Ever get pulled over during residency?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Sea_Bass

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2016
Messages
77
Reaction score
51
I'm wondering if anyone's ever been pulled over on their way to the hospital and flashed their badge or given some story about how they're on their way to an emergency.

Does that work? Do you have a go-to emergency excuse like compartment syndrome or a patient in labor to get out of a speeding ticket?

Members don't see this ad.
 
I've never done it (never been pulled over actually!) and probably wouldn't have the guts to do it, but I've heard docs say they've used that excuse before.
 
I've been pulled over on my way home from work, but not for speeding. I was pulled over for "driving too carefully." The cop was concerned that I was following the posted 25 mph speed limit on an abandoned stretch of road where people routinely do 55. He was worried that my abiding the usually ignored limit might be a sign that I was drunk or otherwise trying to avoid police attention.

As for going in to work? I wouldn't dream of claiming an emergency unless there really was one. Even if that wasn't a great way to have the cop tail you all the way to work to be sure that you are going where you said you would... it is just bad karma. I mean, what a way to invite the code fairy to give you some real emergencies on your shift! Nah. I don't say the "q" word when there are no cases going on in the OR and I would never lie about something like that, lest it bite me.
 
I've been pulled over on my way home from work, but not for speeding. I was pulled over for "driving too carefully." The cop was concerned that I was following the posted 25 mph speed limit on an abandoned stretch of road where people routinely do 55. He was worried that my abiding the usually ignored limit might be a sign that I was drunk or otherwise trying to avoid police attention.

As for going in to work? I wouldn't dream of claiming an emergency unless there really was one. Even if that wasn't a great way to have the cop tail you all the way to work to be sure that you are going where you said you would... it is just bad karma. I mean, what a way to invite the code fairy to give you some real emergencies on your shift! Nah. I don't say the "q" word when there are no cases going on in the OR and I would never lie about something like that, lest it bite me.

Agree about not lying to police officers. Never a good move. That said, I'm perfectly fine saying it's quiet in the ED, or in the ICU, or wherever. If you honestly believe that you verbalizing the thought that it's quiet is somehow going to directly cause more people to come to the hospital, I worry about your decision making process.
 
I heard something about a resident getting his hand smacked at the hospital I did my TRI at for claiming to be returning to the hospital for an emergency. To note, there's provision in California's Vehicle Code that specifically cover physicians returning to the hospital for emergencies.

What I've heard happens more commonly is people just clips their hospital badge to their dash and most officers would end up giving a warning.
 
I personally never got pulled over in residency.

However, it was known that if you got pulled over and flashed your county hospital ID and said you worked on the trauma unit, they'd tell you to "have a nice night doc" and let you go. You didn't have to claim you were driving in for a trauma, the cops just did it out of respect for the trauma team. While I heard rumors of some of the CT and critical care fellows using this, I never actually heard anyone say they actually did it. One of my co-residents once got out of a ticket by fake-responding to a page from the hospital while actually calling his mom to make it look legit. The look on his face when I asked "why'd you lie when you could've just shown him your badge"? was hilarious. Hadn't thought of it.

I used to work in a smallish town and the cops would verify doctors were actually headed to the hospital; they'd either follow the doctor in if the doctor was insistent they couldn't wait for a ticket or call the hospital to verify there was a delivery/surgery/emergency in progress. I guess they'd had a few doctors that were known to falsely claim an emergency in the past...all of whom were ironically orthopedic surgeons who claimed to have to deliver a baby or do open heart surgery or something rather.
 
I haven't been pulled over since high school and college (once for stopping to let church traffic exit and once for a dead license plate bulb--both were warnings stops). I make sure to wake up on-time so I don't have to speed.

My intern year was in a smaller-ish city. The PD recommended if you got pulled over to just be 100% honest--"Sorry officer, I'm a physician at XYZ Hospital and I should know better." Be honest, apologize/acknowledged you made a mistake, let the chips fall where they may.

If you're really speeding because you got paged into the hospital for a WWII vet who's bleeding out or a preemie who keeps desatting--let them know--you either want them to let you off the hook right away or write that dark ticket as quick as possible so you can get going!

I would never fake a page or lie to an officer. Maybe it would get you out of the ticket, but we should be much better than that.
 
I'm wondering if anyone's ever been pulled over on their way to the hospital and flashed their badge or given some story about how they're on their way to an emergency.

Does that work? Do you have a go-to emergency excuse like compartment syndrome or a patient in labor to get out of a speeding ticket?

My hospital had a surgery resident who actually managed to get placed on probation and f- up his fellowship chances over something like this. The cops verified that he was not, in fact, coming in for the emergency he said he was and he got reported to his program director.
 
If I was speeding on my way to work, then I would tell them that.

If I was going elsewhere, I'd just turn to the officer and say, "Damn you got me". I'd slide my physician's license card into his hand when I give him my ID too though, just so he knows.

I've never been in the second situation and idk if I'd have the balls to actually do it, but I'm definitely considering it.
 
I've been pulled over on my way home from work, but not for speeding. I was pulled over for "driving too carefully." The cop was concerned that I was following the posted 25 mph speed limit on an abandoned stretch of road where people routinely do 55. He was worried that my abiding the usually ignored limit might be a sign that I was drunk or otherwise trying to avoid police attention.

As for going in to work? I wouldn't dream of claiming an emergency unless there really was one. Even if that wasn't a great way to have the cop tail you all the way to work to be sure that you are going where you said you would... it is just bad karma. I mean, what a way to invite the code fairy to give you some real emergencies on your shift! Nah. I don't say the "q" word when there are no cases going on in the OR and I would never lie about something like that, lest it bite me.

LOL what?

"I knew there would be some douche like you hanging around so I decided to follow the law"
 
I don't think one should really use their status as a physician to get out of a ticket. Funny story though...when I graduated medical school a couple friends and I went to Vegas. At the time I had always driven an old Chevy S10 so I never did really ever get to drive fast. In Vegas we of course rented a nice car and so while en route to the Grand Canyon I decided to push it to 100mph. I hit it for maybe a minute and slowed back down. Well, of course I was dumb enough to do it while going over a slight grade and there was a state trooper sitting on the other side. Clocked me at 100 in a 75. When he asked me to get out of the car (probably to make sure I wasn't intoxicated) he asked what my friends and I were doing in Arizona. Told him, that oddly enough he pulled over a med student soon-to-be resident, newly minted prosector for a county in my state, and police officer and we were here to celebrate our new jobs. Gave him my story about driving an S10 and never going 100 before. He laughed and told me his buddies would really get a kick out of this run. He then started talking about healthcare policy (read conservative state so I pulled some conservative lines to help the cause). He wished us well and to have fun. Got me out of a speeding ticket (never been pulled over before or since). Told me to watch my speed and even gave me the mile marker down the road where another state trooper was at!
 
I was just taking about this with my attendings the other day. Two of them had been pulled over when actually coming in from home for an emergency and both got lights and sirens escort to the hospital. One said in fellowship they covered a bunch of hospitals so she always figured out which one she could be on the way to in case she got pulled over but she never was.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-J120AZ using Tapatalk
 
Man, there's a lot of choir boys on this thread. Haven't you all ever heard the saying, "In life, the only people you should lie to is the police and your girlfriend"?

In other words, only lie to get out of trouble. Otherwise, tell the truth. I've been pulled over A LOT, almost every time gotten off with warnings. Never as a resident though. If you're proud of the fact that you've never been pulled over...well, you haven't lived. And I don't want to hang out with you.

When I was pre-med, I worked at a hospital where off-duty cops worked security. If you ever got pulled over in that town, all you had to do was say you worked at ______ hospital and they gave you a pass since you were basically co-workers. I think that's one reason cops are generous to physicians--especially ED/trauma physicians. They might rub shoulders at some point, so it's sort of a courtesy.

I usually carry my white coat and badge in my car. You can guarantee if I ever get pulled over, I'm telling the cop I'm on my way to the hospital for a super-serious emergency, and just give me a ticket and let me go 'cause I'm in too much of a hurry! I think I'd get off. Only thing is, I drive an old crappy car, and as you know, lay people expect anyone with an MD after their name to be be driving a big fancy car, so that might arouse suspicion. But otherwise, I'll take my chances on that excuse.
 
I was pulled over in a rural county for going 80 in a 75. Officer asked me to get out of the car and said
"I'm officer x", I responded "hi, I'm Dr Y"

He asked where I worked and my specialty, I told him I was a psych resident at the large local charity hospital. He said "oh man, we give y'all some crazy folks, slow it down and and have a good day doc"


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile app
 
I've been pulled over on my way home from work, but not for speeding. I was pulled over for "driving too carefully." The cop was concerned that I was following the posted 25 mph speed limit on an abandoned stretch of road where people routinely do 55. He was worried that my abiding the usually ignored limit might be a sign that I was drunk or otherwise trying to avoid police attention.

That's kind of stupid. If people routinely drive 55 mph on that abandoned stretch of road, why not just make the posted speed limit 55 mph?

Anyway, as for me, no, I've never done it. But I did think about it during those night calls I had during fellowship, when I would have to drive in to the hospital to see ICU patients who needed emergent CRRT or dialysis, or other emergent nephro consults. The consults often came around midnight and the roads would be virtually deserted at that time, meaning I could get away with speeding to a certain extent. I always thought about using that story of an emergency if I really did get pulled over. Technically, I wouldn't be lying 😀
 
Last edited:
I've never requested it but I have been pulled over and let go twice because of my doctor status.

1) Leaving late night clinic on a rural rotation (clinic with one attending routinely ran past 9pm). Didn't stop for a stop sign right by the hospital that I didn't see. Pulled over. Officer sees my white coat etc and asks if I work at the hospital. I reply yes I'm a resident working with Dr. X this month. He says "cops don't give doctors and nurses tickets around here, please slow down and be mindful of the signage and have a safe night."
2) On my way into the hospital one morning, going over a bridge a little faster than posted because I was running late. Pulled over. Officer sees me and asks if I recognize him. I don't at first but then he tells me he's been one of the officers sitting post outside one the ICU patients (a gang member arrested after a shootout but still on the vent after an exlap/massive transfusion). Has seen me rounding on my patients every morning. Tells me to please slow down and thank you for MY service. I thank him for his and go on my way.

I would never ever ask for it but am of course always respectful and grateful for the consideration.
 
Man, there's a lot of choir boys on this thread. Haven't you all ever heard the saying, "In life, the only people you should lie to is the police and your girlfriend"?
Anything besides a traffic ticket, if you say enough to a police officer to lie... then you've said too much. The only words you should be saying is, "I invoke and refuse to waive my 5th Amendment rights."
 
This happened to my husband about 15 years ago when was a resident at a program in a small(ish) program in a college town. He was speeding and got pulled over, told the cop he was on his was to the ER, showed his badge (was also wearing scrubs) and was let off with a warning.

However, when he got to the ER just a few minutes later, he walked in and they started laughing at him. The cop had actually called and checked to see if they recognized his name and they confirmed my husband's story.
 
I've been pulled over twice. Once, they saw my scrubs and asked if I worked at the trauma center and let me off. The other time, I was actually on my way in for a trauma and got a ticket. I suppose I used to speed a lot more than I should.
 
I've been pulled over 3 times in my 2+ years of residency, 0 tickets. 2 times were on the streets near my inner city hospital, and the police recognized my scrubs before getting to my window and just told me to slow it down and have a good day. The third time I was driving out to do an EMS shift on the helicopter and going way too fast on a country road. The state patrolman really game me an earful and let me know how dumb I was driving that fast with all the bad traumas I've seen. He didn't give me a ticket, but he did follow me all the way to the EMS base. I totally deserved one that time, and it did make me more conscious of my driving after that.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
I had a university cop pull me over as I was about to pull into the resident parking lot... The dingus took his time and ended up making me late for rounds... Nevermind that it was like 5:30 or 6 am and there wasn't anyone else on the street, he was just staked out there.
 
I had a university cop pull me over as I was about to pull into the resident parking lot... The dingus took his time and ended up making me late for rounds... Nevermind that it was like 5:30 or 6 am and there wasn't anyone else on the street, he was just staked out there.
Campus cops are the f***ing worst.

I've now had the experience twice (once as an undergrad, once the final year of my fellowship) when campus security was actually deputized and became an armed police force. They went from being lovable lunks that would usually fix things with minimal drama, to thugs who pulled out weapons and handcuffs at the slightest provocation, basically overnight.
 
Campus cops are the f***ing worst.

I've now had the experience twice (once as an undergrad, once the final year of my fellowship) when campus security was actually deputized and became an armed police force. They went from being lovable lunks that would usually fix things with minimal drama, to thugs who pulled out weapons and handcuffs at the slightest provocation, basically overnight.

lol campus police. They do their best to ticket poor college students. When I get called or sent mail about donating to the school I'm like lol nope
 
lol campus police. They do their best to ticket poor college students. When I get called or sent mail about donating to the school I'm like lol nope
I think it depends on the cops. Our campus cops were also local deputies (carried guns and everything), but I can count on one hand the number of people I knew who got into any trouble for the usual shenanigans. Their main concern was honestly keeping us safe, and so long as we weren't doing anything profoundly stupid they left us alone.
 
Back when I worked and volunteered in EMS I did get pulled over a twice. Both times I had not just an ID, but a real badge as well sitting on the dash. Both officers let me go with no more than a "Be careful." With my route in to the hospital here it is actually fairly difficult to speed, so if I get pulled over then chances are it truly is an emergency and I would have no problem letting them know that. Hopefully they would let me go.
 
Top