Minnesota vs Nebraska vs Wake Forest

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

US9283

New Member
Joined
May 19, 2025
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
I am currently accepted to Minnesota and Nebraska, and am still on the waitlist for Wake Forest. I need to make a decision here soon and am curious to hear opinions on my situation. I definitely am trying to keep an open mind in terms of residency, but I like surgical/proceduralist specialties and am leaning towards ortho.

All Have:
  • 1.5 Year Curriculum
  • In person or remote lecture option
  • Essentially all in house residency options
  • P/F preclinical
Minnesota
Pros
  • In-state tuition - Lowest 4-year COA (305,000)
  • Close to family - note - I have lived away from home for over 5 years and have enjoyed my independence, but understand the benefits of having a close support system. Would be curious to hear thoughts on how important this pro is in med school.
  • True P/F for preclinical and clinical (maybe a con in clinical due to interest in competitive specialties)
  • Well known and trusted in Minnesota if I eventually return to practice (70% of physicians in Minnesota are UofM graduates)
  • Good ortho match
  • Top 20 for NIH funding
Cons
  • Entering in blind: of the three, I haven’t toured the campus and do not know anyone in the classes, so I know the least about what its like to be a student there
  • Lowest opportunity to work with Spanish speaking patients
  • Tests on lockdown over the weekend - offers flexibility but also room for procrastination; not taking exams in person could be annoying
  • 2025 match list has a significant number of students deferring residency. Maybe it is due to MN displaying the future plans for all students and others excluded non-matched students? Have not seen this on other match lists and am not sure of its significance
  • Some access to a car M1
  • Switched to 1.5 year didactics 2 years ago, have been told it is still a WIP
  • Unknown what Fairview and UMMS ending partnership in 2027 means for clinical education (would be first M3 class to experience the split)
  • Class culture seems to be variable year-year
Nebraska
Pros
  • Tests usually every 2-3 weeks (Pro or maybe Con? I could see this keeping me more on track with studying vs quiz + test format blocks)
  • More condensed medical campus: convenient for shadowing and clinical years. The medical school and all buildings in the hospital are connected, almost all rotations are at the medical center
  • Very familiar with hospital layout, medical campus, and Omaha area
  • Have several friends in Omaha and at UNMC
  • High access to a car M1 year
  • Enhanced Medical Education Track (EMET)
Cons
  • More expensive than Minnesota – 345,000 4 year COA
  • Lowest of the three for Ortho and other top specialty matches
  • Already have lived here for several years and would like a new place (some benefits to this in terms of comfort)
Wake Forest
Pros
  • Phenomenal match list: commonly match top 10-20 programs into very competitive specialties, home program itself has many strong residency programs
  • Most interesting research opportunities, especially its Regenerative Medicine Institute
  • Best of the three schools for things I am interested in (MAESTRO Medical Spanish, global health electives/track, etc.)
  • Ability to do clinical years in Charlotte – new medical campus, Carolinas Medical Center, Pearl District (partnerships with many biomedical devices companies for training opportunities)
  • Best location: new place and weather – would be excited to live in a new place outside of the Midwest
  • Great class culture
Cons
  • Expensive: 400,000 4-year COA
  • No possibility of having a car M1 year
  • Anatomy is front loaded, not as integrated into blocks
  • Further from family
Summary: Wake Forest is my favorite school considering its programs and opportunities, but I’m not sure if its worth the extra 50-100k, Nebraska and Minnesota seem to be very similar but I’m curious to hear opinions on which school is better.

Members don't see this ad.
 
Last edited:
Between Minnesota and Nebraska, Minnesota is the clear winner. Minnesota is a better and more reputable program and it is 50k cheaper than Nebraska. Minnesota having better resources for matching ortho is just the cherry on top.

Minnesota versus Wake Forest is definitely tougher. A 100k difference in COA is pretty big, but if you love Wake Forest it might be worth it. If you are going to be in a high-paying specialty like ortho you may be able to afford that cost difference. You clearly love the program so I would highly consider it if you get in!
 
As a Wake grad (and MAESTRO grad), the answer here is Minnesota. It gives you the top 3: money, family, and prestige. Plus, UMN tends to keep their home students for competitive specialties while WF mixes things around, keeping a handful of each.

If you want to work with Spanish speaking patients at UMN, just do the hybrid program, and do your 3rd year clinical rotations at HCMC where you’ve got primarily minority patients. MAESTRO was not all that spectacular. If anything, it was just one more thing to attend when I already had other stuff to get done.
 
Top