim and hand drawing blocks ... we'd be A.I. untouchable. In fact, now that I think about it, a pure benign RT practice could be A.I. untouchable if it wanted to set itself up to be so, and the plan and RT quality would be totally fine. A pure brachy practice would be pretty A.I. untouchable.
Noone really knows where electrons land and what dose they deliver. It's one of life's mysteries.
In my opinion, distrust is what essentially all physicians have in their corner. I suspect it will be the better part of most of our careers before the general public will accept truly autonomous AI for health care, even if it were capable.
Agree with GFunk that AI to this point has made my life easier. Are AI generated contours perfect? Nope. I have yet to meet one that can reliable distinguish between bowel and pelvic vessels on a non contrasted scan. But are they close enough for a simple prostate plan? Absolutely. Even for an N+ case, I’m just tweaking the AI normal tissues instead of starting from scratch.
Agree with GFunk that AI to this point has made my life easier. Are AI generated contours perfect? Nope. I have yet to meet one that can reliable distinguish between bowel and pelvic vessels on a non contrasted scan. But are they close enough for a simple prostate plan? Absolutely. Even for an N+ case, I’m just tweaking the AI normal tissues instead of starting from scratch.
A study that puts the radonc market at $1.2B when 21C was doing $1B per year in annual revenue at its peak a decade ago is very not serious.
it's just medicare part b spending. that number sounds accurate to me.
In my opinion, distrust is what essentially all physicians have in their corner. I suspect it will be the better part of most of our careers before the general public will accept truly autonomous AI for health care, even if it were capable.
Agree with GFunk that AI to this point has made my life easier. Are AI generated contours perfect? Nope. I have yet to meet one that can reliable distinguish between bowel and pelvic vessels on a non contrasted scan. But are they close enough for a simple prostate plan? Absolutely. Even for an N+ case, I’m just tweaking the AI normal tissues instead of starting from scratch.
bowel awful.
if you do a ton of abdominal sbrt it matters and it's such a time sink. hope it gets better
So breathless
Getting better and will exceed us
But not today!
Getting better and will exceed us
But not today!
Eh, I just fix the contour where it abuts the PTV and can impact the plan, otherwise I don't care. An even tighter contour ring if you will.bowel awful.
if you do a ton of abdominal sbrt it matters and it's such a time sink. hope it gets better
It depends on how complex it is. For isolated nodes which will be pretty conformal, just having to tweak around the PTV is still a win. For something like pancreatic SBRT where you really push the conformality against abutting structures and you know there will be high dose streaks…way less helpful. For those I delete all bowel AI contours and do them myself.bowel awful.
if you do a ton of abdominal sbrt it matters and it's such a time sink. hope it gets better
breath hold is a way better solution than AI.Sure agree just the part by the high dose PTV but still it’s an annoying task IMO esp if there a lot of bowel motion near tumor and you want to account for it
I am the biggest radonc doomer here and not worried about ai per se. more concerned about remote docs covering multiple centers.
I am the biggest radonc doomer here and not worried about ai per se. more concerned about remote docs covering multiple centers.
Diabolical genius… lol
Sounds like some of the rads reads I've seen over the yearsOn a related note, today my physicist wanted to show me the Brainlab Elements autocontour software for brain mets. Of the three mets in my patient, it got one exactly right, missed a slice on another, and missed the third met entirely.