Aamc10 bs 124

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

eybc20

New Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2012
Messages
8
Reaction score
6
I have a question on #124 in the BS section, from the H. pylori passage.

Q: The ELISA is a test that is often used to detect antibodies to a particular organism. Would a positive result from such a test for H. pylori indicate the patient had an ulcer?

A) No, because the patient could have been exposed to H. pylori and eliminated it
C) Yes, because the patient must have cells of H. pylori present to produce antibodies

I narrowed it down to these two choices, but incorrectly chose C. I take some issue with the solution, because it seems to suggest that upon pathogen exposure, we are pumping our blood full of antibodies all the time, and a random ELISA will always pick up on this increased level of antibody production.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't the humoral/antibody response need to be triggered first by antigen presenting cells and helper T's? In my mind, this would only happen if the bacteria is present.

Does our body produce antibodies for every pathogen we've encountered before, 24/7?

Thanks in advance!
 
Last edited:
I have a question on #124 in the BS section, from the H. pylori passage.

Q: The ELISA is a test that is often used to detect antibodies to a particular organism. Would a positive result from such a test for H. pylori indicate the patient had an ulcer?

A) No, because the patient could have been exposed to H. pylori and eliminated it
C) Yes, because the patient must have cells of H. pylori present to produce antibodies

I narrowed it down to these two choices, but incorrectly chose C. I take some issue with the solution, because it seems to suggest that upon pathogen exposure, we are pumping our blood full of antibodies all the time, and a random ELISA will always pick up on this increased level of antibody production.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't the humoral/antibody response need to be triggered first by antigen presenting cells and helper T's? In my mind, this would only happen if the bacteria is present.

Does our body produce antibodies for every pathogen we've encountered before, 24/7?

Thanks in advance!

I'm going to bypass your entire thought process because it's completely wrong. Just because you have a positive Ab test does not mean you will suffer symptoms. H.pylori is normal flora; meaning it lives in your alimentary (stomach, I believe) tract and normally doesn't cause any problems.

A positive microbial test does not mean microbial disease.
 
I'm going to bypass your entire thought process because it's completely wrong. Just because you have a positive Ab test does not mean you will suffer symptoms. H.pylori is normal flora; meaning it lives in your alimentary (stomach, I believe) tract and normally doesn't cause any problems.

A positive microbial test does not mean microbial disease.

Actually, that clear it up. Thanks
 
Top