How bad does residency suck?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ekimsurfer
  • Start date Start date
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
E

ekimsurfer

I mean... they "limit" you to 80 hours of work which is like telling a person that you're only to go break ONE of their hands (i.e. you're still largely ****ed).

Does choosing a higher specialty with a long residency make more sense than choosing a lesser specialty/field where you have a short (3 year res.) but the money isn't as good once you get out.

For example, orthoped, gen surg., plastics, ENT where you have 5+ years but when you get out you can make $500K VS. something like ER where you have 3 years and make around $200K

And the way i see it, a job is a job. Everything you have to do day to day is going to become somewhat dull. All my drives and interests are in things outside of medicine i.e. surfing, climbing, boating, skiing, etc.

My problem is that i don't want to see my 20's go down the tube and regret it (even though i might be in a more financially sound position).
 
ekimsurfer said:
And the way i see it, a job is a job. Everything you have to do day to day is going to become somewhat dull. All my drives and interests are in things outside of medicine i.e. surfing, climbing, boating, skiing, etc.

My problem is that i don't want to see my 20's go down the tube and regret it (even though i might be in a more financially sound position).

Why don't you become a forest ranger, or a surf/ski instructor? Why go into medicine if you don't really love the field and would rather have more free time? (Not a flame, just curious.)
 
residency CAN suck, but I think that if you pick something you really like it doesnt suck so much. The whole money/lifestyle subject is all over every forum, and it gets old because you are the only person who can determine what you really value and want. Sometimes residency sucks, but I would venture there arent many jobs that never suck, and certainly no jobs that offer everything medicine offers. People on SDN complain about medicine all the time, but it seems like no one ever discusses the unique opportunities it provides. Find a specialty you really like and go enjoy your career.
 
tr said:
Why don't you become a forest ranger, or a surf/ski instructor? Why go into medicine if you don't really love the field and would rather have more free time? (Not a flame, just curious.)

I have given this very much thought, but when it comes down to it... a.) i'm not good enough to become a ski instructor b.) you don't make enough money to do other things besides that c.) you can end up taking something enjoyable and making it no longer fun

all in all, i very much like science. it just seems that as of late, everyone else does everything they can to try and make medicine miserable. i'm not looking to own a ferrari or anything. my goals are to be able to not worry about paying bills, enjoy as best i can my job, and be able to have a somewhat good amount of free time.

all in all i think medicine sets me up for the best of this. but my question is, why do they have to make residencies like extended bootcamps? do you really learn taht much better when you are rounding for 15 hours a day?

and really, for all functional purposes it seems that during residency you have no free time at all to do anything. so basically if your residency is 5 years, do you get any time off in there?
 
kungfufishing said:
residency CAN suck, but I think that if you pick something you really like it doesnt suck so much. The whole money/lifestyle subject is all over every forum, and it gets old because you are the only person who can determine what you really value and want. Sometimes residency sucks, but I would venture there arent many jobs that never suck, and certainly no jobs that offer everything medicine offers. People on SDN complain about medicine all the time, but it seems like no one ever discusses the unique opportunities it provides. Find a specialty you really like and go enjoy your career.

you have very good points.

so here's a hypothetical... is it worth becoming a surgeon which i probably will like more than ER where i will start practice at around 33 and make very good money but work a great deal of time. or is it worth it to become an ER physician where maybe i will not enjoy the work as much, but i can practice by 28 and work less hours?

do you see what i'm saying?
 
well, again, which one do you enjoy more? As a future EP myself, Im biased. Emergency Medicine is great. Rotate through the things you think you might want to do. Seems to me that a lot of people who go into surgery really love operating enough that the necessary sacrifices - time in the hospital, time doing things at work but outside the OR, a rough residency - are worth it to them. EM seems to be love it or hate it for some people. Have you rotated through both?
 
meister said:
Wow, 28? How old are you now? If everything goes as planned, I wouldn't be practicing anything until I'm like 30.

i'll be 25 at graduation of school.

and to answer the kungfu, i have not rounded in either yet.

i think surgery would be cool, but they spend so much time in the hospital that i don't think i want the life. they make tons of money but they work their ass off for it.

as far as EM goes, my grips with that are 1. you see many people who don't care for themselves and are the bottom of the social barrel 2. you don't really get to do procedures

i kind of think as EM docs as glorified triage nurses. and don't take it the wrong way, because i think they have the best job lifestyle of all physicians. it's just that i don't know if it could get old after a while. but again i think after any amount of time, everything becomes monotony.
 
ekimsurfer said:
i kind of think as EM docs as glorified triage nurses. and don't take it the wrong way, because i think they have the best job lifestyle of all physicians.

Here I was going to give you some reasoned advice and you had to pop off with that offensive crap. 😡

Well let me hold my bile for a moment and see if I can still help you. If you don't like EM and you do like surgery you should do surgery. If it's the lifestyle that bothers you you would have to suck it up during residency but then you can do what you want. You could look into part time practice opportunities, shared practices, etc. You might post on the surgery board and ask what opportunities for less than 100 hr/week surgery practices are out there.

Now back to the bile. The triage nurse comment is as old as dirt and is offensive as hell. I've said before and I'll say again if you don't think we're good enough to see you patients why do you keep sending to my ER. If I'm so dumb keep your clinic open 24/7 and more power to ya.

ekimsurfer said:
as far as EM goes, my grips with that are 1. you see many people who don't care for themselves and are the bottom of the social barrel 2. you don't really get to do procedures.

Who do you think you're going to see on call. Are you going to be one of those who askes what kind of insurance the patient has and then adjusts treatment accordingly? feh!
 
Damn ekimsurfer that comment you made about ER docs was mighty offensive. I dont blame docB for responding that way.
The way I see it, if you want prestige, money and early burnout then by all means go for surgery. I respect the hell out of surgeons because they have to bust their asses for their money. I was thinking about looking at surgery as a possible career choice but after knowing what I now know about life as a surgeon I dont believe its for me.
Maybe I'm just different from most other SDN'rs out there but maybe, just maybe there are more important things than money out there.
Who knows if you would be more happy as an ER doc than a surgeon.
 
docB said:
Here I was going to give you some reasoned advice and you had to pop off with that offensive crap. 😡

Well let me hold my bile for a moment and see if I can still help you. If you don't like EM and you do like surgery you should do surgery. If it's the lifestyle that bothers you you would have to suck it up during residency but then you can do what you want. You could look into part time practice opportunities, shared practices, etc. You might post on the surgery board and ask what opportunities for less than 100 hr/week surgery practices are out there.

Now back to the bile. The triage nurse comment is as old as dirt and is offensive as hell. I've said before and I'll say again if you don't think we're good enough to see you patients why do you keep sending to my ER. If I'm so dumb keep your clinic open 24/7 and more power to ya.



Who do you think you're going to see on call. Are you going to be one of those who askes what kind of insurance the patient has and then adjusts treatment accordingly? feh!

bro, i definitely did not mean to press your buttons like that so let me clear something up.

i've always been told that ER docs are a jack of all trades, master of none. and it is true that you have to refer out the cases for surgery to other specialties.

BUT... i've also learned taht teh ER physician is one who is a doctor more for teh fact of having a steady job that lets them enjoy their outside interests.

I have several friends taht are ER physicians and none taht are surgeons... why? because surgeons think they are gods gift to the world.

and i'm sorry you took my comment the wrong way but it was meant to imply that the job doesn't seem as procedural and not that the position is unneccessary.

take a chill pill... i'm leaning more towards EM than any other field.
 
Dr Who said:
Damn ekimsurfer that comment you made about ER docs was mighty offensive. I dont blame docB for responding that way.
The way I see it, if you want prestige, money and early burnout then by all means go for surgery. I respect the hell out of surgeons because they have to bust their asses for their money. I was thinking about looking at surgery as a possible career choice but after knowing what I now know about life as a surgeon I dont believe its for me.
Maybe I'm just different from most other SDN'rs out there but maybe, just maybe there are more important things than money out there.
Who knows if you would be more happy as an ER doc than a surgeon.

first... prestige is for babies.

i could give a **** less.

what i give a **** about is having a job that allows me as much free time to pursue my interests.

i'm sorry you took my post the wrong way, but it is the truth that the ER isn't the one doing the actual fixing in many cases and that could get annoying. It's like you always have to send your patient out to have something done. And like i just said, obviously the ER doc is needed... because who else knows enough about everything to make a decision on where the patient needs to go.

The ER doc deals a lot with triage... that's just the name of the game. i guess i could of been a bit more tactful in my sayings, but deal with it... i'm more for ER than anything else.

and success is measure in your quality of life, not by how prestigious you are.
 
Dr Who said:
Damn ekimsurfer that comment you made about ER docs was mighty offensive. I dont blame docB for responding that way.
The way I see it, if you want prestige, money and early burnout then by all means go for surgery. I respect the hell out of surgeons because they have to bust their asses for their money. I was thinking about looking at surgery as a possible career choice but after knowing what I now know about life as a surgeon I dont believe its for me.
Maybe I'm just different from most other SDN'rs out there but maybe, just maybe there are more important things than money out there.
Who knows if you would be more happy as an ER doc than a surgeon.
Oh puh-leeease ! Keep the ''holier than thou'' attitude to yourself.
 
ekimsurfer said:
i've always been told that ER docs are a jack of all trades, master of none. and it is true that you have to refer out the cases for surgery to other specialties.

and i'm sorry you took my comment the wrong way but it was meant to imply that the job doesn't seem as procedural and not that the position is unneccessary.

I won't comment on your triage nurse comment, as it has been handled well by docB, but about your other comments above... I think that Emergency Medicine Physicians are the master of resuscitations and, obviously, "emergent care." Would you want a hospitalist coding your grandmother? Or a surgeon delivering your wife's baby? A psychiatrist intubating ( 😱 )? There is a place for all specialties. If every physician kept his hours open 24 a day, there would be far less need for EPs.

And I think EM is procedure heavy . Maybe not compared to any of the surgical specialties, but we do lines, intubations, deliveries, LPs, lac repairs, crics, resuscitations, thoracotomies, ultrasounds, DPLs, pericardiocentesis, blah blah.

Q
 
Forgive me, as I want to make a comment but I am not going to be a surgeon or an EM doc, yet I respect both. It seems to me that making the comment you did about EM docs is very dissrespectful. Let me explain!
First, where did you go to med school at because all you are talking about is sending out your patients to have other docs do something procedural. Have you been in the real medical world? Because that happens in medicine. If you have a pt that you cannot care for, ie.. internal medicine doc with a pt with gallstones--> they go to surgeon, EM doc with pt in ER with multiple fractures--> they go to orthopod, etc.... This is medicine and it seems your medical school should have prepared you for this. No One doctor in today's healthcare can take care of all issues and to think you can is irresponsible and ignorant. It is in your best interest to respect all the fields of medicine even if you think some are better fits for you than others, because one day you may need that doc that you think is "just a glorified triage nurse." So my comments to you are, Find you niche and go for it. There is no field of medicine that you will like all aspects of, that is irrational. There are always going to be advantages (things you like) and disadvantages (things you don't) in any field of medicine or any work for that matter. You just have to be smart enough to weigh these and determine what field fits you best.
Good luck in your medical endeavors, but learn some maturity and respect others because you don't know whose toes you may be stepping on!
 
if you havent rotated through either field, you might want to wait until you pass judgement on which specialty to pursue. Im not a surgeon, but I can tell you that EM is not quite how you imagine it to be. And believe it or not, most of the people I know who chose it did so for reasons other than lifestyle. The lifestyle isnt bad, but it has plenty of negatives to go along with the positives. Looking at your other posts, I think you are either an MS1 or a premed. You might take into account that there are many residents and attendings who read these forums, which means there is some good advice to be had. It also means that spouting ignorant opinions might piss a few people off. When you have rotated through the fields you are talking about, you'll probably have a lot more accurate idea about which one you like better as well as more educated opinions.
 
QuinnNSU said:
Would you want a hospitalist coding your grandmother?

I don't understand this comment. I would want a hospitalist coding my grandmother. A hospitalist is an IM trained doc and that's who usually runs codes on the floor. I would think they would be exactly who you'd want althought I'm sure ER docs know how to run one well also. Of course my school doesn't have ER residents so maybe it works differently where you are.
 
I'm sorry your pu$$ies are all so sore from my comment, but deal with it.

the fact is that EM docs don't do as in-depth procedures as surgeons. you can whine all you want, but like i said deal with it.

and as for teh EM docs on here, i never said i disrespected your field or that you are any less important in the scheme of healthcare. you guys must have the napolean complex or something or maybe you guys haven't been laid in a while.

in any case, this wasn't mean to bash any single specialty... i was simply asking about how bad residency hours are and if don't feel like contributing anymore (after my comments made your pu$$y hurt... i.e. grow some balls and be a man), then please stay out of my thread so that others may contribute to the original post question of whether it is worth waiting out teh longer residency for a different specialty.

and once more... i like ER docs, my friends who are ER docs just give me the real deal on it and tell it like it is. If you feel offended then i'm sorry.
 
fourthyearmed said:
I don't understand this comment. I would want a hospitalist coding my grandmother. A hospitalist is an IM trained doc and that's who usually runs codes on the floor. I would think they would be exactly who you'd want althought I'm sure ER docs know how to run one well also. Of course my school doesn't have ER residents so maybe it works differently where you are.

bro it's obvious that there is a sore spot here. they are lashing out for some reason. in any case you are correct and don't let these guys ride your sac.
 
fourthyearmed said:
I don't understand this comment. I would want a hospitalist coding my grandmother. A hospitalist is an IM trained doc and that's who usually runs codes on the floor. I would think they would be exactly who you'd want althought I'm sure ER docs know how to run one well also. Of course my school doesn't have ER residents so maybe it works differently where you are.

I suppose I should have said "compared to an EP." You're right, hospitalists are trained in running codes. I would raher have an EP run the code compared to a hospitalist, though. That's not to say everywhere that all EPs are better, though. I can tell you that none of the IM residents where I'm at are comfortable at intubating, out of the 10-15 3rd year IM residents I know, I can't think of one who has intubated more than 3 times. So in a small hospital, I'd rather have the ED attending run the code on the floor than the hospitalist (IMHO).

Q
 
I'm a surgery resident. Let me set a few things straight here:

First, surgeons do NOT make great money anymore, at least general surgery anyway. Certain specialties, private practice, in an affluent town, yeah they'll still do very well. But overall an EM doc actually will usually make more, certainly more per hour worked than a surgeon.

Second, and more importantly, you said that in the ER:
" you see many people who don't care for themselves and are the bottom of the social barrel"
Gimme a break - we all do! Every specialty with patient interaction sees whatever patient walks into the hospital. I guess you can set up some nice private practice in some rich town and see only the insured if you want...but this is a tough job to find. Plus most good residencies involve taking consults from the ER, which means in IM, Surery, Peds, whatever, you'll still be coming down the the ER to admit these patients and then take care of them for days, weeks, months. You're really not going to be a very happy physician in any patient care specialty if you're really as snobby as that comment above makes you sound because you WILL have to interact with these people even if you're not in the ER.
 
ekimsurfer said:
i've always been told that ER docs are a jack of all trades, master of none.

I like to think we are masters of the first hour (or more depending on how lazy the referred MD is).
 
fourthyearmed said:
I don't understand this comment. I would want a hospitalist coding my grandmother. A hospitalist is an IM trained doc and that's who usually runs codes on the floor. I would think they would be exactly who you'd want althought I'm sure ER docs know how to run one well also. Of course my school doesn't have ER residents so maybe it works differently where you are.

Hospitalists are great, they are the wave of the future. I love the fact that where I am at virtually all the patients are admitted to a hospitalist. It makes everything more efficient and the quality of inpatient care much better. However, I still respond to all the codes in the hospital at night. The hospitalists are there but almost none of them are credentialled to intubate. Many aren't very comfortable with central venous access. Once the patient is tubed and lined as necessary I will ask the hospitalist if they want me to stay. Sometimes they do, sometimes they don't.

As for ekimsurfer. Sounds to me like he is basically conflicted. He has the ego of the stereotypical surgeon without the drive or work ethic. Something is going to have to give.

In answer to the original post. Sure residency is hard but not as hard as it used to be. Sure its long but its not forever. Even the surgeons I know took some nice vacations during residency and got a few ski days in even when they weren't on vacation. Don't choose your specialty based on how long or hard residency is. Residency might be 7 years but your life is much longer than that.
 
ekimsurfer said:
choosing a higher specialty with a long residency make more sense than choosing a lesser specialty/field

Sort of says it all right there. I never realized there were greater and lesser specialties.
 
ERMudPhud said:
Sort of says it all right there. I never realized there were greater and lesser specialties.

ugh... you guys are certainly masters of something... and that's semantics.

higher specialty = longer residency program, with more competitive applicants.
 
Wow. I would just stop replying now. Take your hands away from the keyboard, think about everything you have typed, and go lie down in the fetal position with your thumb in your mouth. Apparently you are too competitive for this thread.
 
higher specialty = longer residency program, with more competitive applicants.

Do you really believe that some physicians are "higher quality" than others? It takes all kinds of doctors to have full patient care achieved. I'll bet you're going to take your child to the pediatrician one day. Be sure not to mention to them that you think they are in a lower specialty. When you break your arm and need to go to the ER, don't tell them either. And let's just hope you never need the services of the "higher quality" physicians like neurosurgeons or cv surgeons because by that time you're probably pretty sick.

People who apply to IM, Peds, ER, FP, etc. (your lower quality residencies) are not necessarily any less competitive than those who choose radiology or ENT. You're supposed to choose something you could enjoy doing for the rest of your life. I think 75% of the AOA people in my class are doing IM but some of them could definitely do derm or neurosurg if they wanted, they just choose not to because that's not what they enjoy.
 
fourthyearmed said:
Do you really believe that some physicians are "higher quality" than others? It takes all kinds of doctors to have full patient care achieved. I'll bet you're going to take your child to the pediatrician one day. Be sure not to mention to them that you think they are in a lower specialty. When you break your arm and need to go to the ER, don't tell them either. And let's just hope you never need the services of the "higher quality" physicians like neurosurgeons or cv surgeons because by that time you're probably pretty sick.

People who apply to IM, Peds, ER, FP, etc. (your lower quality residencies) are not necessarily any less competitive than those who choose radiology or ENT. You're supposed to choose something you could enjoy doing for the rest of your life. I think 75% of the AOA people in my class are doing IM but some of them could definitely do derm or neurosurg if they wanted, they just choose not to because that's not what they enjoy.


wtf are you talking about...

i never said anything about the applicants. i said that residencies can be more or less competitive.

if you want derm, neuro, integrated plastics, ortho... you're going to need to basically be in the top 1/3 of your class with some nice scores and letters in order to have a good chance.

it doesn't mean that students who are highly ranked with great scores don't apply to other less competitive programs.

seriously, you guys have the biggest complexes i've ever seen. no wonder other specialties make fun of you... look at how you act. GP is not as competitive as Derm... and ER is not as competitive as Neuro. You cannot disupte this. In fact i don't want anyone who is an ER physician or resident to participate in this thread any further because it's obvious you guys have some internal issues you need to work out with yourselves.

SO here is my new question:

Generally how does a 5 year surgical rotation go as far as hours, vacation, etc? And after you get done with residency do you still feel that it was worth it?
 
ekimsurfer said:
wtf are you talking about...

i never said anything about the applicants. i said that residencies can be more or less competitive.

ekimsurfer said:
higher specialty = longer residency program, with more competitive applicants.
😕

ekimsurfer said:
In fact i don't want anyone who is an ER physician or resident to participate in this thread any further because it's obvious you guys have some internal issues you need to work out with yourselves.

You can't always get what you want...

ekimsurfer said:
Generally how does a 5 year surgical rotation go as far as hours, vacation, etc? And after you get done with residency do you still feel that it was worth it?

So why haven't you posted your question to the surgical forum? You might say something like, " I want to be able to play and enjoy myself as much as possible during my 20's but I still want the prestige that comes with being a surgeon so how much time off will I have during residency and will it be worth it in the end?"

ekimsurfer said:
You know, the guy that if someone on the mountain gets hurt... they ski patrol bring him to the base of the mountain and see the doctor. Is that dude an ER guy? How much do you think they make and what type of hours?
ekimsurfer said:
I'm a current student and i'm leaning toward maybe becomming an ER doc and working out in the midwest like utah, colorado, wyoming, etc. where i can get a lot of skiing and mountain activities in.

Here are my questions:

1. Is it reasonable to assume that i will have a fair amount of free time to do these activities that i like?

2. What kind of salary (net) will i be looking at taking in?

3. What type of step1 scores and GPA are we talking about?

4. Is it worth it to try and go for something where you can make more money but work more hours?

I know many of the faculty at Denver and Utah. Several of them serve as medical directors for local ski patrols. Make sure when you apply that you tell them about your life long dream to be trained in their program to become a triage nurse. Also ask about the season passes given by the residency programs and the no work if there is more than 6 inches of fresh powder policy. After all , their fringe benefits were modeled after the package offered by the Domino's franchise in Crested Butte. I am sure you will top the rank list.
 
ERMudPhud said:
😕



You can't always get what you want...



So why haven't you posted your question to the surgical forum? You might say something like, " I want to be able to play and enjoy myself as much as possible during my 20's but I still want the prestige that comes with being a surgeon so how much time off will I have during residency and will it be worth it in the end?"




I know many of the faculty at Denver and Utah. Several of them serve as medical directors for local ski patrols. Make sure when you apply that you tell them about your life long dream to be trained in their program to become a triage nurse. Also ask about the season passes given by the residency programs and the no work if there is more than 6 inches of fresh powder policy. After all , their fringe benefits were modeled after the package offered by the Domino's franchise in Crested Butte. I am sure you will top the rank list.

i didn't post my question in the surgery forum because it felt it was a general question about what residencies are like in different specialites.

now, i've already explained myself regarding my comments about residency competitiveness and that issues has been beaten to death.

as far as my triage comment, that comes directly from the ER docs i've worked with while i was an EMT... go take it up with them. They were really upfront about how other doctors don't give them the credit, but at teh same time they were like... "alot of the time we do end up triaging and sending off... but then again we only work 16 days a week and are able to spend time with our kids and enjoy ourselves." But they were also on a first name basis with their staff so maybe things were different.

Whatever the deal is, i wasn't trying to poke fun at any particular specialty. And i could care less how prestigious something is as long as it affords me an enjoyable life.

My thoughts are as follows... most intelligent people can become doctors... the difference is that some people work much harder than others. To me, i see no intellectual difference between the people the bottom 10 people and the top 10 people. What i do see, though, is that the top 10 people most likely put in many more hours of studying. I can go on and on, but it will be for no reason as most of you guys will twist around what i say to make it seem like i think ER doctors are dumb and surgeons are god's gift from the heavens. I'm done trying to explain myself and like i've said several times, i'm probably more likely an ER personality than a surgeon.
 
ekimsurfer said:
SO here is my new question:

Generally how does a 5 year surgical rotation go as far as hours, vacation, etc? And after you get done with residency do you still feel that it was worth it?

All sorts of people, including the usually reasonable and thoughtful users at SDN, can react prematurely, inappropriately or appropriately based on information given. The trouble with web based bulletin boards is that it can be easy to misconstrue a message posted by another. Using appropriate language goes a long way toward eliminating or at least reducing confusion and the possible fire storm resulting from it. Toward that end, may I suggest that you be a little more precise in your language. The term "higher specialty" does not convey much and is open to misinterpretation, which is exactly what happened. "GPs" no longer exist in the US; the correct term is FP or Family Practitioner. A surgical training period after medical school is not a rotation, but a residency. If one takes the time to read posts carefully and give the OP the benefit of the doubt, it usually cuts down on responses such as those you received. Trouble is, when the language is confusing and possibly misleading, as yours was/is, many don't take the time to try and understand the intent. Perhaps if you read your posts and those of others with a more objective eye, we can all reduce some of the unpleasantness here.

On to your new question...

A 5 year + (some programs require or encourage research years in the laboratory and some fellowships will be a difficult match without that experience as well) surgical residency will vary somewhat with regard to hours.

I'm sure you are aware of the relatively new 80 hour workweek restrictions. I'd like to believe that most programs are making a concerted effort to adhere to these. However, the actual hours you work during residency will vary based on:

a) how much your program/faculty/senior residents enforce the workhour restrictions;
b) the rotation you're on - some, like Trauma may be more time intensive and have less allied health assistance and others, like SICU or an Anesthesia elective (if you have one) may be more shift like or have you working less hours per day. We have a fairly quiet Transplant rotation for example, but other places work plenty of hours on that rotation, so it will vary from site to site;
c) the amount of call you take; in general I've found that if you're on call more than twice in one week, its pretty much impossible to stay under 80 hours unless you are allowed to leave early/come in late, etc.;
d)whether that call is in house or at home; some rotations may allow you to take home call, and this is not unusual at the senior level. So while you may be on call, those hours don't count toward the 80 hours unless you come into the hospital;

But in general you should count on working a minimum of 80 hours per week during your junior years, with some rotations perhaps having less hours and some requiring more hours. As you become more senior, your in house call and the need to come in early for rounds decreases, but you may find you are in the hospital later (ie, doing more senior cases) or have to come in if you have a patient on your service in trouble. We've found that many of the senior residents are picking up the left over work as the juniors go home post-call; this leads us to add more hours to our tally.

Vacation time will vary from program to program as well, but most give you 3 weeks; I've seen some with only 2 weeks and a couple with 4 weeks. You may get a few additional days for conference time at some programs.

I can't answer the last question as I'm not done yet, but while a Surgical residency can be miserable, literature shows that Surgeons have some of the highest job satisfaction so I would bet that they thought it was all worth it (and these would be the guys who trained in old days before work hour restrictions). Some will be less comfortable saying so, especially that malpractice rates have risen and reimbursement has dropped.
 
ekim, i agree with some of the stuff you have said about 80hrs is like having one arm broken, and how you don't want to see your 20's go down the tube. i just graduated med school and i feel like a black cloud has been lifted off of me. i felt my school was particularly malignant which is one of the reasons i am not sure if residency would be any better (after all, 3rd and 4th years are walks in the park compared to residency.)

there is an emerging population (maybe 2% or so) of recent medical school graduates who are just plain fed up. I am 26 and I feel that my last 4 1/2 years did suck a lot of the life out of my twenties, although there are some people who find med school easier and would not say the same. It sounds like you got some good hobbies and i think you are correct in prioritizing them.
i take it you have not seen third year yet, as you would not be asking if a surgical residency would afford you the free time YOU are probably looking for. 80 hours tends to be the minimum in a lot of those surgical fields, and over 100 is not unheard of. do the math, 168hrs in a week, is that the free time you are looking for?? I mean, i like surg, but do i love it?? No. i love hobbies, friends, sports, family, dating, going out, etc.

i will not be doing a residency, at least not during my twenties. some people ask "well, what are you going to do??" , as if an MD from an american med school closes doors. I don't know what I'm gonna do, but I know that i'll find something that allows me to work to live rather than live to work. you do only get one "twenties", there are no rewinds or do-overs. by the way, i love the knowledge i've obtained, i just hate the system, which is why i will be applying my medical knowledge in an alternative environment (business, pharm, law, consulting, etc), hopefully still using it in a way that helps others.

i only browsed through some of this thread, but if I had to make a call on this one, I would say that you are not going to be a surgeon. write it down.
 
ekimsurfer said:
Generally how does a 5 year surgical rotation go as far as hours, vacation, etc? And after you get done with residency do you still feel that it was worth it?


I'm not a gen surg resident, but I've certainly rotated on enough gen surg services to understand what the life is like.

The 80 hour work week certainly applies, but getting those 80 hours can be less than ideal. For instance, depending on manpower, etc. I've seen PGY-2 alternating 24 hour shifts in the SICU. So, yeah, they only work 80 hours, but doing alternating 24 hour shifts for 2-3 months straight isn't exactly fun.

As for vacation, that's pretty much territory of the residency program. Expect 3-4 weeks with bookended weekends to make a total of 9 days off per vacation week.

I'm not going into gen surg, but urology. I definitely feel that going into urology will be worth it. I thought about gen surg, but find urology to have the best parts of gen surg without having to deal with the worst parts of it.
 
bobbyseal said:
.

As for vacation, that's pretty much territory of the residency program. Expect 3-4 weeks with bookended weekends to make a total of 9 days off per vacation week.

Do NOT expect bookended weekends or you may be disappointed (expect Saturday am to Saturday am and if you get more then it'll be gravy).
 
Kimberli Cox said:
Do NOT expect bookended weekends or you may be disappointed (expect Saturday am to Saturday am and if you get more then it'll be gravy).


Hmm, sorry to hear that Kim. Again, another reason to go Urology...
 
backontop said:
ekim, i agree with some of the stuff you have said about 80hrs is like having one arm broken, and how you don't want to see your 20's go down the tube. i just graduated med school and i feel like a black cloud has been lifted off of me. i felt my school was particularly malignant which is one of the reasons i am not sure if residency would be any better (after all, 3rd and 4th years are walks in the park compared to residency.)

there is an emerging population (maybe 2% or so) of recent medical school graduates who are just plain fed up. I am 26 and I feel that my last 4 1/2 years did suck a lot of the life out of my twenties, although there are some people who find med school easier and would not say the same. It sounds like you got some good hobbies and i think you are correct in prioritizing them.
i take it you have not seen third year yet, as you would not be asking if a surgical residency would afford you the free time YOU are probably looking for. 80 hours tends to be the minimum in a lot of those surgical fields, and over 100 is not unheard of. do the math, 168hrs in a week, is that the free time you are looking for?? I mean, i like surg, but do i love it?? No. i love hobbies, friends, sports, family, dating, going out, etc.

i will not be doing a residency, at least not during my twenties. some people ask "well, what are you going to do??" , as if an MD from an american med school closes doors. I don't know what I'm gonna do, but I know that i'll find something that allows me to work to live rather than live to work. you do only get one "twenties", there are no rewinds or do-overs. by the way, i love the knowledge i've obtained, i just hate the system, which is why i will be applying my medical knowledge in an alternative environment (business, pharm, law, consulting, etc), hopefully still using it in a way that helps others.

i only browsed through some of this thread, but if I had to make a call on this one, I would say that you are not going to be a surgeon. write it down.

i appreciate your post as i'm glad that someone else can recognize my worries.

you see i always thought surgery would be so much fun, and then i realized that these guys work their ass off and it's like you are a slave to your people. so what if you make millions of dollars... even if you retire at 50 you lost your most athletic years and i'm not about to see taht happen.

maybe it's selfish, i don't know. but i also don't know why people try and make you feel bad about wanting to enjoy your life and not spend eleventy billion hours a week working. i enjoy the med school knowledge... as i feel it allows me to great knowledge and priviledges and an MD can most likely never be to your disadvantage... but the practicing world just seems like they do everything they can to make your life miserable.

as far as delaying a residency is concerned, if i take 5 years or so off after graduation to pursue "other interests," and then i go back and apply for residency when i'm 30 or so, how will that affect my chances of getting in?
 
bobbyseal said:
I'm not a gen surg resident, but I've certainly rotated on enough gen surg services to understand what the life is like.

The 80 hour work week certainly applies, but getting those 80 hours can be less than ideal. For instance, depending on manpower, etc. I've seen PGY-2 alternating 24 hour shifts in the SICU. So, yeah, they only work 80 hours, but doing alternating 24 hour shifts for 2-3 months straight isn't exactly fun.

As for vacation, that's pretty much territory of the residency program. Expect 3-4 weeks with bookended weekends to make a total of 9 days off per vacation week.

I'm not going into gen surg, but urology. I definitely feel that going into urology will be worth it. I thought about gen surg, but find urology to have the best parts of gen surg without having to deal with the worst parts of it.

are you able to tell me a little bit more about urology.

how competitive are the residencies, what's teh average day like, and after 2 years what is avg work hour and salary?

thanks.
 
ekimsurfer said:
are you able to tell me a little bit more about urology.

how competitive are the residencies, what's teh average day like, and after 2 years what is avg work hour and salary?

thanks.

www.urologymatch.com
 
ive never heard of an EM doc doing an LP, thoracentesis, or paracentesis. usually they are too busy to do procedures that some poor intern is going to have to do, so they just admit them. EM is not as procedure intensive nowadays as 1. more patients use the ER for general medical care, 2. medicine is becoming more specialized, and 3. they are just too busy.
 
radonc said:
ive never heard of an EM doc doing an LP, thoracentesis, or paracentesis. usually they are too busy to do procedures that some poor intern is going to have to do, so they just admit them. EM is not as procedure intensive nowadays as 1. more patients use the ER for general medical care, 2. medicine is becoming more specialized, and 3. they are just too busy.

It depends where you are. At smaller community hospitals the ER doc is often one of the only physicians in the entire hospital, and are thus responsible for procedures. At some places, radiologists are beginning to do a lot of these procedures with image guidance. At large hospitals, sometimes the procedures are handled by specific services, yes, but not always.
 
radonc said:
ive never heard of an EM doc doing an LP, thoracentesis, or paracentesis. usually they are too busy to do procedures that some poor intern is going to have to do, so they just admit them. EM is not as procedure intensive nowadays as 1. more patients use the ER for general medical care, 2. medicine is becoming more specialized, and 3. they are just too busy.

Where do you work? I work at a large community hospital that is also a referral center. We have no house staff anywhere in the hospital(despite peoples perception the norm at most hospitals in the USA). I do tons of procedures every day because if I don't it might be a day before the hospitalist gets around to it. If they need to be done under USG or flouroscopic guidance I do that to. At night I go to the units for lines, intubations, and codes. Even when I was a resident we did lots of procedures. If there was anything left undone, anywhere a needle could go that it hadn't been, the medicine residents would raise hell when they came down to admit the patient.
 
radonc said:
ive never heard of an EM doc doing an LP, thoracentesis, or paracentesis. usually they are too busy to do procedures that some poor intern is going to have to do, so they just admit them. EM is not as procedure intensive nowadays as 1. more patients use the ER for general medical care, 2. medicine is becoming more specialized, and 3. they are just too busy.

Hmmm. I do an LP about every 2 shifts. I don't do thoros and paras where I am now but where I moonlit (moonlighted?) when I was a resident I did lots of them. I think it's more a question of where you are and the practice norms in that area than an absolute one way or the other.
 
I think there is quite a bit of variation depending on where you are. When I'm working at University, we do all of the procedures that need to be performed, because the medicine people typically like their patients wrapped in a bow with nothing left to do. Thoracentesis / paracentesis -- these are pretty rare (in my experience) even if the ER doc is doing them. LPs I do frequently, probably 1 every few days -- sometimes a few in a single shift though. Chest tubes, probably one a week (at univ.). I actually intubate and place central / arterial lines more than anything. In the community however, many times you'll defer the central line / arterial line to the admitting team, depending on how busy you are. Intubations are pretty much always done by the ER docs. In the community some of the procedures are kind of up to you -- do you want to do them or leave them for the hospitalist?
 
ekimsurfer said:
wtf are you talking about...

In fact i don't want anyone who is an ER physician or resident to participate in this thread any further because it's obvious you guys have some internal issues you need to work out with yourselves.

SO here is my new question:
LOL suuuuuure... THEY are the ones with the internal issues. :laugh:
 
Wow, all you guys are such victims of propaganda... We as physicians fight each other with such gusto. In the mean time, the MBAs and lawyers are laughing all the way to the bank on our backs.

To think that one specialty in medicine is more 'noble' is laughable.

Really, most of what we all do is a load of crap. Once in a while we'll actually help somebody, but mostly we just waste our patients and our own time with needless studies, side effects from meds., unreasonable regimens, and botched procedures.
 
ekimsurfer said:
I mean... they "limit" you to 80 hours of work which is like telling a person that you're only to go break ONE of their hands (i.e. you're still largely ****ed).

I'd still like to hear some responses regarding the original post - how bad does residency suck? Could someone just even describe how it works? I mean, how is it possible to be alert and making life or death (or maybe lawsuit or no lawsuit?) decisions for 80+ hours a week?

I am in the early stages (pre pre-med) of decision making and the one thing that makes me hesitate is the fear that residency could possibly kill me. I want to become a doctor, but will that only come at the expense of everything else I value in life?
 
Snugstar said:
ekimsurfer said:
I mean... they "limit" you to 80 hours of work which is like telling a person that you're only to go break ONE of their hands (i.e. you're still largely ****ed).

I'd still like to hear some responses regarding the original post - how bad does residency suck? Could someone just even describe how it works? I mean, how is it possible to be alert and making life or death (or maybe lawsuit or no lawsuit?) decisions for 80+ hours a week?

I am in the early stages (pre pre-med) of decision making and the one thing that makes me hesitate is the fear that residency could possibly kill me. I want to become a doctor, but will that only come at the expense of everything else I value in life?

woah, tiger. calm yourself. residency will not kill you, and you are WAY to early on to be worrying about it... take two chill pills and i'll see you in about 8 years
 
fourthyearmed said:
I don't understand this comment. I would want a hospitalist coding my grandmother. A hospitalist is an IM trained doc and that's who usually runs codes on the floor. I would think they would be exactly who you'd want althought I'm sure ER docs know how to run one well also. Of course my school doesn't have ER residents so maybe it works differently where you are.


That's what I thought when I saw the post. IM run codes all night long.

And I'd much rather have an anesthesiologist intubating than an EM doc ....:meanie:
 
Docta said:
That's what I thought when I saw the post. IM run codes all night long.

And I'd much rather have an anesthesiologist intubating than an EM doc ....:meanie:

Well let me tell you that in private practice where I am no one runs a code except the ER doc. I've had the IM PMD at the bedside bow out and have me run the code because they are uncomfortable doing it. And as for anesthesia when it comes to an emergency airway in a non-prepped patient with a full stomach none of the anesthesia docs in my hospitals have tubed somoeone like that since the dawn of never. Where I am the pulmonologists call me to tube people in the ICU.
 
Top