Hi all,
I'm in the somewhat unique position of being fairly certain of the specific area of medicine I want to practice (Bariatrics: It was my undergrad research and really lifelong interest and reason for going to medical school so I'm not likely to change my mind), but having multiple options of residencies in order to pursue this interest. Surgical weight loss seems more evidence based, but I never thought of myself before as a surgeon. After observing many cases in the OR, however, I think I can do it with enough training. It also seems to be getting more and more prone to a mostly office practice 10 years out (when I'll be finished residency and fellowship) with SILS and trans-oral approaches to surgery. I've also worked with medical bariatricians and while options are more limited (and drug pipeline not as promising), it can certainly be done. The best approach seems IM with or without Endo/GI fellowships after.
My main question is how does a 5 year surgery residency compare to a 3 year IM residency in terms of hour, call, physical demand, etc. I know it varies by program but are there some general differences hours and lifestyle wise aside from the obvious 2 extra years?
Also, whether it's a weight loss dug or surgical intervention, BOTH are really just "tools" and behavior intervention and diet and exercise are key. I know it doesn't pay as well, but I really like this part. My thinking is that since bariatric surgery is much more established than bariatric medicine and that surgeons can obviously also write perspescriptions and work in multidisciplinary teams, surgery would give me one additional "tool" (as well as a much more clear pathway) I wouldn't have if I went the medical way. Does anyone have any thoughts on this? Specifically, is it misguided to think a few extra years of residency would be worth it to gain a very powerful additional skillset to help my patients? I know not many baiatric surgeons want to counsel and do much followup because of the economics, but suppose I'm willing to sacrifice higher pay. Is it realistic to be in OR one day a week, do 10 surgical cases for those pts who need surgery, and spend the other days following up and working medically with patients who don't need surgery? Would I know enough after med school and a GS residency to also medically manage patients?
Thank you very much for any insight on either general IM vs. GS surgery or bariatrics specifically!
I'm in the somewhat unique position of being fairly certain of the specific area of medicine I want to practice (Bariatrics: It was my undergrad research and really lifelong interest and reason for going to medical school so I'm not likely to change my mind), but having multiple options of residencies in order to pursue this interest. Surgical weight loss seems more evidence based, but I never thought of myself before as a surgeon. After observing many cases in the OR, however, I think I can do it with enough training. It also seems to be getting more and more prone to a mostly office practice 10 years out (when I'll be finished residency and fellowship) with SILS and trans-oral approaches to surgery. I've also worked with medical bariatricians and while options are more limited (and drug pipeline not as promising), it can certainly be done. The best approach seems IM with or without Endo/GI fellowships after.
My main question is how does a 5 year surgery residency compare to a 3 year IM residency in terms of hour, call, physical demand, etc. I know it varies by program but are there some general differences hours and lifestyle wise aside from the obvious 2 extra years?
Also, whether it's a weight loss dug or surgical intervention, BOTH are really just "tools" and behavior intervention and diet and exercise are key. I know it doesn't pay as well, but I really like this part. My thinking is that since bariatric surgery is much more established than bariatric medicine and that surgeons can obviously also write perspescriptions and work in multidisciplinary teams, surgery would give me one additional "tool" (as well as a much more clear pathway) I wouldn't have if I went the medical way. Does anyone have any thoughts on this? Specifically, is it misguided to think a few extra years of residency would be worth it to gain a very powerful additional skillset to help my patients? I know not many baiatric surgeons want to counsel and do much followup because of the economics, but suppose I'm willing to sacrifice higher pay. Is it realistic to be in OR one day a week, do 10 surgical cases for those pts who need surgery, and spend the other days following up and working medically with patients who don't need surgery? Would I know enough after med school and a GS residency to also medically manage patients?
Thank you very much for any insight on either general IM vs. GS surgery or bariatrics specifically!