Depends what you’re looking for in your career I think. Are you looking to stay in NYC? If you notice, Downstate matches heavily into NYC; whether that’s student preference or just limited reach outside the region I can’t say.
Also, do you want to do PC and have a mission that aligns w health equity? I’m pretty sure Loyola is one of those schools that is community focused which tends to lend itself to PC driven individuals. Could be they attract students who are interested in PC or that they simply don’t have the resources to match well into competitive specialties… if there’s abundant research and home programs, though, the latter likely isn’t the case. You’d have to look into that if you’re consider competitive specialties.
Think they’re pretty much neck and neck here… if you want to match in NYC, however, it’s a no brainer.