Technology macbook air: First impressions

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Dr Who

Future MD...
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2004
Messages
876
Reaction score
4
I recieved my macbook air yesterday. After a whole day of playing with it these are my initial impressions:

The air looks absolutely beautiful. I thought I would find the black keys on aluminum a bit tacky, but I actually like it. I absolutely loved the backlit keyboard, hopefully Apple will incorporate it into future versions of the macbook. The aluminum enclosure is very nice with surprisingly little heat. My friends black macbook gets much hotter than the air. With a 13.3" display the air has the same "footprint" as the macbook. The difference is when you compare them side by side. I always liked the style of the macbook, but when placed next to a macbook air, they look HUGE and bloated. It really is that thin!

The aluminum body feels very, very tight. Although it is so thin I can actually pick it up from a corner and feel absolutely no bending or warping, the thing is solid as a rock. I would never have dared to do that with my older IBM Thinkpad. In regards to weight, those 2 pounds do make a differnce.

The operating system was pretty responsive, as it should be with 2 Gb of RAM. It took Office 2008 from 5 to 8 seconds to open (yes, I timed it too 🙂). I was pretty surprised at how zippy and responsive the laptop is considering that I ordered the base 1.6 GHz model. It is pretty much on par with the macbook. I wouldnt recommend it for gaming, 3D modeling or HD decoding, but it should be more than enough for normal computing needs.

The screen is a 13.3" LED backlit which is brighter than the macbook version (which is LCD not LED). When I open the case it instantly turns on which is nice. i am not a fan glossy screens, but so far it hasnt bothered me much. The new multi- touch gestures of the trackpad are pretty intuitive. Those of you with an ipod touch or an iphone will be right at home. If you have never used an iphone dont worry, they are easy to learn. My sister who has never handled an iphone got the hang of it pretty quickly and loved it.

My biggest worry when buying the macbook were the reports of non replacable battery and puny hard drive (the SSD option at $999 is waaay to expensive for me). Fortunately this doesnt seem to be the case at all. Reports from mac sites demonstrate that the battery is actually pretty easy to replace, as all you need is a screwdriver. With this in mind, its only a matter of time before third party replacement batteries are available. Removing the hard drive takes a little more work, but its definately doable. The only problem is that the largest size comaptible 1.8" HDD available is precisely 80 Gb. This shouldnt be a problem as SSD drive prices are falling more and more every day, with reports saying that their prices should rive HDD prices by the end of this year/ early next year.

The "lack" of features is probably not going to be as big a problem as I thought. In all the years I have had my Thinkpad laptop, I probably burned less than 10 CD's/ DVD's. If I do find the need to burn a CD/ DVD I already have my 24" iMac as my primary desktop computer for that. When transfering files I mainly use my trusty 4 Gb USB drive which is more than enough. I installed Office 2008 using remote disk, which is an application that permits the macbook to "borrow" the disk drive from another computer to unstall apps. It worked as advertised, Office 2008 installed without any problems whatsoever.

The speaker sounded ok as it is mono, but as with any laptop I recommend using the headphone jack. The air also has a built in isight camera on top of the screen, it worked great. The one thing that I really missed was a firewire port. The external hard drive I use to back up my info and store my movies is firewire only, which means I am going to be forced to shell out some money for a USB external hard drive for use with my macbook air. Other than that the other "missing" features would most likely not be missed at all.

So after playing with the macbook air for more than a day I have to say I am pretty happy with it. One thing to keep in mind is that the macbook air is NOT meant to be used as a primary computer. If you decide to buy one I recommend you at least have a decent desktop for you primary computing needs. In the end I believe that Apple always meant for the macbook air to be used as a second computer, where portability was more important.

I know this was a bit long winded, but I hope it gives you all a better idea of what you are getting into if you decide to get a macbook air.

Members don't see this ad.
 
I thought some of the existing Mac laptops had backlit keyboards already: maybe just the Pros and not the regular MacBooks. Either way, I'm sure the Air is an improvement. Congrats!
 
I thought some of the existing Mac laptops had backlit keyboards already: maybe just the Pros and not the regular MacBooks. Either way, I'm sure the Air is an improvement. Congrats!

(MPB not MB)

Anyway, I think the MBA would be a nice computer, but I have a nice F800/400/USB external HDD I use to backup. I really wouldn't want to use USB to do that and it kind of seems like a waste since I'm not going to buy time capsule and I don't think it would be very fast anyway. I do have wireless in my house, so I'm probably going to invest in a nice new MB sometime in the near-distant future.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
The external hard drive I use to back up my info and store my movies is firewire only, which means I am going to be forced to shell out some money for a USB external hard drive for use with my macbook air.

You know you can just go buy a hub that can combine firewire and USB like the one at http://www.iogear.com/main.php?loc=product&Item=GUH420 or http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=990788&CatId=403. Just an idea if you don't want to buy a whole new external HD. Although, if it has a 4-pin firewire, I am unaware of any 4-pin firewire/USB 2.0 combo hubs on the market.
 
Congratulations on the new MBA.

I currently have a 12'' ibook G4 and am thinking of upgrading to the MBA. Your post seems very informative and after checking the real thing in the store, I am thoroughly impressed. I haven't really had any experience with how bootcamp works though so I wanted to know if you have both installed and how much actual storage space is left in the memory after having OS X installed (and if applicable, the windows). I already have a PC that I use for programs that only run on windows but I would really like to be able to run such programs on my mac. What's your take on that?

Oh, and do you have a protective case for the MBA?
 
check out vmware rather than bootcamp to run windows.
the only advantages of bootcamp are

1. price (bootcamp's free, but if you've got the cash for a MBA...) and
2. full speed graphics for games (but a MBA will suck at games anyway)

--- well IMHO anyway
 
Congratulations on the new MBA.

I currently have a 12'' ibook G4 and am thinking of upgrading to the MBA. Your post seems very informative and after checking the real thing in the store, I am thoroughly impressed. I haven't really had any experience with how bootcamp works though so I wanted to know if you have both installed and how much actual storage space is left in the memory after having OS X installed (and if applicable, the windows). I already have a PC that I use for programs that only run on windows but I would really like to be able to run such programs on my mac. What's your take on that?

Oh, and do you have a protective case for the MBA?

With OS X, Office 2008, firefox and a few other apps that I deem essential I have 57.75 GB of space left. I plan on using my MBA as a second computer, as my desktop (iMac) is more than enough for any heavy computing needs I might have. With this in mind and the limited disk space I recommend using VmWare or parallels istead of boot camp. You wont have to partition your disk and there is something to be said about the ability of running OS X and Windows side by side. By the way, avoid vista and stick with windows Xp. Vista is a resource hog and the install takes much more disk space than Xp.
 
I bought a Macbook Air 2 weeks ago and its great I can't believe how cool it is. I had a few troubleshooting problem but in general it works great. Here is a page for Macbook Air Problem solving if you'll ever need it.

Thanks

Cochak
 
I would second the recommendation for using parallels vs. bootcamp. Parallels runs very nicely, and no need to restart to do whatever windows stuff you have to do. Been using it for a little over a year on my intel macbook with no problems.
 
The biggest reason I've heard people cite for not wanting a MBA is the lack of the drive. I then ask them how often they use their current dvd drive and I get the "Ionoo....." with a bit of a blush. The lack of ports is also an issue, albeit a minor one most of the time. I got to play around with it quite a bit and I am impressed. The one thing I did not like is how freakishly narrow the click part of the touch pad is. I'm 6'5", so my hands are on the slightly larger side and it just did not sit that comfortably with me. I'm sure I'd adjust after a day or two though. As noted, it is not a primary computer, especially if you intend to do anything on the hardcore side. The longer I use computers, the more I find myself being relegated to the same things : Email, Documents, Internet, Chat, and Music. Those 5 things are probably 90+% of my time on the computer, and for those it is great. If you are like me and have your laptop attached to your hip with your entire life in it, then I think it is a great alternative as well. I transitioned to a macbook from a 17 inch dell beast. This thing felt like a feather compared to that. Now, I am finding myself wanting something even more portable for how much I use it.
 
I prefer to not have a DVD drive (makes it lighter). I would actually prefer a smaller screen (12") to fit the form factor of the PowerBook 12" that was around a few years ago. I would also like to see another speaker (to make it stereo) that is of higher quality than the current tin-sounding speaker.
 
Top