Is this really how the match works?

[Pike]

---

Members don't see this ad.

The match has been explained to me in this way before - but I guess I'm just seeking some additional affirmation that my understanding is in line with reality:

Say for example I feel I have the best chance of matching at program X. However, I am not too fond of program X, and therefore choose to rank 9 more competitive programs ahead of program X. So I rank the program #10 out of 10 programs. Meanwhile, my friend ranks program X #1. If program X has ranked me #4, and my friend #5 (and if program X has just 4 spots), then potentially it would be the case that I would still match at the program before my friend if I don't get a spot at any of my first 9 choices - correct? This is how it's been explained to me - just want to make sure. Thanks.

 

[Wolverine98]

The match has been explained to me in this way before - but I guess I'm just seeking some additional affirmation that my understanding is in line with reality:

Say for example I feel I have the best chance of matching at program X. However, I am not too fond of program X, and therefore choose to rank 9 more competitive programs ahead of program X. So I rank the program #10 out of 10 programs. Meanwhile, my friend ranks program X #1. If program X has ranked me #4, and my friend #5 (and if program X has just 4 spots), then potentially it would be the case that I would still match at the program before my friend if I don't get a spot at any of my first 9 choices - correct? This is how it's been explained to me - just want to make sure. Thanks.

That's correct. The way the algorithm works (they used to have it published, but apparently it's harder to find now), it's in your best interest to rank programs in the order you want them, and not to try to guess who will rank you highest.

Dave

 

[brats800]

http://www.nrmp.org/res_match/about_res/algorithms.html

that's the match site's explanation of the algorithm...

 

[Olddog1]

That's correct. The way the algorithm works (they used to have it published, but apparently it's harder to find now), it's in your best interest to rank programs in the order you want them, and not to try to guess who will rank you highest.

Dave

Applicants please read and understand this statement. If a program says we love you, you are the greatest, we are going to rank you first (yes this is "illegal"), say thank you and you are definately one of my favorites or one of my top choice. Don't let your ego take over the rank list and rank a program because they say they like you. It doesn't matter how much they like you, your list guides the match. Rank the place you want to go first, then second choice, etc... Just don't lie and tell every program you are my favorite; fellowship directors have a long memory.

 

[Pike]

Thanks everyone.