Is ECAP-SCS Opioid Sparing

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

drusso

Full Member
Moderator Emeritus
Lifetime Donor
Joined
Nov 21, 1998
Messages
13,190
Reaction score
7,789
This is generating a lot of positive feelings among those in the know...

Pain Pract. 2021 Jul;21(6):680-691. doi: 10.1111/papr.13008. Epub 2021 May 2.

ECAP-Controlled Closed-Loop Spinal Cord Stimulation Efficacy and Opioid Reduction Over 24-Months: Final Results of the Prospective, Multicenter, Open-Label Avalon Study

Charles Brooker 1 2, Marc Russo 3, Michael J Cousins 1 2, Nathan Taylor 1 2, Lewis Holford 1 2, Rebecca Martin 1, Tillman Boesel 4, Richard Sullivan 5, Erin Hanson 6, Gerrit Eduard Gmel 6, Nastaran Hesam Shariati 6, Lawrence Poree 7, John Parker 6 8
Affiliations expand
PMID: 33768664 PMCID: PMC8359972 DOI: 10.1111/papr.13008
Free PMC article
Abstract
Introduction: Chronic pain is a major public health concern, as is the associated use of opioid medications, highlighting the importance of alternative treatments, such as spinal cord stimulation (SCS). Here, we present the final 24-month results of the Avalon study, which investigated the use of the first closed-loop SCS system in patients with chronic pain. The system measures the evoked compound action potentials (ECAPs) elicited by each stimulus pulse and drives a feedback loop to maintain the ECAP amplitude near constant.

Methods: Fifty patients were implanted with the Evoke system (Saluda Medical) and followed over 24-months. Pain, quality of life (QOL), function, sleep, and medication use were collected at baseline and each scheduled visit. ECAP amplitudes and programming adjustments were also monitored.

Results: At 24 months, responder rates (≥ 50% pain reduction) and high responder rates (≥ 80% pain reduction) for overall pain were 89.5% and 68.4%, respectively, the latter up from 42.2% at 3 months. Significant improvements from baseline were observed in QOL, function, and sleep over the 24 months, including ≥ 80% experiencing a minimally important difference in QOL and > 50% experiencing a clinically significant improvement in sleep. At 24 months, 82.8% of patients with baseline opioid use eliminated or reduced their opioid intake. Over the course of the study, reprogramming need fell to an average of less than once a year.

Conclusion: Over a 24-month period, the Evoke closed-loop SCS maintained its therapeutic efficacy despite a marked reduction in opioid use and steady decrease in the need for reprogramming.

Keywords: Chronic; closed-loop SCS; evoke; evoked compound action potential; feedback; opioid; pain; spinal cord stimulation.
 
I'm excited by this.

Feedback in a system is a good thing. I'm interested to see how they integrate it into sub-paresthesia waveforms as it's predicated on the ECAP generated by the dorsal column paresthesia.

With that said, Steve's right this is all study shenanigans to some extent so we'll have to see what happens when we get outside the walls of a clinical trial.
 
FDA approval of Saluda is supposedly coming very soon. Let’s see what the real-world outcomes are like. From what I’ve seen with patients so far, they seem to be doing pretty well. But of course they’re all <1 year out from implant.
 
Write a protocol and advertise to patients how much they can make by having a device implanted to get them off opiates. Win win win.

This is going to be a #Gamechanger for our #space and help improve #outcomes and reduce #opioidprescribing for #chronicpain.
 
Basing that assessment in an industry sponsored retrospective non blinded trial is specious.

I think I heard the exact same expectations from:
HF 10
SCS for diabetic neuropathy
Qutenza
OxyContin
Deterrent proof oxycodone/morphine ER
MILD
Relievant
Minuteman
Vertiflex
Prialt
Low dose ITP
Etc Etc etc
 
Basing that assessment in an industry sponsored retrospective non blinded trial is specious.

I think I heard the exact same expectations from:
HF 10
SCS for diabetic neuropathy
Qutenza
OxyContin
Deterrent proof oxycodone/morphine ER
MILD
Relievant
Minuteman
Vertiflex
Prialt
Low dose ITP
Etc Etc etc
Only PRP and Stem $ells are strong enough to do that.
 
Only PRP and Stem $ells are strong enough to do that.

Thank you for your service. #Outcomes #WoundedWarriors #OpioidSparing

1642005771400.png
 
One of the authors tried to sell me his practice(unsolicited) a few years back. He was a nice guy but by no means a Regen med KOL.
 
Any physician who tells his or her pts that SCS can be used to get them off opiates is a quack.

You know what gets a pt off opiates? Just stop them...

Boom. You're off opiates, and 6-8 weeks later you feel no different off the drug than you did on the drug.

I recognize some of the authors in this study - For this reason I'm skeptical.
 
Any physician who tells his or her pts that SCS can be used to get them off opiates is a quack.

You know what gets a pt off opiates? Just stop them...

Boom. You're off opiates, and 6-8 weeks later you feel no different off the drug than you did on the drug.

I recognize some of the authors in this study - For this reason I'm skeptical.

If a doctor lied to me and said that I would feel "no different off the drug than on the drug" and I did feel different off the drug anyway, I'd be pissed.
 
Any physician who tells his or her pts that SCS can be used to get them off opiates is a quack.

You know what gets a pt off opiates? Just stop them...

Boom. You're off opiates, and 6-8 weeks later you feel no different off the drug than you did on the drug.

I recognize some of the authors in this study - For this reason I'm skeptical.

…They may feel different, but their pain will be the same…
 
If a doctor lied to me and said that I would feel "no different off the drug than on the drug" and I did feel different off the drug anyway, I'd be pissed.
Which is more likely a lie?

1. The newest SCS device is so effective you'll ask your doctor to take you off opiates.

2. Within 6-8 weeks of coming off opiates your pain will be no different than it was on opiates.

The answer is obviously #1.

I can pretty much guarantee that study is BS and I haven't even read it.

I'd like to see honorarium over the next 5 yrs for each of those authors.
 
By what moa does scs treat dependence?

Okay I’ll
Bite…
Burst treats depression. Improving depression decreases dependence. There ya go. With this nugget you can wear a suit top with tighty whities below cam for your zoom training conferences 2 nights a week while St Jubbot reps call you a visionary and flirt with you.
 
Okay I’ll
Bite…
Burst treats depression. Improving depression decreases dependence. There ya go. With this nugget you can wear a suit top with tighty whities below cam for your zoom training conferences 2 nights a week while St Jubbot reps call you a visionary and flirt with you.

You too? And they told me I was special...
 
Cannot even dignify the uselessness of the above. Darn it, I did.


The upshot? In my clinical experience, chronic SI joint pain is easy to treat with orthobiologics like PRP. However, I do have serious concerns that most IPM practitioners aren’t getting the memo about orthobiologics changing what should be treated., This new study is a great example of how just switching out one injectate (steroid) with another (PRP) is likely hamstringing the orthobiologic approach.
 

The upshot? In my clinical experience, chronic SI joint pain is easy to treat with orthobiologics like PRP. However, I do have serious concerns that most IPM practitioners aren’t getting the memo about orthobiologics changing what should be treated., This new study is a great example of how just switching out one injectate (steroid) with another (PRP) is likely hamstringing the orthobiologic approach.
Have to agree that patients do much better after PRP injections of both the SIJ and ligaments not just the joint.
 
Top