Advisor Advice

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Vlnwi2017

New Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2009
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
So I am finishing up my year-off lab experience before MSTP. Honestly I treated it a little too much like a vacation and really slacked. I mean I did what I was told and had some successful experiments etc. and I wasn't rude but I was not begging to do experiements or seeming really interested. Today my PI acknowledged my slacking and told me that I needed to be an experimentalist to succeed (I know this by the by :laugh:). He reassured me that I can still use him as a recommendation etc. and that he "won't say anything negative" if asked. Its not that I don't trust him, but he is not going to exactly sing my praises. I know I treated this year as a paid vacation. I am already accepted into an MSTP program so its not like I need his recommendation for that....but are people down the road going to want to talk to him about me? He sort of indicated that people would for residency etc...but I assume that the experience will be so far back by that time that only graduate work will count for residency directors. What do people think?
 
I am not sure, but I don't think you will have to worry. You will probably meet several people during your 7-8 years in the MD/PhD program who can write solid recommendations for you when it comes to applying for residencies. I agree with you that residency directors would probably only look at your graduate work, since it would be your most recent work. Besides, in 7-8 years you will be a completely different person than you are now. It wouldn't make sense that residency directors would judge you based on how you were in the past.
 
The letter that matters is the one from your PI. My PI from my year off told me he thought I wasn't very smart and that he'd never write me another letter. A PhD, a bunch of publications, and a grant later and I don't think I care.

Don't worry about it.
 
Top