Dying language, ethnicity is a minority in a majority race-URM?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Halogas

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2012
Messages
24
Reaction score
0
Hi, I could not really find any thread that specifically discusses languages. In many countries, the language you speak defines your group. Without getting into the super specifics, my language is spoken by about 500,000-1 million people in the world (Ethnologue). I am a minority where I come from. I have never really hung out with people of my "race" because 1)I couldn't speak what they spoke ,2)I couldn't relate to them in any significant way. Where I come from, scholarships were not granted for people who spoke my language, no matter how high the scores(in the past that's how it was). We also look a lot different than the majority (on average, some of us stand out a lot more).

Of course the question to be asked is "Have I always thought of myself as an URM?"...the answer is yes. That is because:

1. In the US where I have lived since I was a child, there are very, very few speakers(probably only 10 in my state). The speakers are adults, not children. That's because most of the children ended up speaking English at home with their parents (my parents never spoke English at home so I ended up learning the language). We are all polyglots(not really the newer ones, I guess), those of us that live in countries like France end up speaking French and forget their native tongue.

2. As I had said before, I never really hung out with people from the country because I could not relate to them in anyway. Most of my friends were very diverse, coming from all sorts of backgrounds.

I am solid middle class. Of course, I don't know if they would actually see my language and consider me to be of a different group or not. (Different ethnic group). People who speak my language make up less than .5% of the countries population(where ~95% of the group lives), so you can imagine how many would be overseas.

Also, I said it is a dying language because most of us are going overseas and the children are not learning it + it is an oral language(so no writing, you have to learn it when you are a child or you won't know it).

(and in case anyone is curious: it is cool to speak a language which not many people speak, but it sucks not being able to talk with anyone outside of your family)

edit:I should probably mention that I would be marking down caucasian or asian as the race.
 
Last edited:
Are you from Burma? It sounds as though you are, or an Asian country with very similar dynamics. Anyway, I think you'll still have to identify as Asian, or mark "other" and explain. I don't recommend the latter, though. You could work this all into your application. I'm sure you'd get diversity points with an adcomm or two. Good luck!
 
I am not Burmese. I would probably be marking down Asian (that's assuming I mark that down based on nationality), but I am also able to mark down Caucasian (my "race"). Is there a way for me to put this stuff down on my AAMC or does each medical school read my application and decide individually?
 
URM means UNDERREPRESENTED minority, which means per your population there aren't enough doctors from your group in the united states, so it's not just about being a minority. You can write whatever you want, but if you're asian or caucasian, you're not considered a URM.
 
I don't know of any doctors from my "group". Although it looks like if I mark Asian or Caucasian I will not be considered at all...>.>

Thanks.
 
I don't know of any doctors from my "group". Although it looks like if I mark Asian or Caucasian I will not be considered at all...>.>

Thanks.
I understand your frustration, but unfortunately, you'll be lumped with all other Asians/Caucasians.
 
MCAT scores, interview offers, and med school matriculation are much more closely correlated with socioeconomic status than race. You stated you're "solidly middle class." I interpret that as you "have educated parents who earn a very comfortable living."

It's cool that you speak a rare language, but that has affected your opportunities much less than your middle class status. Look at the data in the MSAR. The people who are truly under-represented in medicine are people from low socioeconomic backgrounds, blacks, and Hispanics.
 
I don't know of any doctors from my "group". Although it looks like if I mark Asian or Caucasian I will not be considered at all...>.>

Thanks.
The point of URM status is to try to get doctors that more accurately reflect the US population. If there are hardly any of your group in the US population to start with, this is not really much of a concern. Unless your small group happens to be in a particularly high concentration within the local region of a particular medical school you apply to, and this group is underrepresented in medicine (not just a minority, but not proportionately represented) such as for example the Hmong in Minnesota, no adcom will consider you a URM and you cannot be reported in URM statistics.
 
URMs are underrepresented relative to their population size. So if there are 5,000 total individuals of xyz ethnicity and 4900 of them are physicians, they are not URMs even though they are a minority compared to caucasians or asians.
 
the URM and race card doesn't play well in med school application at least not for me. i had all the requriement to be URM, impoverished, etc etc. But even with a 3.5 GPA, and 34 MCAT, I only got interviews from 3 DO schools, and was on the waiting list at only 1 MD school. What you want to be is rich and white and private school. That'll be a stronger card to play.
 
Top