Actually, you are trying to pay someone to violate the NRMP regulations on the match & the scramble...so yes, that is unethical. The fact that the NRMP only provides the list to unmatched applicants who registered is not a 'slight flaw in the system'--it is fair. Otherwise, why should any of us bother to properly apply through ERAS and pay for the NRMP match, if others can just bypass all that in a free-for-all? And if you finished a family medicine residency, I have a hard time believing that you 'simply didn't understand the procedure.' Presumably you actually have experience with the 'procedure' from when you applied to your first residency. As someone who is not scrambling myself, but has wonderful classmates who are unfortunate enough to have to scramble tomorrow (trying to get into their FIRST residency), after they followed the system the 'right' way, I think it's pretty sketchy for people to try and do what you're doing.