Yes, I am in the same boat. I've pretty much decided on BU, because it fits well into my long term goals. Apart from that, I thought NYU was way better. If BU were to charge a tuition that was significantly less than NYU, only then would it be a better option. Otherwise, I think the school is just OK. A lot depends on whether you like Boston or Manhattan. I don't like Manhattan, so that's another reason for why I'm going with BU.
I am yet to come across anyone who has given me a clear cut reason for why one school would be better than the other, apart from the huge patient pool at NYU.