Going for a completely out there personal statement...?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Status
Not open for further replies.

snowys435

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 5, 2012
Messages
426
Reaction score
102
Hi Everyone,

I've been having some trouble regarding my personal statement. Ive been told my pre medical dean to ditch pretty much the whole statement and talk about my commitment to medicine in the past couple of years.

Currently what I have is very out of the box and not the typical personal statement but it does a very good job of conveying who I am. I'm not sure it's worth the risk. Are there already any thoughts on this.

Would anyone be willing to read and give some feedback?


Thanks!

Members don't see this ad.
 
Unless you used to be homeless or were a child soldier in Africa, I think it's usually better to have a vanilla personal statement than one that might stick out in a bad way. The problem is that it gets sent to everybody, so unlike a secondary essay, might not be worth the risk.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Doctor Strange-sent

Mt. Kilimanjaro would you be willing to read it as well and see ifs worth the risk?
 
Well I only drew that feedback from my pre medical dean and no one else. Everyone else loved it.
 
Well I only drew that feedback from my pre medical dean and no one else. Everyone else loved it.

If you need an extra read/thoughts on whether it's too out-there, I'm free to read as well.

The typical mantra from current medical students and all the personal statement books is to not make it to crazy or out there. They just want to know plain and simple--why do you like medicine!
 
Doctor Strange-sent

Mt. Kilimanjaro would you be willing to read it as well and see ifs worth the risk?

Honestly I think it's a risk assessment you have to make. I've never been on an adcom, so I have no idea what they consider "out there." Despite the advice that's usually given, I think writing a engaging, unique personal statement is nearly impossible for most applicants, though, so it's probably safer to write the normal PS that explains why you want to be a doctor and provides a few examples.
 
I'm happy to read it to tell you if it seems palatable, though like most of the posters here, I won't be able to tell you exactly how it's perceived by an admissions committee. PM it as an attachment if you'd like.
 
I'd be happy to read it also. Feel free to PM it to me.
 
Curious to read it as well. Send pm
 
Hi Everyone,

I've been having some trouble regarding my personal statement. Ive been told my pre medical dean to ditch pretty much the whole statement and talk about my commitment to medicine in the past couple of years.

Currently what I have is very out of the box and not the typical personal statement but it does a very good job of conveying who I am. I'm not sure it's worth the risk. Are there already any thoughts on this.

Would anyone be willing to read and give some feedback?


Thanks!

Don't take risks. An "out-there" PS can raise a red flag. I know someone who did not get any interviews because of his unconventional PS (schools told him so when asked at the end of the application cycle). An average PS that describes your commitment to medicine in a conventional way, though will not make you stand out, most likely not be a red flag. An "out-there" PS alone can prevent you from getting interviews.
 
Last edited:
I've read it.

Stylistically, the PS is a tad bit different, but it's not as completely "out there" as the OP thinks. It does, however, take a good writer to pull something off like this, and I think the OP is a pretty good writer. I took a more creative approach to my PS also, and I got very positive comments about it on the interview trail everywhere I went.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
I'm happy to read it and give feedback as well, if you want to PM me
 
Don't take risks. An "out-there" PS can raise a red flag. I know someone who did not get any interviews because of his unconventional PS (schools told him so when asked at the end of the application cycle). An average PS that describes your commitment to medicine in a conventional way, though will not make you stand out, most likely not be a red flag. An "out-there" PS alone can prevent you from getting interviews.
I think it depends how unconventional it is. there are some unconventional personal statements that are very strong and really work well, still answering the question of "why medicine" albeit in a unique way
 
I'm thinking of writing my personal statement in iambic pentameter. What do you guys think?
 
Don't take risks. An "out-there" PS can raise a red flag. I know someone who did not get any interviews because of his unconventional PS (schools told him so when asked at the end of the application cycle). An average PS that describes your commitment to medicine in a conventional way, though will not make you stand out, most likely not be a red flag. An "out-there" PS alone can prevent you from getting interviews.

Depends how strong of a writer you are. I think a unique PS will get you some extra attention if done well.
 
One of you needs to post an example of an 'out there' personal statement. After reading about 60+ example PS's, I don't think that I would consider anything 'out there' short of the PS being terrible.
 
I think it is a mistake. I wrote a rather "out there" PS that I was proud of. Sent it to a friend of mine who was involved in admissions when she was a fourth-year student at her medical school. Her words: "It's an extremely well-written personal statement, but if you submit it, you will have zero chance of being accepted."

Of course, "out there" is totally subjective, but the message I got from her is that it's better to write a strong, conventional PS than to go out on a limb and risk having your file tossed in the trash. You can be interesting without being nutty; it just might take a little more work.

Good luck!

-Bill R.
 
OP sent me his PS. It was incredible, very unique yet strikes just the right chords to bring the music of medicine to my ears:

"Mbuto."
My African driver springs to his feet.
"Yes, Sahib."
"Pass me another baby, I think this one has died." I lay the dead infant in the pile by my feet. What I'd really like him to do is pass me an ice-cold bottle of the local beer. Compassion is hot, thirsty work. There is no ice in this wretched refugee camp, mores the pity, but as I'm here to help I will suffer in silence. I stare into the eyes of the African baby who is suffering from HIV or dengue fever or something gross, look out into the hot, dusty savannah and ask, "Why? Why gender-neutral and non-judgmental Diety (or Deities) does this have to happen?"
"And Why, Mbuto, is the air-conditioning on my Land Rover broken again?"
"One thousand pardons, Sahib, but the parts have not arrived."
I will suffer. I have lived a life of privilege and my suffering serves to link me to the suffering of mankind. I roll the window down. God it's hot. How can people live here? Why don't they move where it's cool? Still, I see by the vacant stare from the walking skeletons who insist on blocking the road that they appreciate my compassion and I know that in a small way, I am making a difference in their lives.
Africa. Oh wretched continent! How long must you suffer? How long will you provide the venue to compensate for a low MCAT score? How many must die before I am accepted to a top-tier medical school?
When did I first discover that I, myself, desired to be a doctor? Some come to the decision late in life, often not until the age of five. The non-traditional applicants might not know until they are seven or even, as hard as it is to believe, until the end of ninth grade. I came, myself, to the realization that I, myself, wanted to be a doctor on the way through the birth canal when I realized that my large head was causing a partial third degree vaginal laceration. I quickly threw a couple of sutures into the fascia between contractions so strong was my desire to help people.
My dedication to service was just beginning. At five I was counseling the first-graders on their reproductive options. By twelve I was volunteering at a suicide crisis center/free needle exchange hot-line for troubled transgendered teens. I'll never forget Jose, a young Hispanic male with HIV who had just been kicked out of his casa by his conservative Catholic parents. He had turned to black tar heroin as his only solace and he was literally at the end of his rope when he called.
"How about a condom, Hose," I asked. The J, as you know, is pronounced like an H in Spanish.
Annoying silence on the line. Hesus, I was there to help him.
"Condoms will solve all of your problems," I continued, "In fact, in a paper of which I was listed as the fourth author, we found that condoms prevent all kinds of diseases including HIV which I have a suspicion is the root of your depression."
More silence. No one had ever had such a rapport with him. He was speechless and grateful and I took his sobs as evidence of my compassion.
"Hey, it was double-blinded and placebo controlled, vato." Cultural competence is important and I value my diverse upbringing which has exposed me to peoples of many different ethnicities. I always say "What up, Homes," to the nice young negroes who assemble my Big Mac and I think they accept me as a soul brother. "
"We also have needles, amigo. Clean needles would prevent HIV too."
My desire to be a physician has mirrored my desire to actualize my potential to serve humanity in many capacities. This may be something unheard of from medical school applicant but I have a strong desire to help people. I manifest this desire by my dedication to obtaining all kinds of exposure to all different kinds of people but mostly those from underserved and underprivileged populations. In fact, during a stint in a Doctors Without Borders spin-off chapter I learned the true meaning of underserved while staffing a mall health care pavilion in La Jolla, California.
Most of my friends are black or latino and I am a "Junior Cousin" of the Nation of Islam where I teach infidel abasement techniques to the Mohammed (PBUHN) Scouts. I also am active in the fight for women's reproductive rights except of course for women in Afghanistan who were better off before our current racist war.
As Maya Angelou once said, "All men (and womyn) are prepared to accomplish the incredible if their ideals are threatened." I feel this embodies my philosophy best because the prospect of grad school is too horrible to contemplate.
 
If it truly conveys who you are and why you want to pursue Medicine then sure.

I tried to stretch mine a bit originally, but since the story was unusual, it required about half the paper to properly explain the details. After a lot of reader feedback, I settled into something a bit more vanilla. But it definitely answers the question of "Why you? and Why Medicine?"

That said, I don't know how much a great personal statement (if it works) even separates those who get accepted and those who don't. But it can definitely negatively effect you. So I would think its not worth the risk, but I would have many people experienced in reading PS' read it first.
 
Hi! My PS is also not "vanilla". It is my story and could never be written by anyone else. I think that is most important! I am an anthropology student so I really played on that and shaped culture into medicine. Feel free to PM.
 
Someone should just copy and paste 5200 characters from the novel Finnegans Wake, then use the last 100 characters to write 'me want be doctor fix fix heal!'
 
Pro tip: never send any part of your application to another pre-med.

I can take a quick look if you still want another pair of eyes.
 
In all honesty, the personal statement is just filler. It's not the first thing adcoms will see or the first thing interviewers read. Yeah, you don't want it to suck but if you already have stellar grades, activities there's really no reason for you to go out on a limb and look like a fool. If you have mediocre grades, activities than you want to put a little more effort into the PS to convey your "love of medicine". If you're an amazing writer, on the other hand, go for the homerun but I don't think many of us are that talented or have that unique of an experience to really make an adcom/interviewer say "wow, I've never read something so amazing in my x years of doing this". If you're thinking about it, someone else has probably already done it. Keep it vanilla until the interview and then rock it.
 
Pro-tip #2 - Anyone can claim to be a medical student on SDN.

True, but SkinMD has been around long enough to be trusted. I am happy to read the OP's statement as well and give feedback. You can also often tell whether or not someone is likely to be a med student based upon time here, prior posts (e.g., look in their post Hx for when they took the MCAT, which schools apparently applied to, etc.; the profess is long enough that someone is unlikely to have spent 2+ years making up B.S. posts properly spaced out to show an entire MCAT prep and then app cycle), post content, etc.
 
If you PM me the old and new one I can take a look
 
True, but SkinMD has been around long enough to be trusted. I am happy to read the OP's statement as well and give feedback. You can also often tell whether or not someone is likely to be a med student based upon time here, prior posts (e.g., look in their post Hx for when they took the MCAT, which schools apparently applied to, etc.; the profess is long enough that someone is unlikely to have spent 2+ years making up B.S. posts properly spaced out to show an entire MCAT prep and then app cycle), post content, etc.

I'm not saying he isn't. But I still think it's an important thing to realize.
 
My personal statement wasn't super vanilla, and I actually had a dean of admissions at one of the schools I applied to tell me it was one of the best he had seen. That being said, it was all on topic - why do I want to be a doctor, and why should the medical profession want me? I had a lot of experiences outside of mine with the medical field that are quite unique and have played a huge role in making me who I am now, and therefore, have been a part of the path that led me to medicine.

If your answer to those questions (why do I want to be a doctor, and why should the medical profession want me?) includes more information about your life or experiences, than go for it - just make sure to tie it all back and make it relevant.
 
Hi Everyone,

I've been having some trouble regarding my personal statement. Ive been told my pre medical dean to ditch pretty much the whole statement and talk about my commitment to medicine in the past couple of years.

Currently what I have is very out of the box and not the typical personal statement but it does a very good job of conveying who I am. I'm not sure it's worth the risk. Are there already any thoughts on this.

Would anyone be willing to read and give some feedback?


Thanks!

K.I.S.S. By going too far "out of the box" you are likely to get more "WTFs?" than people that think it is actually interesting.

Survivor DO
 
Pro-tip #2 - Anyone can claim to be a medical student on SDN.

well yea, you shouldn't trust someone who says they're a med student but joined yesterday and has 2 posts. there are plenty of well-established med students and residents around who are extremely easy to identify.

also, OP, there is a PS reading service run by NickNaylor and a bunch of volunteer med students who he has vetted (or is in the process of doing so). You might want to consider using that resource.
 
ok I actually have a new draft that I thought was less out there but am still getting told it is out there. I basically did a lot of story telling and didnt make it super explicit. at this point im not sure what to do. i feel it comveys who i am but i didnt use the tradtional outline.
 
would any of you mind reading my personal statement stil? i have since fixed it but im not sure if it is still not coventional enough....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top