Greetings I am from the vet forum; also spend time on Podiatric medical forum (because they have great topics), but this one is good as well. My mom just finished with her transitional DPT and introduces herself as Kathy ****, physical therapy doctor. Some clients call her doctor and so do some of her co-workers and our dentist, and family doctor (who is a DO), all call her doctor. Any professional that earns the highest academic degree within their field of study should be able to call themselves doctor (I am no promoter of communism either). I know most people think: "Who cares if it is tradition to only call MDs doctor...too bad....everyone else works very hard for their academic degree and deserves the title as well"; let the MDs say "hi I'm Dr. X, medical doctor", or DPMs say "I'm Dr. X, podiatric medical doctor, or Ph.D Div. say "I'm Dr. X, Doctor of theology". I agree that many, including the AMA needs to give credit where credit is due and realize these newer or improved professionals are highly trained and provide an element of healthcare that MDs have over-looked or deemed not important. I don't agree that MDs should be MADE to embrace these newly trained medical professionals with open arms, and if they want to keep things seperate that is fine with many folks. Here is the flip side, MDs and the AMA however need to understand that if a group of DCs or DPTs want to get together to open up a physical/preventative health clinic and they want to call themselves "doctors" they should have that right to do so (don't try to control me and I won't try to control you; have respect for me and I will for you, simple, seperate, and autonomous). To say you are a doctor does not mean you are equall to the training of medical doctors, but if you are a DO, or DPM you should be able to say you are a medical doctor (DPMs are in a debate with this now); however I think we all understand where MDs are comming from when they say it confuses people for a DPT to call themselves doctor in a hospital setting, because the "average Jo" thinks they are a medical doctor. Personally I respect people's traditions, and if the MDs and lay people only want to allow themselves to think medical doctors are "doctors" that is fine with me, especially when working in a hospital (where medical doctors are the traditional doctors). I think when other un-equally trained medical professionals (excluding DOs, DPMs, perhaps some DMDs) like DCs, DPTs, PsyD, and others are working in a hospital they (at least till things change, or a compromise is reached) should say what type of "doctor they are" so they will not confuse the lay person; but remember that when an MD steps into the DPT/DC clinic he/she will have to introduce themselves as Dr. X, medical doctor (it is elite to think people should just assume). Sorry for going off into this side note, but I just want to bring in another comparison: this is the same problem we are facing in our cultural war in the USA and medicine is part of it. Every day we see one group of people trying to control another. Everyday we see: debates on legal drug use, gay rights, appropriate ethnic slang, music lyrics, illegal immigration, liberals, conservatives, environment, religion....WOW! Did anyone ever think that is why we have so many world religions, cultures, slangs countries, ect in the first place. People should not think they are better than the next person and they have to stop trying to control eveything. People work best when they are seperated into groups that think and act like themselves, but at the same time have respect for the people in the next group who are different. There is no need to make one group think like the other or control them, every thing should be seperate but work as a whole and healthcare is no exception. My advise to new DPTs is, don't ram "DPT doctor" down the MD's esophagus. When you are in their hospitals say you are a physical therapy doctor, but don't let MDs control you and pass elite laws that say you can't open your own clinic and simply call yourself doctor, plus make them say "hi I'm Dr. X, medical doctor when in your clinic. In the dark ages France and England would fight at every availabe event. To say France was better than England, or vise-versa is bogus! Both have remained seperate through history and should hold their identity, but because they have more respect these days for one another they can both work seperate (in their own way) to achieve a better Europe. Perhaps this notion can be developed in healthcare (as well as other parts of culture) and understanding will result, but a seperate, cooperative and respecting identity is the key. I don't want to be like you, you don't have to be like me, don't try to control me, and I will not control you, but when the time calls for it, lets work together to get the job done! Sorry for the long post! Going mad waiting for accept/reject letter from vet school. 😳
Mountain Man