Medicine & Step I

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

praying4MD

2K Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 21, 2001
Messages
2,444
Reaction score
3
I know this has probably been asked before, but I will ask anyway. My school does not require that we take the boards before entering clinical rotations. The rumor is that it helps to have had internal medicine before taking the boards because you remember your patients and the intricacies of their diseases more than you remember studying it from a book. Is there any truth to the rumor that having gone through your internal medicine rotation would help you on Step I?
 
I would say that your school has extremely high board scores and I would follow whatever advice they gave you.
 
Jalby said:
I would say that your school has extremely high board scores and I would follow whatever advice they gave you.
Ah, but it is selection bias-- people at a particular school will do well on the boards no matter what-- they are overachievers anyway. Or is it due to the curriculum?

btw, how ya been Jalby?
 
I've been good. How about yourself?? And it's not all selection Bias. Compared to other schools that have students with the same #'s, Baylor does better.
 
I think that it is a mistake to delay step 1 until after clerkships because so many of the fine details got lost with every passing day. It's like if someone took the step 1 on a monday and were told that their exam got screwed up and they have to retake the exam 10 days later. I am pretty sure that would be a nightmare scenario. the best thing to do is not fear the step 1 and take it ASAP after 2nd year, it will take a huge load off the shoulders. No matter how many patients you see, you're probably not going to see so many of the pathologies that are found in the step 1. Just pick up a copy of any path book like BRS Path and look at how many pathologies there are that are so rare that most people will never see them, yet they are the meat and potatoes of board exams. Same goes for microbio too. In my opinion, being on the wards *may* enhance your knowlege of pharm, but it will probably cause a diminishing of the details of theoretical physiology, pathology, microbio and biochemistry. The biggest pitfall in my opinion is forgetting pathology. There is SO much pathology to be learned for step 1 that if you forget a lot of it, then you will have to repeat all of your effort from the 2nd year path course just to come back to the level of path knowledge that you had at the end of 2nd year. I know some schools let the students take the step1 whenever they want, but I suspect the only reason it turns out well is that most of those school only take candidates with the highest scores,etc and those candidates are likely to study and relearn all the material again.
Either way, that is an arduous experience. BUt if you do hold off on the taking the step 1, my strong advice would be to keep reading your pathology text, or review book, or notes or whatever. Once your knowledge of path fades away, step 1 becomes a painful experience where it seems like 2-3 answers are correct for each question on the step 1 and the whole exam is spent sitting on the fence. "Well...gee...I kind of heard of monckeberg arteriosclersosis....but did that effect the tunica intima or media and did that effect the aorta or the radial artery....and was that all about atherosclerosis or was it about calcification....". Suddenly, 2-3 answers seem right for every question. To make a long story short, take Step 1 ASAP, if you delay it, then make sure to keep your knowledge of path intact.
 
Thanks for all the replies and helpful advice. Unfortunately, I had already opted to delay Step I until the middle of my third year, but I will take your advice and try to keep up on my reading. Although, anyone in clinics knows that we are struggling to just keep up with studing for the board, let alone reviewing old material, so this will prove difficult for me. And you're right-- I already feel as if I've forgotten a mountain of material-- funny how all the minutiae just leaves me within months. But at the same time, there are a couple of really salient points that stick out in my mind simply because I have been pimped on them by my chief resident and looked like a complete dumba$$ because I didn't know it-- but now, I will never forget those few things. In addition, on the wards, I am constantly made to look up stuff pertaining to my patients, so perhaps that will help solidify some of this knowledge.

Any other advice anyone has would be much appreciated.

And jalby: I'm good, just got done with my month of general surgery so I am chilling and marveling that I do not have to get up and 4 am anymore. Isn't life beautiful that way?

Hope life is treating you well. Any idea of what you are going to go into yet?
 
praying4MD said:
And jalby: I'm good, just got done with my month of general surgery so I am chilling and marveling that I do not have to get up and 4 am anymore. Isn't life beautiful that way?

Hope life is treating you well. Any idea of what you are going to go into yet?

I start G Surg in 6 days, and am a little bit scared that that is my first one. Oh well. I'm thinking I want to do Ortho right now, But really I have no idea.
 
Top