Mt Sinai Beth Israel

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

doctorvonnostrand

New Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2016
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
I was quite upset when news stories leaked about Beth Israel closing. Many young attendings were recruited here after the Mt Sinai merger, and we hoped to build a great program. Our volume has increased dramatically and I thought we were on our way to a better future, and so the news of the impending closing was shocking and upsetting. Like everyone else here, I see through the "we are not closing, we are transforming" messages that Sinai quickly assembled following the news stories. If the news had not leaked, they would have said nothing until the day we close.

I was disappointed and felt wronged, but at least I will be ok. In the coming weeks, I will begin shifting my practice to other sites, and I am not alone in this endeavor. The "transformation" press releases suggest that things will not change for years, but the vast majority of attendings are already planning their departure, and some have already interviewed elsewhere outside of the Mt Sinai system.

But while the attendings may be able to weather this storm, my sympathies go out to the residents affected by this. Volume is down, 3 medical floors have closed, and pediatrics, GYN, and ortho are being moved to other sites. Yet, we tell the residents that they will receive outstanding training here for 1-2 more years and then will be absorbed by Mt Sinai or St Lukes, however; those programs simply can not absorb all of our residents and provide any meaningful residency experience. If someone in a position of power reads this, I would urge you to consider granting the residents orphan status. There is no coherent plan to provide for these residents futures and it is wrong to let them suffer as the program deteriorates. Providing orphan status as soon as possible would give them some hope in finding an appropriate program for the coming academic year.

Members don't see this ad.
 
This is shameful!! Those residents have worked hard to get to where they are, and this program is DENYING them their education. Shameful!
 
Ignoring the sock-puppeting going on in this thread, I can't believe the residency PDs and the GME folks at MSBI aren't getting out in front of this.

From the prospective resident/fellow standpoint, the available news suggests that you shouldn't bother to apply to this place for anything longer than a 1 year program. Whether that's right or wrong is kind of irrelevant. Any applicant with other options (including a sweet Starbuck's gig) should avoid this place.
 
Top