is it possible to only submit your highest mcat score when you apply?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

mrh125

Membership Revoked
Removed
10+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2013
Messages
2,371
Reaction score
621
i looked at the aamcs site a few days ago and was filling out the application for med schools and I noticed an option that lets you select to use your most recent or mcat test of your choice when applying to schools. Does that mean they won't see a lower score if you retook it? how exactly does this work?

also, how common is it for med schools to just take your highest mcat score?
 
Like Ismet said, you can't "select" which scores the med schools see. If you retook, they will see all your past MCAT scores. Different schools use this information differently. Some may take your highest scores, but most will just average them out.
 
i looked at the aamcs site a few days ago and was filling out the application for med schools and I noticed an option that lets you select to use your most recent or mcat test of your choice when applying to schools. Does that mean they won't see a lower score if you retook it? how exactly does this work?
Prior to 2003, applicants had the choice to send in only one MCAT score, which is probably why AMCAS has that option. That's ancient history now. AMCAS automatically forwards all your scores to med schools when you apply.

also, how common is it for med schools to just take your highest mcat score?
http://forums.studentdoctor.net/threads/mcat-low-scores.566616/#post-7187293
 
Last edited:
I believe that data is not only dated, but also unverified. I think I recall that LizzyM stated that many schools are considering all MCAT scores now.

Plus even if they say they only consider the highest or most recent or whatever, all the scores are still there and I'm sure create some subconscious/conscious bias.
 
i looked at the aamcs site a few days ago and was filling out the application for med schools and I noticed an option that lets you select to use your most recent or mcat test of your choice when applying to schools. Does that mean they won't see a lower score if you retook it? how exactly does this work?

also, how common is it for med schools to just take your highest mcat score?


The answer is straightforward and everyone here answered it correctly. I just wanted to say that currently, there is no currently no large list of how schools treat MCAT scores. There is one floating around here that's like 5+ years old but most of that information is probably outdated. There's really 4 types of analysis I've seen that schools will do.

1. A "holistic review" of the MCAT score meaning they consider all the MCAT scores and analyze them in context of date and improvement.

Ex. MCAT scores of 20 and 30 within a month of each other are more likely to be averaged as it's unlikely that one can improve on a 10 pt. scale. They'll also ask about it at interviews. However, take those scores but put them 3+ months apart and the most recent score will probably be looked at more carefully.

Common things schools will say if they adopt this policy are:

-Most recent score, but all scores considered
-Most recent score, but all scores still visible
-View all scores
-holistic review


2. A "superscored" MCAT. I've seen some schools (notably BU-not to be confused with their holistic review process of the ENTIRE application) take the best sub-scores from all your sittings and put those together.

Ex.) 2011: 11P, 8V, 14BS
2012: 12P, 10V, 12 BS
Gets you a 12P, 10V, 14BS=36

3. ONLY MOST RECENT:

Notably a lot of SMPs do this but some schools still look at the most recent score and throw the others out.

If they do this, they'll be explicit about it.


4. Average:

At some places recently, as @LizzyM has hinted at, schools are transitioning to averaging MCAT scores as doing so is more strongly correlated with some medical school achievement metric (not sure if it was board scores, grades, or clinical grades, etc.).

If schools do this, I don't think they'll be as transparent about it because I've heard of schools doing this but have not seen indications of it anywhere on websites. For example, at an IU interview, I was interviewed by a PhD and an MD and with a unintended cursory glance at the PhD's clipboard I saw my MCAT Score 1 + MCAT Score 2/2 = X handwritten in large red font. I don't know if this is interview or school specific though so don't jump to conclusions with IU.
 
i looked at the aamcs site a few days ago and was filling out the application for med schools and I noticed an option that lets you select to use your most recent or mcat test of your choice when applying to schools. Does that mean they won't see a lower score if you retook it? how exactly does this work?

also, how common is it for med schools to just take your highest mcat score?

To give you one anecdote, I retook a very low score, improved significantly and was successful at a few schools, so there are cases where a retake will be looked at more "holistically." If scores were averaged, I wouldn't have been very competitive. I also didn't apply to many top schools so maybe take that into consideration.
 
To give you one anecdote, I retook a very low score, improved significantly and was successful at a few schools, so there are cases where a retake will be looked at more "holistically." If scores were averaged, I wouldn't have been very competitive. I also didn't apply to many top schools so maybe take that into consideration.


Same situation here. I don't know to what extent my scores hurt me because I didn't have the research to apply to many top 20 schools. The four highest I applied to were UMich (in-state), UWisc, Boston (thought Boston would be cool), and Cincinnati. Got an II/rejection at BU but they have that super score thing.
 
Top