Ok I am currently a medical master at EVMS, and I interview for the MD program tomorrow actually. The post bac program here at EVMS is unlike any other in the nation. Most post bac programs are cash cows where they accept 150 people into the program, and then MAYBE except 10 into their medical program the following year. Here they accept a max of 20 into the post bac program, and then accept pretty much everyone that did well. Dr. Meyer may have come off rude to you, but honestly its not rude you are just nieve. And sorry if that sounds rude but I wish someone had slapped me around 3 years ago and told me the same thing. You have to realize most medical schools have ten to fifteen applicants for each spot, and everyone has different great experiences to brag about. So when it comes down to it, its so competitive they have to look at the numbers. If you scored lower than a 27 on the MCAT and don't have higher than a 3.7 GPA, why are they going to accept you over the 1000 other people with 30's or higher on the MCAT and 3.5's or higher on their GPA. EVMS is notorious for trying to look past the numbers and choosing people based on the interview and past experience, BUT it's getting more and more competetive. Two years ago when I first applied the average accepted MCAT was 27, now its a 29. I have a 31 on the MCAT and I made a 3.3 in an engineering degree, and this is my third time to apply to medical school, so you think you're frustrated?
OK now that i'm done tryin to scare you, the EVMS program is a good program if you are willing to bust your ass. Its not like other post bac's where you take undergrad courses like organic and biology. You will be taking the ACTUAL first year of medical school minus anatomy and the patient interaction classes. You will be sitting in class with the actual first year medical students, and you will take the exact same tests as the first year medical students. You are expected to outperform the medical school average to prove you are worthy of a spot for next year, and when you are competing against a 100 really bright students with phenomenal grades in undergrad, its very hard to do. The people that are accepted to this post bac program and don't get in to the medical program are people who A) made a C or did below average in any class, or B) doesn't get along with others and did bad on the interview.
Anyway sorry i wrote a novel, this is a huge decision and i just wanta help you out because i wasn in your shoes a year ago...It is a huge gamble but if you have the drive to work your ass off and beat the med school average, it will get you accepted to EVMS. If your MCAT is lower than 27 and or your GPA is lower than a 3.4, a post bac program is probably your only choice. Either that the caribbean or an osteopathic school.
Oh and the reason they look at numbers more now is we got a new dean, and he's more traditional. He wants the top students from the top colleges, just like other med schools. Sucks I know