(hmm, who are you batman?...)
I'm a first year also and I love the school. Not a lot of class time, very supportive staff, lots of resources. Students are very active in organizations and generally in making things happen. Pitt is a powerhouse in many clinical and research areas, e.g. transplants, immunology, pathology (HUGE dept), surgery (top 5). And the match list this year was solid. Plus they are really encouraging students to do research so if you want to be an academic you are well on your way. I like that Pitt has lots of different areas of concentrations including geriatrics, disabilities and care for the underserved.
Curriculum could be good or bad depending on your POV: we take one basic science and clinical skills course at a time, then after 2-4 courses there is a summative (cumulative exam) which sucks a$$. Getting honors is difficult if that matters to you since you have to get 1SD above the mean in both the average of the interim exams for those courses AND >1SD in the summative. In the spring most courses are 2 weeks long and the exams-every-2-weeks thing gets quite old. On the other hand, we see patients in the 2nd half of first year (nothing big, taking histories and learning physical exam skills).
Academics aside, the city is a good place to go to school, i.e. I would never live here as a working single, but there is enough to keep you busy when you have to study most of the time. Lots of activities through student groups, intramurals, and there is actually a club scene and salsa and jazz scene. And as a student I prefer it to a big city because I get distracted easily (why I can't surf SDN too much) and I take comfort in being able to take safety more for granted (I come from a big city). If you need a big city fix there is Philly, DC, NYC and Toronto within a day's drive.
email me if you have questions, good luck in your decision 🙂
sunflower