Cramming a physics major into two years tanked my GPA. Am I hosed, or can I apply?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

archibaldhaddock

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2018
Messages
79
Reaction score
93
Hi all, thank you very much in advance for any input or feedback.

I have the pretty standard high MCAT/low GPA problem -- I'm below the 10th percentile GPA at almost every school, but above the 90th percentile MCAT, so I'm having a ton of trouble making a school list. To make matters worse, I actually have a downward trend in GPA. I took my first two years of classes at community college and did quite well in biochemistry prereqs. Unfortunately, I made the extremely bad decision in my junior year (first year at a 4-year school) to start the physics major, and add it to my biochem major. I did quite well in my junior year, including in my biochemistry classes (so hopefully adcoms can see high grades in 400 level biochem?). However, my GPA completely tanked my senior year. Each quarter, I was taking three or four separate 300 or 400 level physics classes at once, and my GPA was below 3.0 during this time. If you remove the physics classes, my GPA would be around 3.6. Sadly... you can't do that.

Also, I don't know if this will be taken into consideration, but I worked 20+ hours a week through the entirety of undergrad to fund the majority of my education, which definitely had an impact on my grades.

State: Not CA/TX/NY
Applicant: ORM
MCAT: 522 (130/130/131/131)
Science GPA: 3.35
Overall GPA: 3.40
Majors: Biochemistry, Physics

Research:
-600 hours in an undergraduate Biochem stem cell-focused lab. No pub. Presentation/poster at undergrad symposium.

Extra-curriculars:
-I graduated in 2017 and have worked full-time for the past two years at an analytical chemistry laboratory in a leadership role (manager)
-Worked two years at a restaurant to put myself through community college (20 hours a week during school, 40 during breaks)
-Worked four years after that at another restaurant, became a supervisor in my junior year of school (20 hours a week during school, 40 during breaks)
-Have written for a well-regarded sports blog for two and a half years (paid, average 3 posts a week, over 5000 views on each post)
-Honestly haven't done a ton else as far as clubs go. I hike, run, and play tennis, but I mostly worked to support myself through the entirety of college.

Clinical Volunteering:
-Extremely hands-on role at local children's hospital for over a year now, presently have 150 hours. Will continue for the next year and get another 150.

Non-Clinical Volunteering:
-Volunteered as a TA in a local high school chemistry class comprised of disadvantaged students - 100 hours

Shadowing:
-Oncology, 40 hours

Do I absolutely need a postbac to apply MD?
 
Last edited:
In addition to your state schools I suggest these:
Vermont
Quinnipiac
Tufts
Albany
New York Medical College
Seton Hall
Drexel
Temple
Jefferson
Penn State
George Washington
Georgetown
Eastern Virginia
Wake Forest
NOVA MD
Oakland Beaumont
Western Michigan
Wayne State
Medical College Wisconsin
Rosalind Franklin
Loyola
Creighton
Tulane
TCU-UNT
Loma Linda
Kaiser
California University
Apply in June and submit all your secondaries by July.
 
In addition to your state schools I suggest these:
Vermont
Quinnipiac
Tufts
Albany
New York Medical College
Seton Hall
Drexel
Temple
Jefferson
Penn State
George Washington
Georgetown
Eastern Virginia
Wake Forest
NOVA MD
Oakland Beaumont
Western Michigan
Wayne State
Medical College Wisconsin
Rosalind Franklin
Loyola
Creighton
Tulane
TCU-UNT
Loma Linda
Kaiser
California University
Apply in June and submit all your secondaries by July.

Thank you very much for the suggestions.
 
Will you be claiming disadvantaged status? Not many medical school applicants went to community college first, or have 6 years experience working in restaurants.

I think the restaurant thing is a huge draw for your application, actually - people love to talk about how medicine is a service industry. I went to a talk by the head of cardiothoracic surgery from a big hospital, and he said he thought every pre-med should spend time working at a gas station because it teaches you about service and working with people.

Bummer that your volunteering is not higher given you've been just working full-time for past 2 years...

I think you have an interesting application. It's unusual for someone with your background to also have dat MCAT and research experience. Schools love diversity - I'd try to play this up in your essays.

I'd probably shotgun apply to 10 schools in the top 30, 10 schools in the 30-60 range, and 10 schools in the 60-unranked range. Wouldn't be surprised if you got into Harvard or Penn, but also wouldn't be surprised if you didn't...
 
Will you be claiming disadvantaged status? Not many medical school applicants went to community college first, or have 6 years experience working in restaurants.

I think the restaurant thing is a huge draw for your application, actually - people love to talk about how medicine is a service industry. I went to a talk by the head of cardiothoracic surgery from a big hospital, and he said he thought every pre-med should spend time working at a gas station because it teaches you about service and working with people.

Bummer that your volunteering is not higher given you've been just working full-time for past 2 years...

I think you have an interesting application. It's unusual for someone with your background to also have dat MCAT and research experience. Schools love diversity - I'd try to play this up in your essays.

I'd probably shotgun apply to 10 schools in the top 30, 10 schools in the 30-60 range, and 10 schools in the 60-unranked range. Wouldn't be surprised if you got into Harvard or Penn, but also wouldn't be surprised if you didn't...

Hi Gurby, thanks so much for the encouragement. I don't think I can justify claiming disadvantaged status. I am a white male who grew up in an upper-middle class family in an urban area. I mostly worked so much so that I could be independent of my family. I went to community college, again, so that I could be independent of my family without taking out massive loans. I agree that my service industry experience is a low-key big draw to my application. Just hoping it will be enough. Though I do agree that my volunteering should really be higher.

Your advice is mostly what others have given me: apply extremely broadly and hope for the best. Was just hoping for some more input, as I really don't want to needlessly drop a grand or so if those upper-tier schools are a pipe dream. Thank you again!
 
Hi Gurby, thanks so much for the encouragement. I don't think I can justify claiming disadvantaged status. I am a white male who grew up in an upper-middle class family in an urban area. I mostly worked so much so that I could be independent of my family. I went to community college, again, so that I could be independent of my family without taking out massive loans. I agree that my service industry experience is a low-key big draw to my application. Just hoping it will be enough. Though I do agree that my volunteering should really be higher.

Your advice is mostly what others have given me: apply extremely broadly and hope for the best. Was just hoping for some more input, as I really don't want to needlessly drop a grand or so if those upper-tier schools are a pipe dream. Thank you again!

You've been working full time in a white-collar job for 2 years - you should be able to guiltlessly drop a grand on this crucially important step in your future career. Consider that any savings you have managed to stash away will go poof as soon as you get your first tuition bill anyways.
 
Top