I would say... watch the first 3 minutes of the pilot fully and maybe re-evaluate. Particularly, in that time, when he says "People say I am the best boss. 'We've never worked in a place like this before. You're hilarious. ...and...you get the best out of us.' *holds up worlds best boss mug*" It's no coincidence that's the first time the camera is alone with him in his office.. it's supposed to be him introducing who he thinks he is to the audience. He thinks by "telling jokes" and "being hilarious" (without realizing people find it offensive and complain to HR), he will be "the best boss".
Also, if you look at the UK version.. David Brent even more directly hangs his self-worth as a manager on what people think of his jokes. And it's not a coincidence that the Michael Scott character thinks the HR guy is the devil. Michael Scott is a character whose entire management style revolves around trying to be funny and getting his employees to like him...which is a ridiculous goal and that's why he ends up alone for so long. He really wants to be funny.. that's why he is always taking improv classes or putting on performances in the conference room...and doing terribly.
I would agree that Michael Scott, as a real person in that world, is NOT funny and is awkward socially. But he is definitely trying to be funny to endear all of his employees...not realizing for like 7 seasons that they are all always going to resent him for it.
It's most definitely the starting concept for the boss character on the show.. whether or not it's the premise of the whole show depends on how much you think the show centers around that character.... seasons 8 and 9 kind of lead me to believe it does quite a bit.
So.. I've been watching a lot of TV while waiting for medical school to start.
Sorry to derail. I have my opinion and you have yours. I will definitely recant and apologize if you're actually Ricky Gervais and spend your time policing Office references...as your opinion may instead count as fact in this case. In that case PM me!

I just thought parallel was neat. Yep, definitely too much TV.
Anyway, OP will be way more successful in his endeavors than either of these fictional characters as it seems like he is capable of taking inventory and making the necessary changes.
In case @PortlandSurgeon wants my advice, I would agree with others who have said list the activity, try to pick the best possible reference, and don't ask for a letter. I'm rooting for you.