Can someone explain Huckel's Rule?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

notJERRYFALWELL

Squirrel tactics!!
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 15, 2003
Messages
3,913
Reaction score
1
My text sucks, and does not resonably explain what the 4n + 2 (pi) electrons thing means or how to determine it. Could some of you enlighten me?

And none of that 'you shouldn't be studying' crap. I am bored, and curious.

Members don't see this ad.
 
Originally posted by notJERRYFALWELL
My text sucks, and does not resonably explain what the 4n + 2 (pi) electrons thing means or how to determine it. Could some of you enlighten me?

And none of that 'you shouldn't be studying' crap. I am bored, and curious.



An compound is said to be "aromatic" when it is more stable then theoretically predicted alkene hydrogenation data. This is due to delocalized electrons(ie. resonance energy)

To figure whether or not a compound is aromatic, it has to fit the following criteria:
(1) must follow Huckel's rule, having 4n+2 electrons in the delocalized cloud
(2) are able to be planar and are cyclic
(3) every atom in the circle is able to participate in delocalizing the electrons by having a p orbital or an unshared pair of electrons
 
i know, i know, but what is 'n'? is it any arbitrary integer?

I know what it means, and what its for, but how do i determine whether something satisfies it?
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Huckel's rule is a fairly straightforward principle. Basically it states that if a compound possesses 4n+2 pi electrons (where n can be an integer greater than or equal to zero--i.e., 0,1,2,...), it is aromatic, PROVIDED that the compound is cyclic, planar, and has an unhybridized p orbital on every atom in the ring structure. For instance, benzene is a six carbon ring structure. Every carbon in the ring is sp2 hybridized, which means that there is an unhybridized p orbital on each carbon. Moreover, the structure is planar. Now you simply apply Huckel's rule as a final criterion for aromaticity. Here's how you apply it: each end of a double bond equals one pi electron, and lone pairs of electrons may or may not be considered pi electrons. In the case of benzene, there are three double bonds (which can be shifted around as per resonance), and therefore there are 6 pi electrons. Can 4n+2 equal six, given the restrictions on the value of n? Definitely. If n equals 1, then 4n+2 equals 6. Oila, benzene satisfies Huckel's rule.

Huckel's rule can become a little bit tricky when cations and anions are being evaluated for aromaticity. Solid working knowledge of hybridization will help you tackle problems of this sort.

Hope this helps.
 
Here's a question for you: does cyclobutadiene satisfy Huckel's rule? This should help you understand the n factor.
 
Originally posted by elias514
Here's a question for you: does cyclobutadiene satisfy Huckel's rule? This should help you understand the n factor.

No, because it has two double bonds, which yields 4 electrons. You cannot obtain 4 electrons using Huckel's rule (4(0)+2=2 and 4(1)+2=6)

Thanks elias... that makes a lot more sense.
 
if i remember properly, huckels rule basically means an even number of pi e-'s that is NOT evenly divisible by 4.
 
Top