I'm completely in agreement on the fact that the historically black foundations have taken a huge hit in the past 10-15 years. Increasingly more schools are recruiting the best black minds to attend their school rather than their historic counterparts. I realize that the lower acceptance statistics does not diminish the quality of the education that is received at the schools, but acceptances are given to students that would not be considered competitive at other institutions. Up until 10-15 years ago, about 85% of minority dental/medical students went to historic institutions whereas today many more options are available, and are more advantageous than meharry/howard. Schools are actively pursuing and are willing to offset the cost of tuition just for the brightest minds to attend their school.
I believe it was courant that did a study in 2003 that found that the MD graduates of meharry and howard had the highest problems with malpractice and licensure issues than other schools in the country. I think as much as 10x more likely than the lowest school in the study.
Yes, they graduate many fine clinicians, but they are catering to underserved applicants with generally lower stats. Generally students come in with not as strong of a background as those entering other schools. As sad as it is, Affirmative Action does nothing but perpetuate the image of lowered expectations for minorities. It is pretty cliche, but even the old case of Chavis vs. Bakke brings up serious flaws in the system even as far back as '73.
There is always the argument that there is a large demand for minority physicans in all areas, but Affirmative Action is nothing but a failing solution to the real problems in the US. That being said, I was referring to NYU and BU in my post, I wasn't advising anyone to apply to Meharry/Howard simply for their lower incoming stats. I interviewed and was accepted to Howard last year. I applied simply for it being located in DC, but obviously it wasn't the school for me.
I don't feel a need to get rid of the tests for admissions, but instead get rid of the "quota" that schools must reach for federal funding. If i apply to a program and am rejected due to some fault of my own, lower gpa, lower scores etc, then so be it, that was my own fault. But if i was rejected simply to make room for a "minority" applicant, that serves no purpose. Reverse Discrimination is much more present in the healthcare field than anything else.