still not sure I understand the rationale with D5% and 1/2 NS. That is hypertonic fluid. 1 bag of that stuff will deliver 70mmol of Na + Cl, but only 1 L of water. Which means, to meet someones daily water requirment you will also have to give them 140mmol of Na and Cl, which is really overcooking them.
that said, most kidneys will handle that insult. but you run a fine line of hyperchloraemia, and overloading their sodium.
beware that 1L of normal saline will take at least 20 mins to STAT into someone, depending on what size line you have. Some of the newer fancier pumps can deliver 1L in less than that.. but on a ward, thats pretty much the fastest you can run a bag into someone.
In the resuscitation setting, your patient will be shocked. Certainly in purely cardiogenic and obstructive shock, fluids are not a major concern. However in hypovolaemia and distributive shock, running in fluids over 1-2 hours is just too slow. The point of resuscitation fluids is to treat aggressively. intravascular volume depletion is serious, and if cardiac output is compromised, then it is fatal if not corrected rapidly. Theres no point dillying about worrying that they will develop failure. Most cases of untreated hypovolaemic shock, or distributive shock will eventually develop some degree of cardiogenic shock or cardiac arrest, for which the prognosis is then exceedingly poor. So don't wait around.
At least in the surgical setting, in a patient with very very high suspicion of a post operative bleed, certainly 1-2 hours is the longest time before weve had them in theater. Most of the time, the boss was called, the senior resident scrubbed and patient wheeled in inside 60 mins. By the time that happened, on the ward we'd already loaded them with 2-4L of NS and perhaps even started a transfusion by then.