Cincinnati vs USF Core vs SLU vs Rochester (WL)

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

SleepingPillow

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2017
Messages
154
Reaction score
106
First of all, super grateful to have multiple acceptances. I was going to wait for FA info, but I am kinda bored atm so wanted to hear some thoughts about these schools. I will update the post with FA later if needed. Just a bit of info about myself to help with the suggestions:
- Very OOS for all these schools so distance does not matter lol
- Most interested in pediatrics but also 1) radiology 2) anesthesiology 3) ophthalmology. Also want to do something with global health/health policy
- Ruled out FM and most likely IM because I want nothing to do with treating adult chronic diseases
- From low-income family, so FA will matter a lot. Unfortunately, none of my current acceptances are that great with FA.
- I might be interested in matching to the east coast bc I haven't lived there before, but I am fine with cities like Chicago, Atlanta, Nashville, or west coast.

USF CORE (70-80K COA/year)
Pros
- Brand new building with sweet amenities for med students
- Tampa seems very fun, going to school next to the beach can't be that bad
- Skyrocketing rankings and funding, which is supported by good clinical sites not that far from each other
- Fantastic global health concentration with many international connections, especially Asia
Cons
- OOS tuition all 4 years along with the highest COL
- Not the biggest fan of Florida in general
- No real campus
- High SOAP last year is sus, but I am not interested in derm/ortho/plastics
- Their financial aid was a mess as of last year (no real package until you matriculate, and you have to fill out a long application)
- Basically graded

SLU (80K COA)
Pros
- Spent 4 years in StL, feels like home and know I would like it here
- They offer 10-20K need-based tuition
- Located in one of the most segregated regions in the US, so lots of focus on social justice
- Surprisingly very good match list
- P/F
Cons
- Nothing really stood out about the school
- Overshadowed by WashU

Cincinnati (60-70K COA)
Pros
- Cincinnati Children's! And huge hospital system all close together
- More traditional medical school campus with undergrad close by
- Can get IS tuition all 4 years
- Probably about as established as you can get (200+ years)
- I like the midwest vibe
Cons
- Not as diverse as they claim to be. But this is a state school so it's not that bad considering.
- Very few scholarships if any
- They are usually internally ranked (currently full P/F due to covid, may continue but who knows)

Rochester (WL) (80K)
Pros
- Only school on here that is "prestigious"
- Good need-based aid from their info session, up to full tuition possibly
- Excellent research, global, local opportunities with their pathway program
- Small class but I felt like I would fit in with the students (very diverse)
- East coast is cool (although Rochester is isolated as heck)
- Likely sending a LOI here next month
Cons
- Awfully cold weather? IDK
- They didn't accept me 🙁

So yeah, fingers crossed for UR. However, if I don't get in there, what should I pick? I am leaning Cincinnati (pending FA info) but just wanted to hear some thoughts! Thank you in advance

Members don't see this ad.
 
Last edited:
I'd lean Cincy too. If / when you get an A from Rochester, you can compare the two. Cincy is a solid choice though the grading / ranking is the biggest downside IMO. Cheaper than SLU, better school than SLU and USF.
 
Update: Received $20,000 scholarship to SLU. Its COA is now between $20-35K lower than Cincy (NKY x4 vs Ohio x3 tuition). Is it worth it to email Cincy and see if they care about SLU's scholarship, or is that a bad look since Cincy is the better school?
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Update: Received $20,000 scholarship to SLU. Its COA is now between $20-35K lower than Cincy (NKY x4 vs Ohio x3 tuition). Is it worth it to email Cincy and see if they care about SLU's scholarship, or is that a bad look since Cincy is the better school?
Maybe just don’t mention school that gave you money. Just say another program gave aid making it a significantly less expensive option, however talk about how you really want to go here. Ion know tho lol so see what others got to say!
 
Maybe just don’t mention school that gave you money. Just say another program gave aid making it a significantly less expensive option, however talk about how you really want to go here. Ion know tho lol so see what others got to say!
I am sure they would want to know which school haha and I am assuming they would want documentation
 
Top