Christmas Granny Dump

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Groove

Member
Lifetime Donor
20+ Year Member
Joined
May 3, 2004
Messages
3,799
Reaction score
4,427
Points
6,556
  1. Attending Physician
It's that time of year folks. The Christmas Granny Dump where the family is afraid that having frail, old granny by the tree is going to be a buzz kill for the whole Christmas/New Years celebrations so it's off to the ER to dump them for nursing home placement because well....they can't be bothered and that's what the ER is there for, right?

1766419714329.png
 
Unfortunately in Florida it is not the christmas granny dump right now (thats happening too), it is the "does my two/four/six/sixteen year old have influenza a" (yes they do) being asked roughly 4 times per hour, every hour, for 24 straight hours. And subsequently every one of those parents will be seen the next day for "my plague vector spawn tested positive for influenza A yesterday and now I feel like I have a mild case of death, do I have the flu?" (yes you do, and you didn't need me to tell you that).

Every juvenile human being attending school, preschool, day care, or the ball pit at Charles Ezra Cheese has influenza A and is ruining Christmas for everyone.
 
EM/palliative and thinking there’s a missed business opportunity here
 
"We haven't saved a dime or spent a second planning for this inevitable event, so now we want y'all to pay for it and deal with everything!"
Yeah, I usually make them feel really bad about it. I will speak really loud so Granny understands (they always leave their hearing aids at home) that she's not going back home and I'll go something like "SO......ARE YOU WANTING TO PUT GRANNY IN A NURSING HOME? IS THAT WHY YOU ARE HERE?"

They'll frantically look at each other, look at her....then back to me and go "No, no I mean...that's not why we're here. She just....she just....is falling a lot and won't eat or drink very much. She's skin and bones....I mean just look at her doctor." "

RIGHT....AND NONE OF THIS STUFF STARTED YESTERDAY SO AGAIN...IF YOU WANT ME TO PUT HER IN THE HOSPITAL TO GET PLACED IN A NURSING HOME (About this time a family member will sidle up beside me and gently touch my elbow whispering "can we talk about this outside?" and I'll shrug him off and keep talking)

THEN I JUST WANT EVERYONE TO UNDERSTAND, AS WELL AS GRANNY, THAT SHE WILL NEVER BE GOING HOME AGAIN. EVER. ON TOP OF THAT....WE'LL BE UP TO THE MERCY OF ANY NURSING HOMES THAT CASE MANAGEMENT/SOCIAL WORK CAN FIND WITH AN OPENING AND THAT MAY NOT BE THE PLACE YOU WOULD HAVE CHOSEN FOR HER AND IT MAY NOT BE A PLACE THAT SHE WANTS TO GO BUT IT WILL BE THE ONLY OPTION SHE HAS.

(I then look at granny)

DO YOU UNDERSTAND WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT WITH YOUR CHILDREN? THEY WANT ME TO ADMIT YOU SO WE CAN PLACE YOU IN A NURSING HOME AND YOU WON'T BE GOING HOME. YOU WON'T GET TO SPEND CHRISTMAS OR THE HOLIDAYS WITH YOUR FAMILY. IS THAT WHAT YOU WANT TO DO?"

5 times out of 10, they cancel the request and take her home to "discuss it with the family". The other 5 times the family doesn't care and they admit her anyway or the sensitive ones have left the ER by that point so they don't have to feel responsible anymore.
 
And those aren't even the frustrating cases. It's the one where family sent her to the ER by ambulance for some random reason. She gets worked up and you discharge her and once the nurses call to tell them she is being discharged THEN they show up and demand admission for NH or change the story or get put on speaker phone and demand admission for NH placement, etc..
 
Yeah, I usually make them feel really bad about it. I will speak really loud so Granny understands (they always leave their hearing aids at home) that she's not going back home and I'll go something like "SO......ARE YOU WANTING TO PUT GRANNY IN A NURSING HOME? IS THAT WHY YOU ARE HERE?"

They'll frantically look at each other, look at her....then back to me and go "No, no I mean...that's not why we're here. She just....she just....is falling a lot and won't eat or drink very much. She's skin and bones....I mean just look at her doctor." "

RIGHT....AND NONE OF THIS STUFF STARTED YESTERDAY SO AGAIN...IF YOU WANT ME TO PUT HER IN THE HOSPITAL TO GET PLACED IN A NURSING HOME (About this time a family member will sidle up beside me and gently touch my elbow whispering "can we talk about this outside?" and I'll shrug him off and keep talking)

THEN I JUST WANT EVERYONE TO UNDERSTAND, AS WELL AS GRANNY, THAT SHE WILL NEVER BE GOING HOME AGAIN. EVER. ON TOP OF THAT....WE'LL BE UP TO THE MERCY OF ANY NURSING HOMES THAT CASE MANAGEMENT/SOCIAL WORK CAN FIND WITH AN OPENING AND THAT MAY NOT BE THE PLACE YOU WOULD HAVE CHOSEN FOR HER AND IT MAY NOT BE A PLACE THAT SHE WANTS TO GO BUT IT WILL BE THE ONLY OPTION SHE HAS.

(I then look at granny)

DO YOU UNDERSTAND WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT WITH YOUR CHILDREN? THEY WANT ME TO ADMIT YOU SO WE CAN PLACE YOU IN A NURSING HOME AND YOU WON'T BE GOING HOME. YOU WON'T GET TO SPEND CHRISTMAS OR THE HOLIDAYS WITH YOUR FAMILY. IS THAT WHAT YOU WANT TO DO?"

5 times out of 10, they cancel the request and take her home to "discuss it with the family". The other 5 times the family doesn't care and they admit her anyway or the sensitive ones have left the ER by that point so they don't have to feel responsible anymore.
Why are we even involved with this? Have the families make the calls, transfer the records, etc etc.
 
Why are we even involved with this? Have the families make the calls, transfer the records, etc etc.

Honestly, bro. This is why I have a remington retirement plan.
Once I'm done, I'm done. Bottle of gin. Lemme drive my Jeep out to yonder. Pop.
I'll get my ghost to post about it on SDN for teh lolz.
 
You all have grannies with families? What?

Over in the inner city when someone drops of grannie the ONLY family member who drove her plops her in the waiting room and tells security "were not coming back". Then when you call the numbers on her chart for next of kin (or in the cell phone on her for "son") you get an awkward "hello' and when you introduce yourself as the hospital, they just hang up. If you call back you find out they put the hospital line on block. If you call from your cellphone it works again and they yell at you to stop calling them.

My folks have it down to a science
 
Who TF wants to waste away in some nursing home?
Jesus. Men used to be dangerous.
They were soldiers. They were sailors. They would kill anyone that deserved it.
And the courts would say: "that man deserved to die; this man is a hero."
My uncle was a navy man who was looking for a fight to his last day.
Popeye the sailor man.
Literally killed men by strangling them.
Guys. SDN will get a send-off from me.
 
Honestly, bro. This is why I have a remington retirement plan.
Once I'm done, I'm done. Bottle of gin. Lemme drive my Jeep out to yonder. Pop.
I'll get my ghost to post about it on SDN for teh lolz.
Yup. Wheel me onto the beach to see one last sunrise. Then snap a .357 round into my brain pan. Turn me off like a light switch
 
Yup. Wheel me onto the beach to see one last sunrise. Then snap a .357 round into my brain pan. Turn me off like a light switch

Honestly, bro. Once I'm done, I'm done. Eff off with all the performative nonsense.
My uncle was literally a God of Pathology. He died pathetically.
I'm not gonna make that mistake.
 
You all have grannies with families? What?

Over in the inner city when someone drops of grannie the ONLY family member who drove her plops her in the waiting room and tells security "were not coming back". Then when you call the numbers on her chart for next of kin (or in the cell phone on her for "son") you get an awkward "hello' and when you introduce yourself as the hospital, they just hang up. If you call back you find out they put the hospital line on block. If you call from your cellphone it works again and they yell at you to stop calling them.

My folks have it down to a science
That's crazy. I've worked in some interesting cities but have never seen that.
 
You all have grannies with families? What?

Over in the inner city when someone drops of grannie the ONLY family member who drove her plops her in the waiting room and tells security "were not coming back". Then when you call the numbers on her chart for next of kin (or in the cell phone on her for "son") you get an awkward "hello' and when you introduce yourself as the hospital, they just hang up. If you call back you find out they put the hospital line on block. If you call from your cellphone it works again and they yell at you to stop calling them.

My folks have it down to a science

I think my next call might be to APS for abandonment
 
I think my next call might be to APS for abandonment
Every place I've ever worked the first time, I suggest that the nurses laugh and encourage me to give it a shot. I've never seen it motivate anyone in the end. It's entirely possible that maybe in the end some justice does happen, but I'm definitely not seeing it in the Ed, where the families just put all numbers associated with the hospital on ignore, even when you make that threat
 
Every place I've ever worked the first time, I suggest that the nurses laugh and encourage me to give it a shot. I've never seen it motivate anyone in the end. It's entirely possible that maybe in the end some justice does happen, but I'm definitely not seeing it in the Ed, where the families just put all numbers associated with the hospital on ignore, even when you make that threat

I mean...not saying this isn't awful...but is it criminal? Family doesn't have any legal obligation to care for granny, right?
 
I've seen this play out

Answer can actually be yes

If you've got someone living with you and you leave them covered in ****, don't feed them, just stuff them in a closet and throw food at them twice a week you can indeed see things go that route. Needs to be extreme tho

The worst case I've ever seen was a granny left on the couch for months and she came in frozen in a seated position with exposed thoracic and lumbar vertebra because skin had totally broken down

Of course, covered in layers of **** too
 
I've seen this play out

Answer can actually be yes

If you've got someone living with you and you leave them covered in ****, don't feed them, just stuff them in a closet and throw food at them twice a week you can indeed see things go that route. Needs to be extreme tho

The worst case I've ever seen was a granny left on the couch for months and she came in frozen in a seated position with exposed thoracic and lumbar vertebra because skin had totally broken down

Of course, covered in layers of **** too
Yeah but what about "this old geezer is a drag. We're out on this. It's not her, it's us. Don't call us. ✌🏼 <Revs car on way out>"

Wish I was exaggerating
 
Yeah but what about "this old geezer is a drag. We're out on this. It's not her, it's us. Don't call us. ✌🏼 <Revs car on way out>"

Wish I was exaggerating

Oh no that

Quite immoral

Perfectly legal
 
Oh no that

Quite immoral

Perfectly legal
Yeah, which is why I've always found that attempting to threaten them with adult protective services just gets them to ignore me even more.

For all of the annoying entitled patients who tell us that they "know my rights" and then will come up with some completely random thing that they are very clearly not entitled to.... The real jerks of society are always surprisingly astute about random legal specifics like this and how it doesn't apply to them.

So circling back to my original point, you all have family members that even are willing to show up to argue that she's altered? A much more effective tactic is to simply act like you don't even know who Granny is and put the hospital on the do not call list. (I forgot to mention my other favorite tactic, after refusing to cooperate in any way with a workup, if I do decide to discharge grandma with an ambulance ride back home, they will refuse to open the door and the ambulance will just bring her back right afterwards).
 
How are you going to guarantee you won't make that mistake?

A honest question, and it deserves an honest answer:

As long as I have capacity, I will not die after some nonsense palliative surgery "because".

I think (and I can be wrong) that it will occur to me one day that "my work is done; I cannot offer anything more to this planet".

It's over for me then .
 
I mean...not saying this isn't awful...but is it criminal? Family doesn't have any legal obligation to care for granny, right?
Depends on the state, filial laws are a thing and family is responsible do shelter in those states
 
Speaking of Christmas, I am seeing just the most inane nonsense on my shift tonight.
 
Speaking of Christmas, I am seeing just the most inane nonsense on my shift tonight.
I just walked into my day shift at what is normally a very chill free standing in a miami suburb. Busy during the day but usually really quiet at night sort of place. Pretty normal to have 5-6ish patients from midnight to 6am, with that number being frontloaded towards 12-1am. Just arrived and the board shows that they saw 21(!!) from midnight to 6AM. 22 if you count the person they left waiting for me.

This bodes poorly on a day that admin purposely understaffed us.
wtf-what-the-****.gif
 
I just walked into my day shift at what is normally a very chill free standing in a miami suburb. Busy during the day but usually really quiet at night sort of place. Pretty normal to have 5-6ish patients from midnight to 6am, with that number being frontloaded towards 12-1am. Just arrived and the board shows that they saw 21(!!) from midnight to 6AM. 22 if you count the person they left waiting for me.

This bodes poorly on a day that admin purposely understaffed us.
View attachment 413240
How much of that was flu in under-resilient losers
 
How much of that was flu in under-resilient losers
Let me see. <checks> 4. That number is way lower than it should be and I am not thrilled. Lots of weirdly complex medical complaints on the final diagnosis list. I would be happier if it was just the usual stream of weaklings with flu A wanting it confirmed.
 
Yeah I got slammed with tons of medical admissions for very complex deconditioned elders who fallen and had minimal injury but clearly non ambulatory, lived alone…

And had all been sent out of a rehab or SNF in the past 72hr with zero home services.

I think I had 6-7 at once, hard to keep them straight and no alternatives for them in a holiday period. Some of them were painfully aware they were discharged as their annual rehab days had been hit.

What are we gonna do…
 
Yeah I got slammed with tons of medical admissions for very complex deconditioned elders who fallen and had minimal injury but clearly non ambulatory, lived alone…

And had all been sent out of a rehab or SNF in the past 72hr with zero home services.

I think I had 6-7 at once, hard to keep them straight and no alternatives for them in a holiday period. Some of them were painfully aware they were discharged as their annual rehab days had been hit.

What are we gonna do…
Welp, it's the hospitalist's lucky day, 7 straight social 'ambulatory dysfunction' admits in a row. It's xmas, even if you guys had a case manager in the ED, he/she won't be in today. Hopefully you work at a place where you don't get a lot of pushback for these sort of things. If not, good luck.
 
Yeah I got slammed with tons of medical admissions for very complex deconditioned elders who fallen and had minimal injury but clearly non ambulatory, lived alone…

And had all been sent out of a rehab or SNF in the past 72hr with zero home services.

I think I had 6-7 at once, hard to keep them straight and no alternatives for them in a holiday period. Some of them were painfully aware they were discharged as their annual rehab days had been hit.

What are we gonna do…
6/7 you say??
 
Welp, it's the hospitalist's lucky day, 7 straight social 'ambulatory dysfunction' admits in a row. It's xmas, even if you guys had a case manager in the ED, he/she won't be in today. Hopefully you work at a place where you don't get a lot of pushback for these sort of things. If not, good luck.
Nah the culture is good. We try to send them home if there is family and a prayer, and normal days we are good about getting PT/CM to run by the ED to check possibilities.

The concentration of cases was impressive. A couple had something I could point at (AKI or mild rhabdo). But the number who’d been in a long term facility for weeks-to-months dumped out Monday of Xmas week and found me by Tuesday.

It’s like the system is broken… huh
 
The worst hours and the worst patients for mid pay? Mmmm yeahhhh gimme some of thhattttt
 
Last night seemed to be the SNF granny dump. Everyone else was legit, but had two elderly patients who the SNF refused to accept back and had to get Adult Protective Services involved.
Unfortunately, depending what state you are in.
As long as the SNF hands them discharge papers on the way out to the hospital, they don’t have any obligation to take them back.
Otherwise it’s 30 days notice
 
Unfortunately, depending what state you are in.
As long as the SNF hands them discharge papers on the way out to the hospital, they don’t have any obligation to take them back.
Otherwise it’s 30 days notice
They have a legal obligation to take them back unless the facility no longer meets their needs (42 CFR § 483.15). This has to be a significant change that prevents them from caring for the patient (i.e., patient is now bedridden and they are in an ALF instead of full SNF). A transfer to the hospital is just that -- it is considered by CMS to be a temporary transfer and not a discharge from the SNF to the hospital.

A SNF can also refuse a patient if they have exhibited violence toward staff, but this has to be properly documented and requires written notice to the patient and their representative. If the transfer to the hospital stabilized the patient (i.e., psychiatric component or dementia has been treated so that aggressive behavior has been abated), then the facility must take the patient back.

The facility took the patient back after we threatened to contact the Ombudsman.
 
Today, out of my 4 admits, 2 of them were dumps.

Our hospitalist group had a record of 34 admits in 11 hours today.

I had tell one of the ED doc "no need to apologize."

The 2 IM residency teams were also capped (not sure how many admits they had).

Our society is screwed.
 
Honestly, bro. This is why I have a remington retirement plan.
Once I'm done, I'm done. Bottle of gin. Lemme drive my Jeep out to yonder. Pop.
I'll get my ghost to post about it on SDN for teh lolz.

Morbid topic I know, but are we talking hand held or big boom stick? Just I had a friend who went with the hand held option and it didn't exactly have the instantaneous results I think she was after. It did the job, there was just a bit of a delay in terms of effectiveness. Better to just take the head clean off imho. If you're concerned about inconveniencing people in terms of clean up, I'm sure there's some sort of contraption you could set up to assist with that.

I fully support your right to make such a decision, and if it ever comes to that I also hope that you will have access to legal and reliable options to help you with your life retirement goals. 🙂

(my Father in Law chose the legally accessible option and, whilst I wasn't present for it, from what I heard it was a really lovely and peaceful way for him to have spent his final moments on this earthly plane of existence).
 
(my Father in Law chose the legally accessible option and, whilst I wasn't present for it, from what I heard it was a really lovely and peaceful way for him to have spent his final moments on this earthly plane of existence).
I’m glad to hear it was lovely and peaceful for your FIL. MAID is a substantial part of my HPM fellowship this year. I’m in one of two states in the US that accepts patients who are not state residents, so the opportunities are plentiful. Though what occurs to me is that @RustedFox’s retirement plan may not include the requisite estimated life span of 6 months or fewer to qualify.
 
I’m glad to hear it was lovely and peaceful for your FIL. MAID is a substantial part of my HPM fellowship this year. I’m in one of two states in the US that accepts patients who are not state residents, so the opportunities are plentiful. Though what occurs to me is that @RustedFox’s retirement plan may not include the requisite estimated life span of 6 months or fewer to qualify.

I wish you all the best with MAID and your HPM fellowship. Before Voluntary Assisted Dying was made legal and available in my country (Australia, access varies by State) one of my Uncles went through an absolutely horrific death from cancer. I'm glad people have more options available to them now if circumstances warrant it. I was diagnosed with Marginal Zone Lymphoma in 2021, so far the cancer is just kind of sitting there not doing anything, but I have looked into the legalities and requirements of assisted death if I do get to the point where the quality of my life is such that a peaceful death is the far better option (to be honest I fear pain and suffering far more than I fear dying).
 
Morbid topic I know, but are we talking hand held or big boom stick? Just I had a friend who went with the hand held option and it didn't exactly have the instantaneous results I think she was after. It did the job, there was just a bit of a delay in terms of effectiveness. Better to just take the head clean off imho. If you're concerned about inconveniencing people in terms of clean up, I'm sure there's some sort of contraption you could set up to assist with that.

I fully support your right to make such a decision, and if it ever comes to that I also hope that you will have access to legal and reliable options to help you with your life retirement goals. 🙂

(my Father in Law chose the legally accessible option and, whilst I wasn't present for it, from what I heard it was a really lovely and peaceful way for him to have spent his final moments on this earthly plane of existence).

Oh Yeah!
I had a school mate use the hand held with less than optimal results too.
He ended up blind with brain damage and institutionalized for the remainder of his life.
I get a case of the blues every time I think about it.
 
Oh Yeah!
I had a school mate use the hand held with less than optimal results too.
He ended up blind with brain damage and institutionalized for the remainder of his life.
I get a case of the blues every time I think about it.
Is it morbid how many of us are going to be able to tell similar stories?

Had two people in my residency (one I knew and one who was two years ahead of me and I only knew by name) suffer from an acute case of self-determination a few years into attending-hood. One was using the smith and wesson deluxe retirement plan but the other one wrote a nice letter to their loved ones and then achieved terminal velocity (thats not actually true. It was like 20 floors and terminal velocity is >100).

The field is a bitch.
 
Top Bottom