Lmao

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Dr.Inviz

Dr.Inviz

Membership Revoked
Removed
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Oct 1, 2006
Messages
2,422
Reaction score
1
Members don't see this ad.
I just saw a commercial on TV for weight loss .. and this drug called "Hydroxycut" was being marketed. the spokesman physician was a DO ... i was like, lmao ... the commercial was weird overall.
 
I've seen this...I noticed today there is a new weightloss pill out (I forget the name) but it too is endorsed by a DO...
 
i find it ironic that DOs are endorsing weight loss pills, when that is one thing that a pill should definitely not be used for. A.T. Still would be very disappointed...
 
where have you been, lol. That has been on the air for over a year. You can probably find threads about it dating back to 2005.
 
Vix206 said:
i find it ironic that DOs are endorsing weight loss pills, when that is one thing that a pill should definitely not be used for. A.T. Still would be very disappointed...
Click to expand...

why not? if you can find a safe, effective pill then it definitely should be used
 
DRKUBA said:
why not? if you can find a safe, effective pill then it definitely should be used
Click to expand...

i'm not sure if "safe" and "diet pill" go together, especially since none of them are FDA approved. plus, the publicized, harmful effects of fen-phen and ephedra have not given them they best reputation. weight loss is something that should be natural and encourages a change in lifestyle - not a quick fix pill. any doctor, especially DOs, should know that.
 
Vix206 said:
i'm not sure if "safe" and "diet pill" go together, especially since none of them are FDA approved. plus, the publicized, harmful effects of fen-phen and ephedra have not given them they best reputation. weight loss is something that should be natural and encourages a change in lifestyle - not a quick fix pill. any doctor, especially DOs, should know that.
Click to expand...

I agree somewhat, but, no DO only goes the natural route, they prescribe meds as much as MDs ... I just found it funny that it was a DO. While it may increase exposure for DOs in the medical professional, you had to be looking at his white coat to know it was a DO .. otherwise, you wouldnt. Also, if someone was looking at the coat and noticed it was a DO, theyd be like, not shocking that a "quack" DO would be advertising and endorsing such a diet pill in what appeared to be a ridiculous commercial. It only gives DOs a worse name ...
 
Vix206 said:
i'm not sure if "safe" and "diet pill" go together, especially since none of them are FDA approved. plus, the publicized, harmful effects of fen-phen and ephedra have not given them they best reputation. weight loss is something that should be natural and encourages a change in lifestyle - not a quick fix pill. any doctor, especially DOs, should know that.
Click to expand...

i politely disagree. i'll repeat, if a safe, effective pill is engineered, then there is no reason people should not use it. I don't buy the "it should be natural" line. That could apply to many diseases which we treat with pills. Maybe fighting off infection by the immune system "should be natural" but we still use antibiotics. Maybe lowering cholesterol by eating less meat should be natural, but we still use lipitor. Trust in scientific research, every doctor should know that.
 
MJB said:
I saw that commercial too...like 2 years ago!
Click to expand...

well, im sorry, but it was my 1st time seeing it ... evidently the DO is still at it ... 🙄
 
DRKUBA said:
i politely disagree. i'll repeat, if a safe, effective pill is engineered, then there is no reason people should not use it. I don't buy the "it should be natural" line. That could apply to many diseases which we treat with pills. Maybe fighting off infection by the immune system "should be natural" but we still use antibiotics. Maybe lowering cholesterol by eating less meat should be natural, but we still use lipitor. Trust in scientific research, every doctor should know that.
Click to expand...

then i agree to disagree.

PS i do trust in scientific research. but has there even been funded, scientific research on these pills? also, comparing weight gain to infection is an unfair comparison. i didn't say everything should be natural - only weight-loss.
 
Dr.Inviz said:
Also, if someone was looking at the coat and noticed it was a DO, theyd be like, not shocking that a "quack" DO would be advertising and endorsing such a diet pill in what appeared to be a ridiculous commercial. It only gives DOs a worse name ...
Click to expand...

Umm.. are you calling DO's quacks in general and that this commercial/pill is just proving your point or are you just expressing your concern that a rogue physician who happens to be a DO is selling a product that you think is not great?? Also I really don't know too many people out there that would think "not shocking that a "quack" DO would be advertising and endorsing such a diet pill." If you feel that there is some stigma against being a DO then I seriously don't know how well you are going to do in a DO school where the aim is to become one. Good luck!!
 
TerpDO said:
Umm.. are you calling DO's quacks in general and that this commercial/pill is just proving your point or are you just expressing your concern that a rogue physician who happens to be a DO is selling a product that you think is not great?? Also I really don't know too many people out there that would think "not shocking that a "quack" DO would be advertising and endorsing such a diet pill." If you feel that there is some stigma against being a DO then I seriously don't know how well you are going to do in a DO school where the aim is to become one. Good luck!!
Click to expand...

Wow, you guys truly need to work on reading comprehension.

I was referring to how the general public who may not know about DOs often may consider them to be "quack" doctors, especially the MDs .. and seeing how the DO physician was endorsing this drug that isnt even FDA or clinically proven to allow for weight loss (and the weirdness of the commercial) .. it PERPETUATES the problem ... i have nothing against DOs, if i did, I would never ever consider applying to DO schools ... think!:idea:
 
Vix206 said:
then i agree to disagree.

PS i do trust in scientific research. but has there even been funded, scientific research on these pills?
Click to expand...

yes, there has been plenty. Has any shown good results? Not really. What I am saying is if there was a study(s) that did find a drug safe and effective, then by all means it should be considered. I am just saying I don't buy the whole "do it naturally just because it seems like that's the way it should be" way of thinking.
 
DRKUBA said:
yes, there has been plenty. Has any shown good results? Not really. What I am saying is if there was a study(s) that did find a drug safe and effective, then by all means it should be considered. I am just saying I don't buy the whole "do it naturally just because it seems like that's the way it should be" way of thinking.
Click to expand...

I question if there have been studies showing that this drug is safe. The commercial was just too .. fake.
 
DRKUBA said:
yes, there has been plenty. Has any shown good results? Not really. What I am saying is if there was a study(s) that did find a drug safe and effective, then by all means it should be considered. I am just saying I don't buy the whole "do it naturally just because it seems like that's the way it should be" way of thinking.
Click to expand...

i agree to a certain extent. results on the pills out right now have not been most favorable (risk for stroke, unhealthy levels of caffeine, etc). i believe medication for many ailments is the answer. but unless a weight-loss pill is FDA approved (and a study found it safe and effective), i don't believe it's the answer for weight loss.

and that's all i have to say about that - for good 🙂
 
Dr.Inviz said:
Wow, you guys truly need to work on reading comprehension.

I was referring to how the general public who may not know about DOs often may consider them to be "quack" doctors, especially the MDs .. and seeing how the DO physician was endorsing this drug that isnt even FDA or clinically proven to allow for weight loss (and the weirdness of the commercial) .. it PERPETUATES the problem ... i have nothing against DOs, if i did, I would never ever consider applying to DO schools ... think!:idea:
Click to expand...

Okay I'll take the blame for assuming you were calling DO quacks (even though it sounded like it), and of course I know you are applying to DO schools. But I'm not giving you any slack for assuming the public (or even MD's) feel that way. Sure you have nothing against DO's you say but you are going to be matriculating into DO school with the biggest chip on your shoulder if you feel the need to aggressively defend the letters after your name to any random person. From applying this cycle I've explained what a DO is to many people who have never heard of one and rarely, if ever did the person listening assume DO's were inferior. Anyways just as there are way more MD's than DO's in America there are way more MD's endorsing gym equipment/skincare products/diet pills (that may or may not work and may or may not be FDA approved) than DO's so I don't see how Hydroxycut is anything significant. Unless of course it is selling better than other products then you gotta give that guy (who happens to be a DO) some props!
 
The doctor endorsing it is Dr. Jon Marshall, a 2005 graduate of Midwestern University and is now in residency. I'm not sure how I feel about hydroxcut, but if it wasn't him endorsing it, there would have been some other physician right there behind him ready to step up. There is also a physician from Yale University endorsing it, Dr. Christine Lydon. Check out the site: http://www.hydroxycut.com/ It has some pretty sweet jams. :laugh:

My gut reaction is that it's likely not a healthy way to lose weight. Of course, I'm not a doctor yet, so what do I know?
 
riiiiight....there have been thousands of tv commercials over the years w/ MD's promoting products (some crap..some legit)....so the 1st DO you see get into the game makes us all look like quacks.....sure...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top