AlienHand said:
In response to your questions/statements:
- North Korea wants to destroy our country with nuclear weapons. At least they've made some serious threats in that direction. So does Iran, but they don't have the bomb - yet.
- No, I don't want Iran to have have nuclear weapons, because unlike most of the countries in the world with nukes, I'm afraid that they might actually use them.
- When I used the term "Axis of Evil," I was being kind of sarcastic. These countries do pose a threat to us, but I think it was counterproductive from a strategic and diplomatic standpoint for Bush to group them together.
- People who say we should "nuke them all" in various Middle Eastern countries are ignorant. I don't think any country should ever use nuclear weapons, and I think we should do everything we can to prevent more countries from joining the nuclear club.
- Our country has done some bad things in the past, e.g., our treatment of Native Americans. I have a major problem with more recent activities by our government with respect to human rights, e.g., Guantanamo Bay, Abu Ghraib, and apparently at a network of secret prisons in Eastern Europe. However, to equate these recent activities with "genocide" of the sort that is taking place in Africa is a big stretch.
-When has North Korea said that they want to destroy our country? I might have missed it.
-You're afraid that "unlike most countries in the world", Iran might actually use nukes if they had them. Um, excuse me, which is the only country in the world to use nuclear weapons (and on civilian population centers, no less)? Oh yeah, that would be US!
-Iran is not stupid. If they used nukes against the United States they would face massive retaliation and be exterminated as a nation. They want to get nukes because the U.S., Russia, Israel, and all the other big players in the world have them.
-Nuclear weapons are a deterrent and a stabilizing force in the world. The reason we haven't invaded North Korea (besides their lacking oil) and will NEVER invade North Korea is because they have nukes. We knew Saddam Hussein didn't have nukes or chemical weapons, and that's why we illegally invaded his country and decided to let our boys have at it murdering kids and raping women.
-It's not just "counterproductive from a diplomatic and strategic standpoint" for Bush to use the term "Axis of Evil". (What you're saying is, "I agree with the content of what he said, but I wish he hadn't said it in public." Kind of like how some people think blacks are lazy and criminal-minded, but they don't think it wise to say it publicly.) It just makes no sense from a rational standpoint. Iran, Iraq, and North Korea never formed an "axis" because they were never allied around any common cause in any meaningful way. They were not a team of bad guys working together to screw the U.S.
-Yes, I only come on this board like once every three months and then suddenly disappear. Guilty as charged. I wish I had more time to devote to this forum, but I haven't.
-Let me get this straight: we, the United States, have nuclear missiles capable of reaching any country on this earth, but we're so innocent and sweet and we don't want to hurt anyone - it's all about self-defense! - but if someone else wants to acquire even 1/40 of our nuclear capability they're somehow evil. You pretty much have to be a blind racist a$$hole to see things that way.
-"People who say that we should 'nuke them all' in various Middle Eastern countries are ignorant." You're right. And, of course, they don't represent most of America, right? They're some kind of rare exception. And yet it's odd that I've heard this sentiment repeatedly in my adult life. I remember reading in the letters section of TIME magazine in 1998 that "in countries like Afghanistan, there is no such thing as an innocent civilian."
When my grandfather came to this country during the first Gulf War, he was stunned to hear a Presbyterian minister, who should be among the moral leaders of our nation, give such violent speeches endorsing wholesale massacre and destruction of Iraq that he couldn't bear to attend church anymore.
-Whoever said that Palestinians are trying to destroy Israel should examine reality. Israel has ALREADY destroyed Palestine. They stole the land, uprooted the native inhabitants, and oppress and murder the ones who have remained. I should know, because Israel is my country.
Trust me, when I did my required military service in Israel, we were never told to take great pains to "respect human rights" and all that other bull crap you hear Israeli military officials say on TV all the time. We were openly encouraged to wreak havoc in the Territories, to terrorize the Palestinian population.
Do you remember Yitzhak Rabin's publicly stated "break their bones" policy in the 1980s? Did you know that we were given orders to shoot any Palestinian child who sang folk songs or did patriotic folk dances, or who raised a Palestinian flag or wore any combination of colors on his person that could be construed as a Palestinian flag?
My country is founded on erasing the national existence of another people. When they try to assert their existence, such as by participating in the Olympics or submitting a film to the Academy Awards, we attempt to crush them. Israel lodged a formal protest with the International Olympic Committee in 1996, saying that Palestinian athletes should not be allowed to compete since Palestine does not exist as a country. Odd, because Puerto Rico is a not a country, either, and they send teams to the Olympic Games, but Israel never protested their participation.
This winter the Israeli government and several (rabidly) pro-Israeli American groups lobbied the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences not to allow "Paradise Now" as a Foreign Film entry from "Palestine".
I guess our famous former prime minister Golda Meir's thoughts sum up our national attitude best: "Who are the Palestinians? They don't exist."
-So please, don't talk to me about who wants to destroy whom. Talk to me about who HAS destroyed and is destroying whom, and then we can have a real conversation.
HORNET
"I may indeed be a lefty-commie-pinko, but I'm smarter than the rest of you combined."
-Noam Chomsky