- Joined
- Jan 8, 2011
- Messages
- 15
- Reaction score
- 0
Last edited:
You learn ICU medicine from doing ICU medicine . . .
You can't "book" your way into being or feeling competent. Sorry.
Agreed, but nothing wrong with doing a little reading to be at least a little more prepared. I dont think the OP is necessarily expecting to "be competent" just from the reading.
However, the reading isn't going to make a whole lot of sense or mean much, until you actually are dealing with issues in the ICU and have a practical application for that info. I think this is true for most of internal medicine, actually. at least was for me.
Hey Fellow Forumers,
MSIV going into IM here, trying to get some advice on how best to prepare for ICU months. I know there's been some posts on this before, but none that I found were recent and some weren't that helpful (though I'm definitely no forum search wizard). What do you guys think of Marino's book? Especially now in light of a lot of new trials (eg. with streroids, glucose control, etc.). I've heard it's now a little outdated. How about the Washington Manual? Others? I was hoping to find something that will give me a good foundation in as compact a form as possible.
Also, if it helps for recommendations, I don't plan on doing a pulm/cc fellowship, but I really enjoy it and would like to do well on my rotations.
2 things that may be helpful before starting are to look through the surviving sepsis protocols - looks really long but you can get the gist quickly, and to review acid/base stuff. Both come up a lot. But overall there's a steep learning curve that you can't really totally prepare for before you get there.
I wanted to thank everyone for posting, this is actually very helpful; I appreciate it. 👍 Also, to clarify, I've never thought that there is a substitute for "doing". My intention was never to read some random book and transmute on the spot into a pulm/cc fellow. I agree medicine is best learned at the bedside. And it seems like the general consensus is that most people just show up and absorb it? Makes some sense, but the optimist in me still feels like there must be at least some good resources out there to demystify some of the high yield topics.
That said, maybe my learning style is a little different than some. I'll remember most of what I read, even if I don't see a patient with xyz disease/condition. And I'm embarrassed to admit that I'm lacking much of what might be considered very basic ICU fundamentals. For example, I know diddly squat about the different types of oxygenation and masks, very little about ventilation in general, totally unfamiliar with CVVH other than it's continuous, TPN is a big question mark in my mental file, etc. etc. Even mucous plugging was foreign to me until I stated studying for CK. Obviously I'm not going to be the one deciding on how to change the vent settings. Clearly I'm not going to be running the CVVH. Don't get me wrong, I know as an intern I'm not going to be doing a lot of this. I can learn about these things later, but I'm very curious about them and wanted a way to bring it all together so I can at least be in a good place to "learn by doing" when I get there. My learning on the wards is sooooooo much more efficient if I have some sort of foundation to work off of when the attending goes off on some topic. I feel like I have absolutely no foundation to build on when it comes to most ICU topics. Not sure if this makes any sense or if anyone else out there learns like this. I'm not necessarily trying to be a superstar, I just want to understand what's going on so I'm not just an order monkey trying to survive in an unfamiliar world. Maybe to some degree that's inevitable though.
Unless there are other recommendations, I guess I'll just start reviewing CXR, EKGs, surviving sepsis protocols and acid/base+electrolyte stuff, then flip through Marino's book. That should keep me very busy anyway.
Here's some key stuff:
The Surviving Sepsis Campaign is good - covers pressors and fluids in the kind of detail you will need (Norepi is now your "go to" pressor)
Check out the latest ASPEN guidelines on nutrition in the critically ill (TFs >>> TPN [avoid TPN unless absolutely necessary])
Know Early Goal Directed Therapy (Emanuel Rivers, NEJM, 2001) - importance of measured SvO2, and what to do with it
Understand low-pressure ventilation and why it's used
Know how to interpret electrolytes, especially the importance of Mg and Phos - know how to replace said electrolytes
That should be enough to allow you to show up the first day and know a little bit about what's going on and the rationale for why things are going on and will help direct you in starting to make management decisions on your own.
Isnt it lung protective ventilation?
yes, protected by lower pressures, produced by lower tidal volumes
change in volumes
(that is the definition of "tidal volumes")
I thought it was mostly the big change in volumes. So higher peep, lower volume is better
No I get that. I was asking because i thought what makes LPV good was the reduced tidal volume and any supposed decrease in pressure since you might not have that much less pressure if you have PEEP
PEEP generally doesn't add that much pressure. If you're trying to keep peak pressures less than 35 and plateaus less than 30, and PEEP is only making up 5 cmH20, the rest of the pressure in the system is coming from where do you think?
That said, maybe my learning style is a little different than some. I'll remember most of what I read, even if I don't see a patient with xyz disease/condition.
ouu gotcha. thanks
I am going into IM and i want to get some good ICU experience. The problem is that all the MICU is full of students already and I can do a SICU month instead. Do you feel doing an SICU month is suffice enough to get me that experience?
Or should I just do an ID month?