A question for all of the past interviewees

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

separker

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2013
Messages
21
Reaction score
0
So one of the clubs at my schools likes to hold mock interviews – as if we we’re at an interview at a med school. All of the questions seemed pretty simple so this got me thinking – what’s the oddest question you we’re asked in an interview, maybe one that tripped you up or something?
 
What's your greatest weakness. Wasn't peppered for it. Stumbled.

I know a school that asks you what type of cell you would be.
 
How will the Affordable Care Act affect the way you practice medicine in ten years?
This was part of what I'm pretty sure was a stress interview 🙄 However, I do think it's a good idea to be able to talk about current healthcare policies at least in general terms.

one of my friends got asked to explain the Big Bang...
 
How will the Affordable Care Act affect the way you practice medicine in ten years?
This was part of what I'm pretty sure was a stress interview 🙄 However, I do think it's a good idea to be able to talk about current healthcare policies at least in general terms.

one of my friends got asked to explain the Big Bang...

There is this TV show... It has Sheldon, Leonard, and don't forget about Penny! They do stuff that nerds and geeks do, and they make fun of the one non-nerd that is in the group. I laugh a lot at the jokes, but my non-nerd friends don't get them. They see me laugh and wonder why...

That would be an EPIC response to the question. Ha ha.

Actually, the only time I had any tough or difficult questions was in a "mock interview" situation put on by a pre-osteopathic club in my area. I think the question that I disliked the most was "is healthcare a right or a privilege? Explain your answer."

My real interviews were all rather chill. Even the MMI stations at UA Phoenix and OHSU.

dsoz
 
There is this TV show... It has Sheldon, Leonard, and don't forget about Penny! They do stuff that nerds and geeks do, and they make fun of the one non-nerd that is in the group. I laugh a lot at the jokes, but my non-nerd friends don't get them. They see me laugh and wonder why...

That would be an EPIC response to the question. Ha ha.

Nice one... Bazinga!

To the OP, the questions regarding ACA are pretty common.
 
Biggest regret in your life and what you learned from it. Actually I had a prepared answer because of the interview feedback section, but if I didn't I would've stumbled.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
"What are your two greatest weaknesses?"

I was prepared to discuss my greatest weakness, but I completely froze when trying to bring up another one in the spot. So when preparing for interviews, it may be good to have 3 weaknesses and 3 strengths in mind.


Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile
 
Nice one... Bazinga!

To the OP, the questions regarding ACA are pretty common.

They're not as common as mock interviews make you think. I had like 5-6 mock interviews before I started interviewing, and each one really drilled ACA and healthcare policy questions. I interviewed at 8 schools, each with multiple interviewers, and I was never asked anything remotely political in nature. I know n=1, but still, I was expecting at least one ACA/politically-geared question in my real interviews. You should still be prepared and know some facts though 😀
 
The toughest question that I encountered was to describe a previous weakness, and explain what I did to correct it. I had never thought about my past weaknesses or anything like that, so needless to say the BSing commenced.
 
What's your greatest weakness. Wasn't peppered for it. Stumbled.

I know a school that asks you what type of cell you would be.
haha epic on the what type of cell....jeez I don't know what i'd say

How will the Affordable Care Act affect the way you practice medicine in ten years?
This was part of what I'm pretty sure was a stress interview 🙄 However, I do think it's a good idea to be able to talk about current healthcare policies at least in general terms.

one of my friends got asked to explain the Big Bang...
eww to the stress interview...but kinda awesome with the Big Bang question

There is this TV show... It has Sheldon, Leonard, and don't forget about Penny! They do stuff that nerds and geeks do, and they make fun of the one non-nerd that is in the group. I laugh a lot at the jokes, but my non-nerd friends don't get them. They see me laugh and wonder why...

That would be an EPIC response to the question. Ha ha.

Actually, the only time I had any tough or difficult questions was in a "mock interview" situation put on by a pre-osteopathic club in my area. I think the question that I disliked the most was "is healthcare a right or a privilege? Explain your answer."

My real interviews were all rather chill. Even the MMI stations at UA Phoenix and OHSU.

dsoz
👍


Biggest regret in your life and what you learned from it. Actually I had a prepared answer because of the interview feedback section, but if I didn't I would've stumbled.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
everyone says I should be prepared for that one...what was your general response if you don't mind me asking?

"What are your two greatest weaknesses?"

I was prepared to discuss my greatest weakness, but I completely froze when trying to bring up another one in the spot. So when preparing for interviews, it may be good to have 3 weaknesses and 3 strengths in mind.


Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile
freezing...my biggest fear
 
I got asked why medicine and then followed immediately by "what's you favorite scene from a movie?"

It caught me completely off guard.
 
everyone says I should be prepared for that one...what was your general response if you don't mind me asking?

I think it's a question thats designed to see what you value. I answered it truthfully with a personal life event rather than something like dang I wish I studied more for that class 😛
 
I got asked "What type of animal would you be"

Answer: That squirrel from Ice Age, because he isn't the smartest of the group but he is persistent and nothing will stop him from getting to that nut.

Survivor DO
 
I'm from a small town that's known for wilderness activities, and one of my interviewers asked me about fishing on a nearby lake. Another interviewer asked me how I would go about minimizing cigarette sales in the US.
 
I got asked "What type of animal would you be"

Answer: That squirrel from Ice Age, because he isn't the smartest of the group but he is persistent and nothing will stop him from getting to that nut.

Survivor DO
hahaha nice!

I got asked why medicine and then followed immediately by "what's you favorite scene from a movie?"

It caught me completely off guard.

oh dear....please tell me your response🙂
 
"Design a healthcare plan specifically for the region of (where med school is located) and be specific"...:lame: I remember sitting there wondering what in the world is going to come out of my mouth next....
 
"Design a healthcare plan specifically for the region of (where med school is located) and be specific"...:lame: I remember sitting there wondering what in the world is going to come out of my mouth next....

😱 where the heck was this??
 
Give me an example of a time you gave someone advice and it didn't work out for them. How did that effect you and how did that effect the other party.
 
What was your greatest failure?

What do you think about the practice of "defensive medicine"?
 
Give me an example of a time you gave someone advice and it didn't work out for them. How did that effect you and how did that effect the other party.

Haha I remember seeing that in some schools interview feedback and I was like please don't ask me that....
 
An interviewer asked me since I was involved with boy scouts in high school and the boy scouts have gotten a lot of press lately for not supporting gay scouts, if I had any worries about serving diverse patient populations that might be different than me..😕 I went on a nervous rant about how one of my roommates and best friends is gay... End result was accepted!

But my point is some interviewers will just ask you the textbook questions while others will ask you questions you can never be prepared for. My prep technique was preparing for many categories of questions using a book called "The Medical School Interview: Secrets and a System for Success"
 
If you could have dinner with any 3 people, dead or alive, who would it be?
Interesting question right? I said Obama, Tesla, and Newton.

Interviewer with a blank face "Why not your parents?"
I say: I have dinner with them every night...
Interviewer: "So?"
Me: 😕
 
Random: As we we're discussing something completely unrelated, he interjects, "Describe how the kidney functions." Apropos of nothing.

Hardest: "What's your worst vice?" Probably the one question of all my interviews that truly stumped me. I mean, I knew the real answer immediately, but I sure as hell wasn't gonna say that (in a panel interview, no less).
 
Lotta interviews but never a really weird question. I would say something like: "If you could be any character from a book who would you choose?"
 
If you could have dinner with any 3 people, dead or alive, who would it be?
Interesting question right? I said Obama, Tesla, and Newton.

Interviewer with a blank face "Why not your parents?"
I say: I have dinner with them every night...
Interviewer: "So?"
Me: 😕
Hahaha I can just imagine...

Random: As we we're discussing something completely unrelated, he interjects, "Describe how the kidney functions." Apropos of nothing.

Hardest: "What's your worst vice?" Probably the one question of all my interviews that truly stumped me. I mean, I knew the real answer immediately, but I sure as hell wasn't gonna say that (in a panel interview, no less).
Both are pretty awesome questions in there own way - I'm so worried I'm going to get the random question thrown at me and completely draw a blank

"What question were you dreading the most that we didn't ask?"

Yeah...then they asked it.
:scared:...they really asked you...well we're you prepared?
 
"Describe a time that you witnessed unethical behavior in a clinical setting and tell me what you did about it (if anything)."

Besides the "tired two" (questions: why medicine? Why our school?), pretty much every interview [sans any mmi experiences] was an organic conversation with questions tactfully woven in at opportune moments.
 
Last edited:
I was asked in one interview what I thought about Lance Armstrong possibly (at the time it was still being discussed) getting his wins stripped for allegedly doping.

Then one of the interviewers went on and on about how a local chiropractor was a huge scam artist and getting really rich off it. 🙄
 
"What is your greatest weakness as a leader?"
I had thought about weaknesses, just not in a leadership context. Awkward!!!
 
Most of my interviewers asked me what I have been reading recently. I don't really read much, so this was tough to answer without sounding like an uncultured simpleton.
 
I got asked why medicine and then followed immediately by "what's you favorite scene from a movie?"

It caught me completely off guard.

OMG, best interview question of all time!!! Matrix interrogation scene for the effing win here!
 
Would you perform in vitro fertilization for dwarf parents to select for eggs that would produce dwarf children?
 
freezing...my biggest fear

Yea, it can be kind of scary. You just have to be able to recover from it. I admitted that I was drawing a blank, and she said, "Okay, we can come back to that later." The rest of the interview went very well, and I still had two other interviews at the school. It was my top choice, and I ended up getting accepted. So moral of the story - freezing and not having an answer will not always ruin you. Try to avoid it by preparing thoroughly though 🙂
 
Most of my interviewers asked me what I have been reading recently. I don't really read much, so this was tough to answer without sounding like an uncultured simpleton.

I got this one too. My answer was the eragon series. Yeah, I like teen fiction.
 
I was caught off guard when the first question I was asked at my first interview was "tell us about your high school," or something along those lines. I hadn't thought in a million years I would be asked about high school. It was an easy question, but I was so confused.
 
One that threw me off and shouldn't have was "tell me about yourself." I had gone over that question like a 1000x and I totally screwed it up :bang:

The other question that caught me off guard was "How do you think technology will affect the art of medicine?" I thought this was an interesting question and basically went with an answer directed at the difference between how the older generations practice medicine and how I think our generation will practice medicine incorporating things like Watson.
 
How do you plan to change the world? 😕:uhno:
 
all of these questions are freaking awesome!
 
My favorite question that I got (and expertly deflected) was:

"So, tell me about the research you've done."

Now, that may seem like a slam dunk question, but if you're like me, and had no research of any substance, things could have gotten a little awkward if I had to answer that one, but I segued it into sports without actually answering. Oh, and got accepted 😀
 
There are a lot of questions in this thread I am glad I didn't encounter..:laugh:

One of the hardest oddball questions I got was: "Are you more like your mother or your father and why?" At first it seemed easy but I had a hard time coming up with a coherent answer. The whole plane ride home I was thinking about it....
 
oh, another one that my friend got asked at Iowa: How would you get more people to become organ donors?
(Best answer to this: make organ donation opt-out instead of opt-in.)

Also, "I see your parents did x and y. Why don't you pursue x or y?" (this was probably because I had activities linked to x and y as some of my "top 3" activities for AMCAS.)
 
Strangest question I was asked was "Who would win in a fight....a silverback gorilla or a lion?". Crazy huh? I said gorilla and am now an M1 at this school! Haha!
 
If you could have dinner with any 3 people, dead or alive, who would it be?
Interesting question right? I said Obama, Tesla, and Newton.

Interviewer with a blank face "Why not your parents?"
I say: I have dinner with them every night...
Interviewer: "So?"
Me: 😕

LMFAO I just laughed so hard!
 
"What kitchen utensil would you be and why?"

Also, @ Permavirgin, if you said your parents he probably would've asked you why not someone famous like one of the ones you picked... :laugh:
 
Strangest question I was asked was "Who would win in a fight....a silverback gorilla or a lion?". Crazy huh? I said gorilla and am now an M1 at this school! Haha!

EPIC! :laugh:
 
So one of the clubs at my schools likes to hold mock interviews – as if we we're at an interview at a med school. All of the questions seemed pretty simple so this got me thinking – what's the oddest question you we're asked in an interview, maybe one that tripped you up or something?

I walk into the office shake hands and the interviewer starts with, "so what in the world was [she] doing in a canoe pregnant?" (The question stemmed from a story in one of my essays)

So I say, "well, I'm sure she'll never do that again and she was only in her first trimester."

Apparently he had read all my essays and activities because he follows up my answer with a story about a pregnant person dying after jumping out of a plane. Well if you read my app you would know that I jumped out of airplanes. He follows he story up with "anyone who jumps out of a perfectly good aircraft is crazy." And "we must be opposites."

He then asks the typical, why medicine question in an atypical manner. "Looking at your file, I'd have no idea you were applying to medical school, except for the fact that we are sitting in a medical school, so why medicine?"

When things are getting good he tells me, " my grandfather served in one of the wars..." At this point I start to think, finally! We have something in common.

Well, that thought was short lived because this is how he finished his statement, "and [my grandfather] taught me to avoid the military at all costs."

Sooo... He made lots of these kinds of statements that made many of my "good" activities seem totally bad and he rarely followed these statements up with a question.

Yep, that was my most difficult interview.
 
I walk into the office shake hands and the interviewer starts with, "so what in the world was [she] doing in a canoe pregnant?" (The question stemmed from a story in one of my essays)

So I say, "well, I'm sure she'll never do that again and she was only in her first trimester."

Apparently he had read all my essays and activities because he follows up my answer with a story about a pregnant person dying after jumping out of a plane. Well if you read my app you would know that I jumped out of airplanes. He follows he story up with "anyone who jumps out of a perfectly good aircraft is crazy." And "we must be opposites."

He then asks the typical, why medicine question in an atypical manner. "Looking at your file, I'd have no idea you were applying to medical school, except for the fact that we are sitting in a medical school, so why medicine?"

When things are getting good he tells me, " my grandfather served in one of the wars..." At this point I start to think, finally! We have something in common.

Well, that thought was short lived because this is how he finished his statement, "and [my grandfather] taught me to avoid the military at all costs."

Sooo... He made lots of these kinds of statements that made many of my "good" activities seem totally bad and he rarely followed these statements up with a question.

Yep, that was my most difficult interview.

You must have some pretty awesome experiences to be jumping out of airplanes (read the MDapps)! Did you hear back from that school? From my experiences, it's hard to tell whether you truly impressed your interviewer or not.
 
You must have some pretty awesome experiences to be jumping out of airplanes (read the MDapps)! Did you hear back from that school? From my experiences, it's hard to tell whether you truly impressed your interviewer or not.

Rejected, but I think I would have to ask the interviewer because the rejection could easily stem from my GPA more than anything.
 
Top