I never bashed Howard for their admissions criteria. So many people get so worked up and start stuttering and blushing whenever the topic of race is brought up. I pointed out a fact that cannot be argued, and suddenly people are all but calling me a bigot. I do feel that there are intangible factors that should play *some* role in the admissions process at all schools. But I also feel that lowering admission standards to accept more minority students is bad for everybody. First, it is degrading to the minority students that had the scores to get in despite their race. It makes everybody wonder if they got in on their own merit or if they were part of a quota. Secondly, diversity is great as long as the quality of the individuals is not sacrificed to obtain it. The number of dentists in this country is already low, the last thing we want to do is release low quality dentists among the masses. I'm not saying or implying that this is the case, but you can see how it would APPEAR that in SOME cases OTHER criteria is more important than good scores at some schools. Now the "other" criteria may be that the questionable person is the dean's son, it might be a racial issue, it might be the daughter of a large donor to the school, etc. All I am saying is that the traditionally black insitutions have the lowest acceptance criteria of all dental schools in the country. They are private institutions so they are entitled to do as they wish. No question there. And they are accredited by the ADEA. These points cannot be argued. Their students must also pass the national board exams and regional licensing exams. In short, I am all about diversity as long as in doing so quality candidates are not turned away to make room for less competitive students because of racial issues. In the case of Howard and Meharry, it does not appear that this is the case. The same holds true in medicine. If you don't believe that it is MUCH easier to get into professional school as a minority, you need a wake up call.
http://www.aamc.org/data/facts/2004/mcatgparaceeth.htm
These numbers don't lie. White students with the numbers of the matriculated black students wouldn't even get an interview.