Banfield

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

drforwhiskers

ISU CVM c/o 2015!!!!!
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 27, 2009
Messages
165
Reaction score
0
I submitted my application online last night, and I was called this afternoon and offered an interview at Banfield for a summer assistant position.

I have worked for vets before, but they were all privately owned. Any suggestions on the interview? What kinds of questions do they ask? Also, has anyone on SDN worked there? How did you like it?

Members don't see this ad.
 
I'm working at a Banfield right now as part of the Student Job Program. I have mixed feelings so far. On one hand, it is a vet clinic and I am getting to apply a lot of things I have learned to real life situations. The doctors I work with are both young and willing to answer questions, etc. However, the corporate side of things, I don't really like. I have been working there for a couple of weeks now and I have already decided I don't want to work there as a vet. As a "Pet Nurse" though, it's not bad. Other than placing an emphasis on their wellness plans, it's pretty standard tech work. One other thing I don't like is the clinic's inability to treat any serious problem. For example, the refer all HGE cases and stuff like that. The surgeries at my banfield are limited to dentals and spay/neuters. Each Banfield is different, though. For my interview, I was asked a lot of situational type questions. For example, "if you saw a co-worker stealing from the company, what would you do?" Stuff like that. Hope this helps. If you have any other questions, feel free to PM me.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=383678

Probably the best: http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=323028

http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=741242

http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=525479

The general consensus is that working at Banfield is general is a bit of a crapshoot in terms of quality of medicine and being able to work semi-independently (ie not having to follow a "company protocol" to the letter). However, I will also say that it seems to also vary a lot by clinic, with some being fine and some being awful.
 
Im reading some of the posts from the topics and it seems like a chain restaurant/ corporation setting wanting to boost profits over all other things

I like my privately owned veterinary clinic better 😀
 
I think calling all Banfield practices good or bad is foolish - they aren't all run the same way.

That said... they certainly do manage to get some bad publicity in the vet world.
 
I'm working at a Banfield right now as part of the Student Job Program. I have mixed feelings so far. On one hand, it is a vet clinic and I am getting to apply a lot of things I have learned to real life situations. The doctors I work with are both young and willing to answer questions, etc. However, the corporate side of things, I don't really like. I have been working there for a couple of weeks now and I have already decided I don't want to work there as a vet. As a "Pet Nurse" though, it's not bad. Other than placing an emphasis on their wellness plans, it's pretty standard tech work. One other thing I don't like is the clinic's inability to treat any serious problem. For example, the refer all HGE cases and stuff like that. The surgeries at my banfield are limited to dentals and spay/neuters. Each Banfield is different, though. For my interview, I was asked a lot of situational type questions. For example, "if you saw a co-worker stealing from the company, what would you do?" Stuff like that. Hope this helps. If you have any other questions, feel free to PM me.

I'm also doing the SJP and i have the EXACT same experience. it's like you took the words right out of my mouth. it's super cool that they let me do all the tech stuff (drawing blood, running labwork, etc) but they don't really practice *medicine*...anything sick that needs to stay overnight gets referred to an emergency clinic. they focus a lot more on the prevention side of things. we do more surgeries than just dentals/spay/neuters (for example, we did a bladder stone surgery the other day) but dentals/spay/neuters make up the VERY large majority (as i'm sure they do at most other clinics)

overall though i really like it as a petnurse and you learn a lot, but i'm not sure about whether or not i'd work there after graduation.
 
I've interviewed at a Banfield office before and although I ended up not taking the job offer, I can share my experience of the interview. A lot of the questions had to do with customer service like "give an example of a time when you exemplified excellent customer service." They also told me a lot about their pet care packages and then asked about some ways I would help sell more of these packages. After working at a private clinic, the corporate feel really turned me off. Probably one of the reasons why I never ended up taking the job. Hope this helps 🙂.
 
So I have interviewed at Banfield before I got into vet school (didn't end up working there), and I worked for their student job program last summer. The thing I remember most about their interview before vet school was having to do math problems, and being timed on things I did. I also remembered them asking me similar questions that have already been mentioned.

As far as the SJP goes, my experience was horrible. But I had a lot of friends who did it all over the US as well and it varied with each person. Some Banfields are actually privately owned, and they seem to be the better ones, and the ones where my friends got the most experience. I was limited in what they would let me do, which really sucked the most. However, I did get to see a lot, way more than any normal private practice would see on a normal day, and I did get to help monitor anesthesia, they would let me try and figure out lab results and explain things to me, and I got to scrub in on a surgery. So despite not getting to do a lot of tech stuff at this one clinic, I did get some practical experience where I could think like a doctor.

Good luck with your interview!!
 
How about VCA?

We don't seem to have a huge Banfield presence in PA, but VCA's are springing up everywhere. They bought out my old vet, and the new business has not been getting stellar reviews.

Anyone have any experience with these guys?
 
How about VCA?

We don't seem to have a huge Banfield presence in PA, but VCA's are springing up everywhere. They bought out my old vet, and the new business has not been getting stellar reviews.

Anyone have any experience with these guys?

I was the little usher/room monitor for some of their talks at SAVMA awhile ago (last year?). I don't have personal experience working with them, but I thought their philosophy of buying successful clinics and making them more efficient was interesting. One of the talks had to do with biggest mistakes made in practice and how to fix them, and a lot seemed like common sense stuff... not something you needed a large corporation to tell you. I don't know though. I would hope their clinics have more autonomy than a Banfield, but who knows.
 
How about VCA?

We don't seem to have a huge Banfield presence in PA, but VCA's are springing up everywhere. They bought out my old vet, and the new business has not been getting stellar reviews.

Anyone have any experience with these guys?

I adore the specialty hospital near me, although it has more to do with the staff than the corporate side of things. i've never worked for them, they won't hire temporary people at this hospital (despite desperately needing more techs). the staff (techs and doctors) don't really seem to like corporate management much. a lot of politics that sometimes go against patient care (mainly having to do with finances). the hospital is really well run though and they have state of the art facilities which is really awesome.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
I was the little usher/room monitor for some of their talks at SAVMA awhile ago (last year?). I don't have personal experience working with them, but I thought their philosophy of buying successful clinics and making them more efficient was interesting. One of the talks had to do with biggest mistakes made in practice and how to fix them, and a lot seemed like common sense stuff... not something you needed a large corporation to tell you. I don't know though. I would hope their clinics have more autonomy than a Banfield, but who knows.

I worked for them for over 10 years before vet school, worked for them during vet school, and will return to the family once more after vet school, soon.

At this point, they -are- like a family to me, and there are many, many good people involved in the company. There's good and bad about EVERY business, both mom and pop shops, and larger companies. For now, my path is crossing once more with theirs, and I'm happy about that.

Each hospital is very unique, beyond being part of the company, just like individual privately operated practices. Overall the company strives towards high quality care and great service. As in most fields, it's the people that are working day to day in the trenches, that make or break a place. I worked in more than one VCA practice, and would return again.

The best way to learn more about a VCA hospital is to visit one, or do an externship, just like any other clinic you'd be curious about.
 
I worked for them for over 10 years before vet school, worked for them during vet school, and will return to the family once more after vet school, soon.

At this point, they -are- like a family to me, and there are many, many good people involved in the company. There's good and bad about EVERY business, both mom and pop shops, and larger companies. For now, my path is crossing once more with theirs, and I'm happy about that.

Each hospital is very unique, beyond being part of the company, just like individual privately operated practices. Overall the company strives towards high quality care and great service. As in most fields, it's the people that are working day to day in the trenches, that make or break a place. I worked in more than one VCA practice, and would return again.

The best way to learn more about a VCA hospital is to visit one, or do an externship, just like any other clinic you'd be curious about.

Glad to hear you've had a good experience! Thanks for the info. There aren't any in my current area, but I might encounter one in the future. 🙂
 
How about VCA?

We don't seem to have a huge Banfield presence in PA, but VCA's are springing up everywhere. They bought out my old vet, and the new business has not been getting stellar reviews.

Anyone have any experience with these guys?

A coworker of mine used to work at a VCA and had horror stories. She said the facade they put up was completely different than the way they treated the animals, which was poorly in her experience. Obviously this doesn't speak for all VCAs but the experiences of close family and friends has all been negative - both as an employee and as a customer.
 
How about VCA?

We don't seem to have a huge Banfield presence in PA, but VCA's are springing up everywhere. They bought out my old vet, and the new business has not been getting stellar reviews.

Anyone have any experience with these guys?

I take my cat to a VCA clinic. I think they're great. The staff are really friendly as is the vet. She saw me and my cat when he was a kitten (really tiny), I took him back nearly a year later, he grew to an enormous cat, and she remembered him. They have Saturday appointments. So, no complaints here!
Also, their prices seem to be on par or cheaper to other clinics in the area.
 
I think the main thing to keep in mind is that there are good/bad things about every clinic. I think the people who you work will are really important. If you are not with a good team your clinic will be poor quality. This goes for private practice or corporate practice.

A good thing about the banfeilds is that there everywhere. You could transfer to whatever state you wanted and work for the same place. The banfeilds give great benefits and you have the backing of a large company if anything goes wrong-such as if a client wants to sue.

I also feel like it would be easier to advance in a corporate clinic. What I mean by this is that you could buy your own banfeild which I think would be easier then buying a private practice.

Its kinda like the difference between buying a franchise or starting a new restaurant. Its just easier to buy a franchise because the name is already out on the market.

Just my opinion but I think that working at banfeild would have greater benefits then working at a private practice.
 
How about we ask for horror stories from clinics owned by individuals? I think we'd have a similar proportion of folks with negative stories to tell. It's just one of those things. I hate to hear about a clinic that wasn't/isn't offering clients the best care at the best prices, but these clinics exist. The sign over the entrance has nothing to do with the care and costs found inside... and the vets, staff, and owner/manager have *everything* to do with it. Hard to predict.
 
A coworker of mine used to work at a VCA and had horror stories. She said the facade they put up was completely different than the way they treated the animals, which was poorly in her experience. Obviously this doesn't speak for all VCAs but the experiences of close family and friends has all been negative - both as an employee and as a customer.

hmm thats too bad. our specialty hospital treats clients and patients the best of any place i've ever worked or shadowed at.
 
I take my cat to a VCA clinic. I think they're great. The staff are really friendly as is the vet. She saw me and my cat when he was a kitten (really tiny), I took him back nearly a year later, he grew to an enormous cat, and she remembered him. They have Saturday appointments. So, no complaints here!
Also, their prices seem to be on par or cheaper to other clinics in the area.

Really, around here people complain about how expensive they are. (As in, "more expensive in relation to other clinics", not just the kind of client complaining that always happens anywhere no matter what, haha.)
 
I also feel like it would be easier to advance in a corporate clinic. What I mean by this is that you could buy your own banfeild which I think would be easier then buying a private practice.

Actually, having done the Banfield student work program last summer and gone to a lot of business lunches, that is not really how it works. You can't just buy a Banfield. My understanding is that you can buy in, kind of like buying a partner share (though they have a specific term for it) but corporate is still in charge in a lot of ways. The Banfields that are (kind of) privately owned actually happen in a process that is the reverse of what you describe: owners of private clinics decide they want to sell to Banfield and have Banfield take over the business side of things, but they do maintain some autonomy.
 
Really, around here people complain about how expensive they are. (As in, "more expensive in relation to other clinics", not just the kind of client complaining that always happens anywhere no matter what, haha.)

I guess when I got my cat I looked at a handful of places, and then finally settled on the VCA because of price and a recommendation from a friend. I assume each of these clinics is somewhat independently run? I honestly don't know a lot about them.
Around here, the most expensive place I found was the Penn hospital. For the initial routine exam I scheduled for my cat, it was about twice the price at Penn than at the VCA.
 
I interviewed with Banfield for a receptionist (they call them like, CSC's or something?) position. I didn't like them because they were ALL about sales, and I am horrible at that because I am more of quiet type. I am not someone to talk up all their "packages" and "care plans" to a client, especially when so much of it is a waste of money. This is the same reason I got fired from the tanning salon I worked at 😉 haha

I personally don't like the way they operate, some do.

How about VCA?

I work at a VCA now which as a whole VCA isn't a LOT better, but the HOSPITAL I work at was just bought by VCA a year ago and we are kind of not too "VCA-y" yet so I can handle it. Personally, I feel like you learn a lot more in a hospital that is privately owned and operated than anything corporate owned. This is because they let you do more, the vets are (usually) much happier, and you don't have the goal of ripping people off, and people don't feel like you do. You also don't have to hear people bitch about how you are just out for their money (as much anyway... lol). At VCA we get ripped a new one about our dispensing fee for meds and our "insane" charges for nail trims and anal glad expressions. We have free exams for first time clients with coupon and we havefive AMAZING doctors on staff, two of whom are specialists, one an ortho surgeon. I feel like it majorly depends on the clinic and the doctors for VCA. I love my clinic, but it was a privately owned clinic for 50+ years before it became VCA. We see a lot of really serious stuff, and it's interesting and fun. It's not a lot of turn around, which is awesome and says a lot 🙂

🙄
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I should have qualified that. Most Banfields are in pet stores.
 
How about we ask for horror stories from clinics owned by individuals?

About a dozen incidences come to mind that would be horror story-worthy. And that's just in south Florida.
 
I interviewed with Banfield for a receptionist (they call them like, CSC's or something?) position. I didn't like them because they were ALL about sales, and I am horrible at that because I am more of quiet type. I am not someone to talk up all their "packages" and "care plans" to a client, especially when so much of it is a waste of money.

This has been my issue with them. It's not the doctors' fault, it's not the techs' fault, it's because they are a corporate business. I have never honestly worked in a place that has been so geared towards making money. I find that a lot of the things they do are just money makers and aren't really necessary, but are "included in the plan" (however if they just took them out of the plan, they could lower the costs). As someone who understands what is necessary in a yearly exam and what isn't it, I feel bad for the clients that come in there sometimes, because they are just doing what is on their plan, with no real idea of whether it is actually necessary or useful. I also feel like I am trying to sell them something, and the other people who work there say that it will always feel like that, and that also doesn't sit well with me because I HATE HATE HATE when people do that to me. Usually it's when someone doesn't have a plan and I am trying to help them honestly see the benefits of signing up with one versus paying out of pocket that day. I'm as honest as it gets and have nothing much to gain by these people signing on with a plan, and I hate feeling like they are thinking I am just some salesman trying to make a buck. I also wonder how their plans compare with other places regarding yearly services and dentals, etc... I love the individualized experience and attention I am getting from the doctors and the way people treat me as a vet student rather than just a tech and they are great teachers and wonderful and willing to share their knowledge. But a down side is having to work as a tech and deal with people who actually recognize their money being pissed away.


I work at a VCA now which as a whole VCA isn't a LOT better, but the HOSPITAL I work at was just bought by VCA a year ago and we are kind of not too "VCA-y" yet so I can handle it. Personally, I feel like you learn a lot more in a hospital that is privately owned and operated than anything corporate owned. This is because they let you do more, the vets are (usually) much happier, and you don't have the goal of ripping people off, and people don't feel like you do. You also don't have to hear people bitch about how you are just out for their money (as much anyway... lol).

I will back VCA all day. The clinic I worked for was great and I had no problem whatsoever working for a "corporate vet" with them. I don't know where the corporate side came into play, but it operated just like any other private practice I know. There were no rules that I could see, the doctors did as they wanted, it was a little expensive, but most vets nowadays are and they didn't do things that weren't medically necessary at the time. That has been my favorite job so far ever, and a definite career possibility in the future.
 
How about we ask for horror stories from clinics owned by individuals? I think we'd have a similar proportion of folks with negative stories to tell. It's just one of those things. I hate to hear about a clinic that wasn't/isn't offering clients the best care at the best prices, but these clinics exist. The sign over the entrance has nothing to do with the care and costs found inside... and the vets, staff, and owner/manager have *everything* to do with it. Hard to predict.


I agree, but I don't think this was to uncover horror stories. I know I have certainly been intrigued by the mysterious reason Banfield is so hated. I often wonder, "if they have so many haters, who are their clients?" and now that I have gotten a chance to figure it out, it really just boils down to corporate bull and the people running the show that everyone has to answer to are not vets, but rather MBAs who have never set foot in a clinic. Thus all the trickle-down flaws.

I know just dealing with hiring has been a nightmare. I sent in my paperwork at the end of March and they waited until a week ago, the FRIDAY AFTERNOON before my start date the following Monday, to tell me my paperwork was not all correct. I happened to have a funeral that day and didn't really have the time to just drop all that I was doing and get the needed information, so I still don't have a sign in number and instead of spending the week training myself at a slower pace on a computer, I have had to learn their computer system from looking over people's shoulders. They are so disorganized and take the longest way around anything...
 
I will back VCA all day. The clinic I worked for was great and I had no problem whatsoever working for a "corporate vet" with them. I don't know where the corporate side came into play, but it operated just like any other private practice I know. There were no rules that I could see, the doctors did as they wanted, it was a little expensive, but most vets nowadays are and they didn't do things that weren't medically necessary at the time. That has been my favorite job so far ever, and a definite career possibility in the future.

I was an extern at a VCA hospital this year, and I definitely noticed the corporate side of things. The hospital had priced itself out of spays and neuters simply because they were forced to charge a certain amount for the procedure. There were certain procedures that they had to follow that the vet didn't really want to follow, but because it was corporate, it was required. On the other hand, the head vet no longer felt the pressure of making his business succeed and the vet techs informed me that he was much less likely to have bad days and seemed generally happier. They were able to offer more services than before they had been VCA, as well. They also didn't know I was coming when I showed up even though I had applied months in advance and had emailed with the owner (it isn't just a Banfield issue).

I have also worked at Banfield, and I really enjoyed my experience there. That may have been because it was under the student program, but I was allowed to do a lot. The vets I was there with encouraged discussion of cases and allowed me to think through diagnostics before jumping in with the answer. Since it was after my surgery class, I was allowed to assist with surgeries and perform routine surgeries under supervision. There was a Dr. I didn't particularly like and she did have some professional issues, but the situation was handled well by the corporate office. That said, their paperwork and hiring processes need some help.
 
I have also worked at Banfield, and I really enjoyed my experience there. That may have been because it was under the student program, but I was allowed to do a lot. The vets I was there with encouraged discussion of cases and allowed me to think through diagnostics before jumping in with the answer. Since it was after my surgery class, I was allowed to assist with surgeries and perform routine surgeries under supervision. There was a Dr. I didn't particularly like and she did have some professional issues, but the situation was handled well by the corporate office. That said, their paperwork and hiring processes need some help.


I am working with the student program now as well, and yes, it's great. I am learning tons and the doctors, as you said, are very good with case discussions and things and have let me do things I wouldn't have been able to do otherwise. However, I was just saying that at the end of the day, I am still working for them as a tech and that includes pushing/selling their "plans" to the public (which I don't care for and have never had to do before) and doing things included with the plans that people are paying for that aren't very necessary. I have told my parents that I am torn because the experience is amazing but the drawback is the corporate salesman part. I just feel that overall the Banfield higher ups are much more concerned with making money by any means necessary than any other place I have worked for, including VCA.
 
I've never personally had experience with a VCA hospital, but I will say that after the clinic a couple of miles down the street from the last place I worked was purchased by VCA we definitely saw an increase in business.

I avoid corporate practices because I don't want a third party injecting itself into decisions regarding my pets' care. That said, I am aware of a number of corporate clinics in my area that clients seem to be very happy with... they're just not my thing.

I suspect I'd have a problem acclimating to the sales aspect of Banfield. I worked at a small practice that had almost priced itself out of the market and was often pushing pricey extras and packages because the owner (while a wonderful veterinarian) wasn't very business-savvy. I had a very difficult time selling clients on things I felt were unnecessary or pushing products that could be found far cheaper elsewhere... especially when I knew there were serious financial concerns on the owner's end. It feels unethical and awkward. I hate when pushy sales tactics are used on me. I don't want to inflict them on someone else.
 
I am still working for them as a tech and that includes pushing/selling their "plans" to the public (which I don't care for and have never had to do before) and doing things included with the plans that people are paying for that aren't very necessary. I have told my parents that I am torn because the experience is amazing but the drawback is the corporate salesman part. I just feel that overall the Banfield higher ups are much more concerned with making money by any means necessary than any other place I have worked for, including VCA.

Just out of curiosity... given the more obvious emphasis on sales, have you seen a negative impact on clients' confidence in and ability to trust the doctors/staff and their recommendations relative to less sales-centric places you've worked?
 
Last edited:
Just out of curiosity... given the more obvious emphasis on sales, have you seen a negative impact on clients' confidence in and ability to trust the doctors/staff and their recommendations relative to less sales-centric places you've worked?

To clarify: I work for a charter Banfield and it operates somewhat different (but not totally) than other Banfields under more of a franchised setting.

I honestly feel like the clients where I work are very trusting of the doctors in regards to what their pets' needs are, whether it is on a plan or not. The thing is, people aren't privy to the things that people like us that work in the vet field are, so most clients that use Banfield choose to take the doctors at their word, as with any other private clinic. After all, they're paying them for advice and treatment and if they don't trust them or don't feel they have the best interest of the animal at heart they can always go elsewhere (and some have and do). They are made aware of the plans up front so they understand what the doctor would be recommending, and truthfully if they're set up under the right circumstances they do save money and make a good difference. Plus, people come in there for things other than what is covered under their plan (random vomitting, diarrhea, skin issues, etc), so I think clients feel like the doctors have a mind of their own and aren't necessarily corporate Banfield drones. It seems like the things people are upset with are things that the techs take care of or that are the workings of corporate or don't really have to do with the doctors specifically (heartworm preventative, things not covered on their plan that they thought were) but as far as the doctors go everyone seems to be able to separate the doctors just doing their jobs or following Banfield protocol from corporate Banfield as a whole.
 
I've never personally had experience with a VCA hospital, but I will say that after the clinic a couple of miles down the street from the last place I worked was purchased by VCA we definitely saw an increase in business.

I avoid corporate practices because I don't want a third party injecting itself into decisions regarding my pets' care. That said, I am aware of a number of corporate clinics in my area that clients seem to be very happy with... they're just not my thing.

I suspect I'd have a problem acclimating to the sales aspect of Banfield. I worked at a small practice that had almost priced itself out of the market and was often pushing pricey extras and packages because the owner (while a wonderful veterinarian) wasn't very business-savvy. I had a very difficult time selling clients on things I felt were unnecessary or pushing products that could be found far cheaper elsewhere... especially when I knew there were serious financial concerns on the owner's end. It feels unethical and awkward. I hate when pushy sales tactics are used on me. I don't want to inflict them on someone else.

FWIW, an advantage of working for a larger business is sometimes better employee benefits.

Ample medical benefits, a good dental plan, 401k, paid vacation, paid holiday and sick time, paid continuing education time and cost allowance, as well as other options, such as life insurance and long-term disability insurance, that are affordable or included in compensation, are something to consider when looking at potential employers.
 
I interviewed with Banfield for a receptionist (they call them like, CSC's or something?) position. I didn't like them because they were ALL about sales, and I am horrible at that because I am more of quiet type. I am not someone to talk up all their "packages" and "care plans" to a client, especially when so much of it is a waste of money. This is the same reason I got fired from the tanning salon I worked at 😉 haha

I personally don't like the way they operate, some do.



I work at a VCA now which as a whole VCA isn't a LOT better, but the HOSPITAL I work at was just bought by VCA a year ago and we are kind of not too "VCA-y" yet so I can handle it. Personally, I feel like you learn a lot more in a hospital that is privately owned and operated than anything corporate owned. This is because they let you do more, the vets are (usually) much happier, and you don't have the goal of ripping people off, and people don't feel like you do. You also don't have to hear people bitch about how you are just out for their money (as much anyway... lol). At VCA we get ripped a new one about our dispensing fee for meds and our "insane" charges for nail trims and anal glad expressions. We have free exams for first time clients with coupon and we havefive AMAZING doctors on staff, two of whom are specialists, one an ortho surgeon. I feel like it majorly depends on the clinic and the doctors for VCA. I love my clinic, but it was a privately owned clinic for 50+ years before it became VCA. We see a lot of really serious stuff, and it's interesting and fun. It's not a lot of turn around, which is awesome and says a lot 🙂

🙄

I've looked at this post a few times, and I was not going to reply to it, but, I've decided to comment.

Businesses are usually in business to make money or turn a profit. I would like to think that the manner in which they conduct business is honest and, in the case of vet-med, in the best interest of the animal being cared for.

The VCA hospital I ran for over 10 years did not have a goal of ripping people off, nor is that ever going to be my goal nor M.O. as a veterinarian. "Ripping people off", IMO, implies dishonesty. I know your post is referring to your experiences, as mine does my own; one opinion for another.

If you want to argue that VCA, as a company, is in business to make money, that's absolutely true. If you want to argue that VCA hospitals charge more overall for their services vs. non-VCA hospitals, I also probably wouldn't argue that. It depends on the region, and, also, specific services.

There's a big debate going on, in the veterinary field, which if you look around on VIN, you can find many threads about. The whole issue of pricing, and charging for veterinary services, and what is 'too much' or 'too little', is a big issue. Public perception of the value of veterinary care is part of it. Also, how veterinarians perceived (and do perceive) the value of what they provide, is also part of it. I'm also talking about changes over time: 1990's (and prior), and the 2000's.

I don't mean to rail-road this thread. And it's one thing to debate whether certain services (or packaged services, as offered by some places) is 'necessary' for an animal, or not. Then, we can debate how much that service or product should cost (if any of us REALLY can know that).

Cost vs. value vs. perceived value vs. quality of service, etc. etc.

Anyway. I'll stop rambling. Generically speaking, one of my mentors used to say this (I know I've posted this before on here) - and I think it's mostly true:

Good.
Fast.
Cheap.

Pick two. You can't have all three.
 
I worked at a VCA referral/emergency hospital for 2 years before starting vet school and it was a very positive experience. The Dr's got the practice medicine the way they wanted, and seemed generally happy with being there. And thinking about it now, I would definitely consider working for VCA as a vet when I get done. I enjoyed working there as a tech, and think I would be plenty happy working there as a vet.

I'm sure it varies a lot by location and the individual staff at a given hospital, but I don't think thats a corporate specific issue.
 
Well, I thought I would follow up with this thread by saying I got the job. I really enjoyed my interview experience - the vets were super nice and even though I was just there to interview they explained everything that they were doing/ why they were doing it.

I've decided to take it, and if turns out to be a less than positive experience, it will only be for two months (until I head off to ISU!) and give me extra experience.

I hope everyone's been having a fantastic summer 🙂

😍
 
Yes, don't work there. They are a huge chain and at this point, it's directed towards money, not helping the animals. My cat was drowned in IV fluids at Banfield due to not caring or watching him and lack of knowledge of the new vet unable to recognize that he hadn't even absorbed all his sq fluids from the day before. After this happened, I did a lot of research and it turns out they are pretty much all like this. The make vets perform un-necessary procedures like through the wellness plan, and some of these procedures could hurt or kill your animal, but most of them are just a way to jack up the bill. It's the ones that can hurt your animal that bothers me the most. Just be careful. No matter how much money they offered me as a vet, I would never work there.
 
Yes, don't work there. They are a huge chain and at this point, it's directed towards money, not helping the animals. My cat was drowned in IV fluids at Banfield due to not caring or watching him and lack of knowledge of the new vet unable to recognize that he hadn't even absorbed all his sq fluids from the day before. After this happened, I did a lot of research and it turns out they are pretty much all like this. The make vets perform un-necessary procedures like through the wellness plan, and some of these procedures could hurt or kill your animal, but most of them are just a way to jack up the bill. It's the ones that can hurt your animal that bothers me the most. Just be careful. No matter how much money they offered me as a vet, I would never work there.


I'm sorry to hear about your cat, but you really cannot make gross assumptions and accusations about every Banfield. Every single one is different. Just how every private practice is different. You get the good with the bad.
 
Yes, don't work there. They are a huge chain and at this point, it's directed towards money, not helping the animals. My cat was drowned in IV fluids at Banfield due to not caring or watching him and lack of knowledge of the new vet unable to recognize that he hadn't even absorbed all his sq fluids from the day before. After this happened, I did a lot of research and it turns out they are pretty much all like this. The make vets perform un-necessary procedures like through the wellness plan, and some of these procedures could hurt or kill your animal, but most of them are just a way to jack up the bill. It's the ones that can hurt your animal that bothers me the most. Just be careful. No matter how much money they offered me as a vet, I would never work there.


Wow, there is so much wrong with your statement that I really don't know where to begin. I guess I should start off by saying that it is quite unfair of you to judge and entire corportate veterinary practice based off of a bad experience that you had at one hospital - Banfield has hundreds of hospitals in several different countries and denouncing all of these hospitals over one incident is very unfair. Next, I would like to know where the sources from your "large amount of research" came from. What sources could you possibly have access to that would allow you to make such an outlandish claim about ALL of the Banfields in the world. I also find your claim that their wellness plans contain items that harm pets to be quite flawed. The wellness plans include general fecal exams, dewormings, vaccinations, and other preventative care items. In some cases they may include an OVH, castration, or dental cleaning. 99% of the procedures offered under their plans are 100% safe - I have never heard of a dog being hurt from a fecal sample collection & float or from a dose of pyrantel. The other items that do pose a risk of danger, such as the surgeries, are conducted with great care and are no more dangerous to the pet then they would be if they were to be performed at another non-banfield hospital. I am 99.99% positive that you are just trolling on this forum and if you are then I think you are a pretty sad individual and feel quite sorry for your lack of maturity. If you actually are a vet student then I would suggest that you clean up your act and learn some professionalism. Your are most certainly entitled to your opinions, but bad mouthing different organizations & vet schools is quite unbecoming of a future member of the profession.
 
just thought i'd update and let SDN know how my experience has been going. i didn't really like it at first because even though i've worked at multiple vets and have significant experience, they wouldn't really let me do too much for awhile. now that i'm "trained" and i am working essentially on my own, i'm loving it. i'm learning a lot that i didn't have the opportunity to learn elsewhere, and i can get a lot of client interaction which is one of my favorite aspects of the field. but, all in all, like anywhere else, i think it is the people that make a place. i really like both of the vets that i am working for, and they seem to care a lot about what they do. they don't mind when i ask them questions about something. i don't think it's a place i would want to work when i begin practice, but i am getting a lot out of my experience.
 
just thought i'd update and let SDN know how my experience has been going. i didn't really like it at first because even though i've worked at multiple vets and have significant experience, they wouldn't really let me do too much for awhile. now that i'm "trained" and i am working essentially on my own, i'm loving it. i'm learning a lot that i didn't have the opportunity to learn elsewhere, and i can get a lot of client interaction which is one of my favorite aspects of the field. but, all in all, like anywhere else, i think it is the people that make a place. i really like both of the vets that i am working for, and they seem to care a lot about what they do. they don't mind when i ask them questions about something. i don't think it's a place i would want to work when i begin practice, but i am getting a lot out of my experience.

That's great to hear. Unfortunately for me, I am still pretty disappointed with my experience at Banfield thus far. I really feel like I am simply learning how to work at "Banfield" rather than really learning vet medicine in general and I also feel like since I am only there for 2 and a half months, I only have time to learn the job, and not extra things. I don't feel like a lot of the things I am learning or practicing are going to be all that applicable to future jobs I take with other businesses (vet-related), unless I work for Banfield. Also, the hours I work are extremely taxing. I have never worked such long hours in any of the 6 vet clinics I have worked in. Plus, working 12+ hours a day consecutively it's easy to go into overtime... however, here, they won't let you. I was made to take a THREE HOUR lunch so that I did not go into overtime. Not made to leave early or come in late, but to take a large chunk out of the middle of the day and still work til close. That kind of cheapness just doesn't sit well with me.

I'm learning things, sure, like I have gotten much better at blood draws and have gotten a lot of catheter placing experience, but I find myself wanting more variation. The work/cases there are quite repetitive. Most everything is either vaccines or comprehensive exams and spays/neuters and dentals in regards to surgery. The protocol for surgery prep-type things is quite in depth and not like anywhere else I have experienced, so again, it's very applicable if you're planning on working for Banfield, but otherwise it's a lot of extra things going on that other businesses don't bother with. Not to mention, I notice that everyone gets really stressed out and haywire when anything besides the above mentioned cases comes in, especially if the patient is on a plan... like they aren't prepared to deal with a complicated patient and all the focus has to be on said "unique" case, and things get very backed up because both doctors are working on that one case. Sorry to be so cynical, I just don't really care for the job 🙁
 
there was an opportunity for vet assistant around my area for banfield

would you do it? the job description was very bland consisting of sitting in front of a computer long hours.......it didn't really go into any of the technical aspects I would be doing

im not sure if i'd like having to promote a product everytime to people to get the company more money........
 
Top