Need help about match, advice from illuminati plz (UT-Southwestern help us)

  • Thread starter Thread starter dave262
  • Start date Start date
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
D

dave262

I matched at school A, my #8 choice (my friends #1 choice)
Friend matched at school B his #5 chioce (my #1 choice)

Is there any way to get this switched around?

We're both students finishing at the same program. Is it possible to switch?
 
you are bound by the agreement. i'm almost positive that there can be no switching allowed and the only possible way is to get out of your match spot which would then preclude from joining NRMP for the next few years.

plus, why would the residencies seriously consider this? your program obviously did not rank your friend highly if it was his #1 and your top choice did not do the same for you.
 
dave262 said:
I matched at school A, my #8 choice (my friends #1 choice)
Friend matched at school B his #5 chioce (my #1 choice)

Is there any way to get this switched around?

We're both students finishing at the same program. Is it possible to switch?

First, congrats for matching.

Second, I hope you are joking.

Second-part 2, if you arent joking, just 'become' your friend for 4 years 😉
 
As long as both PDs are OK with the switch, there should not be any problem.
 
Some programs would rather have happy residents than unhappy residents. Use that to your advantage.

I know one girl from my school who is trying to get out of her matched spot in peds to go to another place with an opening. It's shady but it's been done and will continue to be done.
 
yah but the only thing that sucksis if it DOESNT work. both programs are going to hate BOTH of you all..because they both know u dont want to be there.....
 
It can be done but it may take some work getting done. First, off, are both of you in categorical positions? If so, that will make it difficult, depending on how each program uses its categorical positions in the context of the entire residency training program (i.e., will you already be doing anesthesia rotations as interns).

Secondly, as mentioned above, both programs have to be comfortable with your academic standing and be willing to look at either of you. The switch I helped to engineer a few years ago was during a period of time where the competitiveness had increased, but was still not nearly at the level it is at right now. The programs will have the final say on whether or not they will be amenable to the switch.

At this point, both of you need to to excel in your internships and maintain lines of communication with your program directors. It is ESSENTIAL that you both relay to them that you both believe that your respective programs are excellent programs but that family/exigent circumstances would be tremendously allayed with a switch of residencies. If you are both categorical, this is something that you would like to have done now as opposed to next year, but it will be risky given that the programs have no way to judge either of you in terms of performance.

In either circumstance, understand that you are taking a risk that your current program might decide to drop you. In all fairness to them, they don't want to switch a resident they like for one that might turn into a problem child (as occurred at my program, for which I have been constantly reminded by my former faculty, though thankfully in jest).

If both of you can PM me with your background info and the programs involved, I can look into the situation to see if the programs at issue are flexible and have shown a willingness to accomodate this trade in the past.
 
My story:
Matched in anesthesia as a med student
Decided as an intern I really needed to do Emergency medicine (clearly the sleep deprivation as an intern prior to the 80-hour work week made me clinically insane)
Got released from my Anesthesia position, went through the match AGAIN as an intern -> matched in EM
Did two years in EM, realized that I was clinically insane to want to be the triage doc/drug seeker source/midnight primary care scut girl -> went back to the Anesthesia PD that I had originally matched to, threw myself on my knees and begged for mercy (and a spot back in his program)....
3 years later I'm graduating from my original anethesia program (and they even let me be chief resident...talk about open-minded)...and I'm sooooooo glad that I'm an anesthesiologist. I love my job every damn day. 😍

Moral of the story: its always worth a try...and try to make up your mind the first time. Cost me a LOT of money to go through flying around for inteviews, ect twice....and I felt like a *****.....but it was all worth it.
 
PiPhiDoc said:
My story:
Matched in anesthesia as a med student
Decided as an intern I really needed to do Emergency medicine (clearly the sleep deprivation as an intern prior to the 80-hour work week made me clinically insane)
Got released from my Anesthesia position, went through the match AGAIN as an intern -> matched in EM
Did two years in EM, realized that I was clinically insane to want to be the triage doc/drug seeker source/midnight primary care scut girl -> went back to the Anesthesia PD that I had originally matched to, threw myself on my knees and begged for mercy (and a spot back in his program)....
3 years later I'm graduating from my original anethesia program (and they even let me be chief resident...talk about open-minded)...and I'm sooooooo glad that I'm an anesthesiologist. I love my job every damn day. 😍

Moral of the story: its always worth a try...and try to make up your mind the first time. Cost me a LOT of money to go through flying around for inteviews, ect twice....and I felt like a *****.....but it was all worth it.

You sound like a person at my program who switched into EM after his intern year. When I was chief resident the following year, I saw him again and he reiterated that he was happy, though working harder than expected. I got a call from him last week asking how he should approach the chairman of anesthesiology about possibly switching back. Unfortunately for him, it isn't going to happen with a full class coming in plus three transfers already inked.
 
Top