Exam Krackers daily MCAT quiz, full of errors?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

adamg

Full Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2008
Messages
56
Reaction score
0
Ok, the last two days I have seen what seems like 2 blatent mistakes on the EK daily quiz and I am wondering if I am truely going mad or if the daily quiz is full of ****.

First:

The last passage on VR, the one about aparteid in south africa and how it was so wonderful and made the south african economy boom. The one where the author basically blamed all the problems of south africa on the repeal of aparteid.

Question: What is the author's opinion of the (name of law that segregated where black and whites could live)?

A. denounce it
B. Ambivalent about it
C. Neutral
D. Condone it

Obviously from the main idea and the tone of the passage the author likes aparteid and thus would condone it.

I would be willing to bet my life on "d" being correct.

Answer: A, condemns it, WTF!

reasoning: The author dosn't talk at all about how aparteid disenfranchised blacks in south africa but only talks about the strong economy and whites.

Am I insane or does the fact that he talks only positively about aparteid and dosn't mention disenfranchisement of blacks mean the author condones it!

Second, today's physics problem.

A 3000 watt motor pulls 350 kg weight up a mine shaft for 30 seconds at constant velocity.

Question: If the system were changed so that only a 100 kg weight had to be pulled in 30 seconds what power motor is needed then?

A. 670 w
B. 870 w
C. 1300 w
D. 1500 w

I set the ratio of 350/3000=100=x and solved to get slighty under 1000 w, (realized that doing that in my head would be faster but still got answer B).

Answer: A, 670 w

reasoning: the shaft is 20 m tall so find work by F*D = 100 kg*10= 1000 N* 20=20,000 J / 30 seconds= slightly less than 700 w.

BUT at no time does the passage say the shaft is 20 meters high!

So I checked maybe you had to calculate the height from the info in the passage.

P= FV

so V= P/F

3000 watts/3500 N=.87 m/s velocity *30 seconds=about 26 meters!

26 meters*1000 N= 26,000 J/30 seconds= 2600/3= just under 900 watts! THAT IS ANSWER B!

Useing their own logic I got the same answer!

By the way only 11% of people got that answer right!

So am I going insane or is the EK daily mcat quiz full of errors?
 
I remember reading the South Africa passage, and I didn't think the author was condoning apartheid.

Where is the physics question? I can't seem to find it. Is it in the 1001 book or the review material?
 
I read the South Africa passage and it was clearly written by someone with a conservative bend (in fact, if memory serves, one of the questions in that passage asks you to identify who the target audience would be). It very much condoned apartheid (the passage ends by suggesting that areas of South Africa that were most affected by the apartheid repeal became mostly black and dangerous within a short period of time).

I also agree with the physics question issue. If someone would be able to suggest how you can determine the height of the mine from what little information they provide that would be great.

There are a few questions like these and they usually only have 10-24% of the people getting it right (i.e. by guessing).
 
Last edited:
Top