People have been saying that rates can't go lower and will only go up for the last 20 years. Many people think back on the mortgage crisis and worry that having an ARM will cause them to loose their homes. Please look at the following chart that details mortgage rates for the last 40 years.
http://www.mortgagenewsdaily.com/mortgage_rates/charts.asp
As stated previously, the average home loan is held for a period of 3-7 years (depends on the source) but this is nothing close to a 30 year term, but see how close it is to the fixed portion of a 5/1 ARM? Many people believe that they are ahead if the rates go higher than their fixed rate as soon as an ARM would have been set to expire, but let's explore this. Let's take a 250,000 mortgage and compare a 5/1 ARM at 2.75% and a 30 year fixed at 3.5%. After a period of 5 years, the 5/1 arm would have paid a total of 32,982 in interest and the 30 year fixed paid a total of 42,253, which gives the ARM a savings of 9,271 over 5 years. Now lets assume the rate adjusts to 5% on the ARM (about the highest it as been in the last 10 years and almost double what it is today), the current principle balance is approx 223,000 for each loan, so the fixed pays 7741 interest in year 6 and the ARM pays 11,351, a difference of 3,610. Extrapolating this out, if the ARM adjusts to 5% right at year 6 and stays there, the breakeven point for the two loans comes in right about year 8. It really sounds to me like you are paying an awfully high premium to insure against the rate almost doubling AND you keeping the loan for more than 8 years.
By the way, the mortgage crisis was not caused by the 5/1 ARM as it exists today. Banks offered teaser rates for the first year that were below market value, thus the type of loan that really caused the crisis was basically a 1/1 ARM that was guaranteed to go up by at least 2% at the beginning of year 2, yet banks calculated a person's ability to repay based on the teaser rate offered only in the first year. For many people, they saw their interest rate triple, and this caused their payment to double making them no longer able to afford the loan.