Dartmouth (w/ scholarship) vs UofA - Tucson

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Hitman964

Full Member
Joined
Feb 25, 2024
Messages
35
Reaction score
47
Hey everyone, I'm excited to be in this position choosing between two really great schools! I'm not entirely sure what speciality I'll end up in but have an interest in oncology, peds, and gen-surg. I'm in-state for AZ and was initially planning on attending UofA but then Dartmouth threw a $30k/year scholarship at me that lowered the COA quite significantly.

Dartmouth (COA: $280k)

Pros:
  • More prestigious/higher ranked (Ivy League)
  • More research opportunities available to students with individualized attention
  • Some clinical rotations are in California which they painted as a positive(?) Not sure how great I’d feel uprooting from home again to basically live in a dorm with another med student and do my rotations in a new city
Cons:
  • Isolated and snowy. Wasn’t a fan of how rural it was. I’ve spent my life growing up in a large city in AZ so idk what my adjustment is gonna be like
  • Higher cost of living than Tucson
  • Further from friends, family. Will be difficult for them to visit and for myself to visit as often as I’d like
  • Dartmouth-Hitchcock serves a very homogenous population. I want to be able to treat a diverse set of patients in my actual career so this might be a setback.
  • Mandatory attendance for most classes

UofA - Tucson (COA: $250k)

Pros:
  • Closer to home/family
  • Respected within AZ which is where I ultimately want to practice
  • Tucson >> Rural NH
  • Nicer facilities and more research funding
  • Opportunities to learn Spanish
Cons:
  • Not as prestigious
  • Class size of 120
  • Don’t have access to their match list. Have tried emailing the admissions office for it but they don’t give it out
 
From what you've written, I think UA is the best choice. The cons for Dartmouth are huge and the cons for UA seem to pale in comparison. Reach out to current students for a match list. Class size of 120 is pretty average. Prestige would only become relevant for oncology, and I think you can check the prestige box later with a good IM residency.
 
UA.

The prestige of Dartmouth Med is not near the undergrad and the cons, as mentioned above, are ginormous.
 
Thank y'all for your help. Felt bad turning down the Ivy but glad to see that I'm not crazy!
 
Top