mentor responsibility in residency

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

faisal 2000

Probationary Status
10+ Year Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2012
Messages
341
Reaction score
47
hi there
i just finish my meting with my mentor
he has no idea what is his responsibility, even me to be honest.
and he asked me for another meting next week for that
could you please give me what he and i should do

thanks
 
hi there
i just finish my meting with my mentor
he has no idea what is his responsibility, even me to be honest.
and he asked me for another meting next week for that
could you please give me what he and i should do

thanks
It depends...but how is this person your mentor? Were they just randomly picked?

The question is what is s/he mentoring you for? Generally picking a mentor is based on what you need and what they can offer...research or being a woman in medicine, trying to get into a certain specialty,etc.
 
What specialty? Most often your "mentor" or adviser is someone who goes over your evaluations with you quarterly, works on goals based on eval feedback, makes sure you're meeting the milestones and if you need a little extra TLC they can help you with that before you get to the point of needing remediation. They're also there to listen to your concerns and address them as needed and if needed. For example, if you come in complaining that your last block sucked hard they'll be a sympathetic ear. If you come in complaining of significant feelings of depression/burnout their job is to catch that early and get you help
 
hi there
i just finish my meting with my mentor
he has no idea what is his responsibility, even me to be honest.
and he asked me for another meting next week for that
could you please give me what he and i should do

thanks

What kind of question is this? Also, please use correct grammar.

Mentors tend to fall into 3 categories and there is significant overlap:

1) Research mentors - typically someone you work with on a research project. They will help you identify (or give you) a project and will meet with you periodically to make sure the project is being completed. They typically will be a letter-writer for a resident who wants to go onto fellowship.

2) Clinical mentors - typically someone within the IM department where you worked with on service. They model the kind of doctor you wish to be and may have a role residency education. IM program directors fall into this category. They help you become a better clinician and can sometimes serve as a letter writer.

3) Life mentors - typically someone further along in their career than you who can give you advice on longterm goals, such as breakdown between clinical work and research, how to navigate personal life in academic medicine (think long-distance significant others in or not in medicine, how to succeed as woman in medicine, etc). This is typically neglected in most programs but is invaluable to most trainees.

True mentorship develop organically. A good mentor will devote time and effort to help further your career and will take joy in seeing you succeed. From what you said, it sounds like you were assigned a 'mentor' by your program. Generally, this is done to offload the work on the program director and this person is there to check-in with you to make sure you're going through residency just fine. While he/she could develop to be a true mentor, his/her role at the moment is to make sure you're not lagging in your clinical training. At the next meeting, you could ask him/her to point you to some faculty you could do research with (if you're interested in that). That'd be a good starting point.
 
What kind of question is this? Also, please use correct grammar.

Mentors tend to fall into 3 categories and there is significant overlap:

1) Research mentors - typically someone you work with on a research project. They will help you identify (or give you) a project and will meet with you periodically to make sure the project is being completed. They typically will be a letter-writer for a resident who wants to go onto fellowship.

2) Clinical mentors - typically someone within the IM department where you worked with on service. They model the kind of doctor you wish to be and may have a role residency education. IM program directors fall into this category. They help you become a better clinician and can sometimes serve as a letter writer.

3) Life mentors - typically someone further along in their career than you who can give you advice on longterm goals, such as breakdown between clinical work and research, how to navigate personal life in academic medicine (think long-distance significant others in or not in medicine, how to succeed as woman in medicine, etc). This is typically neglected in most programs but is invaluable to most trainees.

True mentorship develop organically. A good mentor will devote time and effort to help further your career and will take joy in seeing you succeed. From what you said, it sounds like you were assigned a 'mentor' by your program. Generally, this is done to offload the work on the program director and this person is there to check-in with you to make sure you're going through residency just fine. While he/she could develop to be a true mentor, his/her role at the moment is to make sure you're not lagging in your clinical training. At the next meeting, you could ask him/her to point you to some faculty you could do research with (if you're interested in that). That'd be a good starting point.

thank you so much for this
and regarding clinical mentor
can I make an arrangement with him in monthly bases for clinical sessions (talk about cases, chose topics to talk about it ...) ??
 
thank you so much for this
and regarding clinical mentor
can I make an arrangement with him in monthly bases for clinical sessions (talk about cases, chose topics to talk about it ...) ??

No. You're in residency now. This is not medical school. You can always ask, but attendings have a life and other responsibilities too.
 
hi there
i just finish my meting with my mentor
he has no idea what is his responsibility, even me to be honest.
and he asked me for another meting next week for that
could you please give me what he and i should do

thanks
It is important to set clear expectations between mentor and mentee upfront. Both must be aware of the goals and objectives otherwise it is not effective. I suggest YOU discuss YOUR expectations at your next meeting.
 
Top