NP vs. MD

Started by riverjib
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

riverjib

Full Member
10+ Year Member
I am pursuing medical school and applying this summer. Since I'm graduating with a bachelor's degree this spring, I applied for a position that is designed to be a gap-year job for future MD's. I made it through three rounds of interviews, and it went well.

The director of the program is an NP. One of her first questions was why I wanted to go into medicine rather than becoming an NP. She liked my answer, but still suggested that it needed polishing for med school interviews. Having worked in medicine for the past ten years, I discussed the fundamental differences between the disciplines. Nursing focuses on patient wellness, whereas medicine focuses on physiology and the science behind medicine.

The lines between the two professions are blurred, especially in NYC, where I've seen NP's perform in a role that is basically equivalent to the MD. Still, there is a difference in the training and the general philosophy behind the two disciplines.

I'm not here to argue which is more valid, because I believe both play vital roles in medicine. Patients increasingly favor NP's (that includes my family and friends) because they're more accessible and generally show greater concern for patients as individual people.

I chose the MD route because I'm not sure what I want to do in the long run, and I don't want to be limited. I'm interested in emergency medicine and anesthesiology, and NP's and CRNA's can take either role. However, I might opt for trauma surgery or something that NP's can't (yet) do, and that's why I'm driven to go to medical school.

Can anyone elucidate what they think is the fundamental difference? I have to follow up with the director, and I need to come up with a satisfactory answer that in no way disparages what NP's do.
 
I have to follow up with the director, and I need to come up with a satisfactory answer that in no way disparages what NP's do.

Well, then...you certainly don't want to answer honestly. 😉

The question is a trap. Your interviewer wants you to stroke her ego.

How would you answer if this were asked during your med school interview instead? Food for thought.

You could ask the same question of any two fields. Why do you want to be a doctor instead of a pharmacist or a dentist? The honest answer boils down to, "because I want to be a doctor."

The education and training of a nurse and a doctor are completely different. The fact that some members of one group now like to think that they're equivalent doesn't change the reality that they're not.

You've asked this question in at least two other forums already. Not sure what else there is to add.

http://more.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?p=9095492
http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=691307
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Exactly what I was thinking when I read it.

Should I say, because at 45 I'm too old to become an MD, but not for NP? 😛

I had a med school classmate who was 50 when he started.

I don't know your situation, but age alone doesn't have to be a barrier.
 
I had a med school classmate who was 50 when he started.

I don't know your situation, but age alone doesn't have to be a barrier.

More power to him.

Most people at these ages have grown children, but we started quite late. Med school is a minimum of 7yrs (assuming all pre-reqs and minimum residency) realistically it's 8-10yrs and $300-400k?

That's quite a bogey to pay back in your 60s.

But for a single person in their 50s or empty nester, I'd say go for it! Specially if you're single. Who cares how much you owe? The bank can't collect from a dead single person and you may not have anyone to leave the money to anyway.
 
More power to him.

Most people at these ages have grown children, but we started quite late. Med school is a minimum of 7yrs (assuming all pre-reqs and minimum residency) realistically it's 8-10yrs and $300-400k?

That's quite a bogey to pay back in your 60s.

But for a single person in their 50s or empty nester, I'd say go for it! Specially if you're single. Who cares how much you owe? The bank can't collect from a dead single person and you may not have anyone to leave the money to anyway.
Quite the optimist!

:laugh: