Graduate school --> MD advice

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

wildcatfan1404

New Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I am a graduating college senior and have the opportunity to go on scholarship to Cambridge to do a PhD in chemical engineering (biomedical research). This is typically a 3.5 year program with little standard deviation. I also have been fortunate enough to get into the MSE in Biomedical Engineering at John's Hopkins (2 years), which will also be funded. I am interested in pursuing a career as a physician-engineer, operating between pure clinical practice and pure engineering/technology development. I am drawn by both these opportunities, but find the Cambridge scholarship particularly hard to turn down. However, I am concerned that having a PhD might actually hurt me when I apply to medical school. Can anyone provide perspective on this? Any advice, direct or peripheral, is appreciated. In particular, are there steps I can take to not make myself look like a disillusioned graduate student when applying to medical school?

Other details:
High GPA
Will finish premed requirements before metriculation into graduate school
Have not taken the MCAT, but will take it this summer or in graduate school
No hospital/shadowing experience as of yet
 
Why do you think having a PhD hurt you during the med school admissions process?
 
However, I am concerned that having a PhD might actually hurt me when I apply to medical school. Can anyone provide perspective on this? Any advice, direct or peripheral, is appreciated. In particular, are there steps I can take to not make myself look like a disillusioned graduate student when applying to medical school?

I doubt a PhD in a health related field will hinder you that much, but perhaps you should look into combined PhD/MD programs, which MD schools offer and thus obviously don't hold against you.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I am a graduating college senior and have the opportunity to go on scholarship to Cambridge to do a PhD in chemical engineering (biomedical research). This is typically a 3.5 year program with little standard deviation. I also have been fortunate enough to get into the MSE in Biomedical Engineering at John's Hopkins (2 years), which will also be funded. I am interested in pursuing a career as a physician-engineer, operating between pure clinical practice and pure engineering/technology development. I am drawn by both these opportunities, but find the Cambridge scholarship particularly hard to turn down. However, I am concerned that having a PhD might actually hurt me when I apply to medical school. Can anyone provide perspective on this? Any advice, direct or peripheral, is appreciated. In particular, are there steps I can take to not make myself look like a disillusioned graduate student when applying to medical school?

Other details:
High GPA
Will finish premed requirements before metriculation into graduate school
Have not taken the MCAT, but will take it this summer or in graduate school
No hospital/shadowing experience as of yet
I'm a PhD now in medical school, and there are plenty of others. Getting a PhD won't make up for a poor UG record, but it doesn't sound like that's an issue for you. As long as you graduate with your PhD, publish your work, and get a good LOR from your PI, I can't think of any reason why having a PhD would hurt you in the app process. You should also make sure to get clinical experience while you're in grad school, because not having that *will* hurt you. Ditto for not doing well on the MCAT. :luck: to you. 🙂
 
It sounds like you'd be a competitive candidate for the MD/PhD programs out there. If you are really interested in both medicine and research, paying for medical school or for a masters degree at Hopkins seems like an unnecessary step when the combined programs are free and usually with a nice stipend.

A word to the wise: A Ph.D. program is not for the lukewarm. In my opinion, the stress and motivation needed to complete a Ph.D. with publishable data far exceeds what medical school will do to you, so go into it with your eyes wide open and ask many people who have experienced both.

I echo was QofQuimica says. A good MCAT score will get you where you need to be and a Ph.D. should help in medical school admissions, but it's neither a huge advantage nor an obstacle to admission.

Good luck!