OMFS Late Decision

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

gothoopdreams

New Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2018
Messages
7
Reaction score
3
Any advice for someone that decided OMFS late into their third year? Taking CBSE July 31 and plan to apply after. Will have 3-5 externships in person. Have attended 5-7 virtual ones as well. Go to a state dental school, but am ranked high in my class.

How many programs should I apply to?

Whats the lowest CBSE I should submit?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 702
Any advice for someone that decided OMFS late into their third year? Taking CBSE July 31 and plan to apply after. Will have 3-5 externships in person. Have attended 5-7 virtual ones as well. Go to a state dental school, but am ranked high in my class.

How many programs should I apply to?

Whats the lowest CBSE I should submit?
Have you taken a practice CBSE for a score estimate?

Without a non-cat year, your chances of getting interviews with a score <70 is slim.

You’ll probably have to send some apps before you find out your score. Most people I knew applied to 30-50 programs.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Have you taken a practice CBSE for a score estimate?

Without a non-cat year, your chances of getting interviews with a score <70 is pretty slim.

You’ll probably have to send some apps before you find out your score. Most people I knew applied to 30-50 programs.
It looked like the earliest deadline of applications was 09/01. I think I should have my score back sometime in august hopefully. Willing to apply to as many schools as necessary. My last practice was 71. Still have 2 months until exam so hoping for improvement.
 
It looked like the earliest deadline of applications was 09/01. I think I should have my score back sometime in august hopefully. Willing to apply to as many schools as necessary. My last practice was 71. Still have 2 months until exam so hoping for improvement.
You’ll do great if you can send everything in by then! Just make sure everything is put in order to click submit. Apply everywhere (and I mean that, as much as you can afford). I know people who applied to 40-60 programs because it was worth it to them to match. 70+, solid class rank, and a great application. No way August will be too late to apply!
 
You’ll do great if you can send everything in by then! Just make sure everything is put in order to click submit. Apply everywhere (and I mean that, as much as you can afford). I know people who applied to 40-60 programs because it was worth it to them to match. 70+, solid class rank, and a great application. No way August will be too late to apply!
I agree! I applied to 32 programs but I know some people applied to more...granted I applied in 2019 before COVID. During COVID with virtual interviews...there number of programs applied to drastically went up!
 
You’ll do great if you can send everything in by then! Just make sure everything is put in order to click submit. Apply everywhere (and I mean that, as much as you can afford). I know people who applied to 40-60 programs because it was worth it to them to match. 70+, solid class rank, and a great application. No way August will be too late to apply!
Thank you!
 
Are you considering 4 or 6 year? CBSE averages vary for these 2 different types of programs
 
Apply to as many programs as you can afford and can see yourself being at. (And even the programs you are hesitant about, think would I rather train here for 4-6 years or not be an OMFS at all.) At the end of the day, matching into an OMFS program is a numbers game. You do not know which programs you are going to stand out to ahead of time, so give yourself the best chance by having your application go across the desk of more PDs.
 
Apply to as many programs as you can afford and can see yourself being at. (And even the programs you are hesitant about, think would I rather train here for 4-6 years or not be an OMFS at all.) At the end of the day, matching into an OMFS program is a numbers game. You do not know which programs you are going to stand out to ahead of time, so give yourself the best chance by having your application go across the desk of more PDs.
Would you say there is like a CBSE score cut off? like if you score less than X dont even bother applying.
 
Would you say there is like a CBSE score cut off? like if you score less than X dont even bother applying.
Dependent on many factors. 4 vs 6, intern year vs no intern year, personality and likeability, class rank, your uniqueness as a candidate, your letters, research, and probably most of all the program and PD looking at your application.

You’ll be surprised to find that the best candidates on the interview trail aren’t the highest scoring ones, but the most well rounded ones. It’s just a feel that they are likable/a good fit/hardworking. They didn’t strike me as the 90+ CBSE type but who knows.

To answer your question, if you have a perfect application (strong letters, ranked #1 in your class, done incredible research etc etc), I suppose you can apply with a 60 and garner interviews. But why not just aim for a 70-75 and have the pick of your choice.
Once you get past a certain score on the CBSE it just becomes about how many reps (hours and questions) you put in. It only gets easier. Good luck!
 
what about for 4-year programs?
Again hard to say. It felt like a 50-50 shot for people. A lot of the 4 years took interns and idk what their CBSE score was. I also had a lot of friends with 70’s and 75’s and above who did not match.
 
Again hard to say. It felt like a 50-50 shot for people. A lot of the 4 years took interns and idk what their CBSE score was. I also had a lot of friends with 70’s and 75’s and above who did not match.
would you say that more interns were accepted this cycle than previous cycles compared to straight out of dental school? wondering if maybe it was due to lack of externships this cycle and programs meeting fewer applicants?
 
would you say that more interns were accepted this cycle than previous cycles compared to straight out of dental school? wondering if maybe it was due to lack of externships this cycle and programs meeting fewer applicants?
i felt like it was 50/50 at almost all programs my friends matched at. i don't think it is attributed to externships. I think it is more attributed to the rise in applicant numbers, and the sheer numbers of interns applying. many interns end up at the programs they interned at.
 
would you say that more interns were accepted this cycle than previous cycles compared to straight out of dental school? wondering if maybe it was due to lack of externships this cycle and programs meeting fewer applicants?
If you look at the post-match stats from 2020 and then 2021, only 11 more spots were matched by a graduate that wasn't in dental school the year of applying (i.e. internship, GPR, private practice) than the year before. I would've expected that number to be a lot higher with the COVID year, personally. But, for "the year of the intern" that we all talked about on here, it really wasn't.

YearApplicantsApplicants matchedmatch rateD4s matchednon-D4 matched
2020​
438​
230​
52.5%​
147​
83​
2021​
493​
235​
47.7%​
141​
94​
 
If you look at the post-match stats from 2020 and then 2021, only 11 more spots were matched by a graduate that wasn't in dental school the year of applying (i.e. internship, GPR, private practice) than the year before. I would've expected that number to be a lot higher with the COVID year, personally. But, for "the year of the intern" that we all talked about on here, it really wasn't.

YearApplicantsApplicants matchedmatch rateD4s matchednon-D4 matched
2020​
438​
230​
52.5%​
147​
83​
2021​
493​
235​
47.7%​
141​
94​
Great chart. Looks like it’s just tough to match in general. I
 
Can confirm that is absolutely not true. I knew plenty this cycle with 64-69 range that got 7-10+ and matched at 6 year programs this cycle.
Agreed.
 
Great chart. Looks like it’s just tough to match in general. I
The number who applied is actually higher than 438, since this number does not count those who applied but did not submit a rank list. I know of some people who received zero interview invites and so didn't even submit a rank list-they are not counted as part of the 438. So, in actuality, the number applying is higher than 438, and the match rate for those applying is lower than 52%.
 
The number who applied is actually higher than 438, since this number does not count those who applied but did not submit a rank list. I know of some people who received zero interview invites and so didn't even submit a rank list-they are not counted as part of the 438. So, in actuality, the number applying is higher than 438, and the match rate for those applying is lower than 52%.
The Match categorizes individuals who were not ranked by a single program as "non-acceptable" applicants. With that said, the % of non-acceptable applicants actually increased from 2020 to 2021 (or, % of "acceptable" applicants decreased).

There was a paper published in JOMS a few months ago that summarizes the stats from this past cycle nicely: Reflections on the Oral-Maxillofacial Surgery Residency Virtual Match
 
  • Like
Reactions: 702
Personal anecdotes!
Personal anecdotes are fallacies when conclusions are loosely drawn from personal experience to refute statistical data with a quality sample size; bergus95, however, illustrated the fact that people do get accepted to 6-years with scores lower than 75. Does the data show only people with 75+ match? You made the claim not to even bother applying if you have less than a 75. Where’s your non-anecdotal evidence that people with scores under 75 should refrain from applying?
 
Personal anecdotes are fallacies when conclusions are loosely drawn from personal experience to refute statistical data with a quality sample size; bergus95, however, illustrated the fact that people do get accepted to 6-years with scores lower than 75. Does the data show only people with 75+ match? You made the claim not to even bother applying if you have less than a 75. Where’s your non-anecdotal evidence that people with scores under 75 should refrain from applying?

Please refer to this survey-based publication in JOMS from August 2020: Does a Difference Exist in Comprehensive Basic Science Examination Scores of 4-Year versus 6-Year Oral-Maxillofacial Surgery Residents?

The authors bring up a couple of good points. Smaller sample size, but all statistically significant: "our study also showed a significant difference in the mean CBSE scores between the 4YPs and 6YPs (63.5 vs 75.3; P < .0001)."

6-year programs mean: 75.3 +- 7.1, median: 75
4-year programs mean: 63.5 +- 7.6, median: 63

Never did I claim that people with under 75 should refrain from applying. However, if you want to be considered competitive in terms of purely your CBSE, you may want to be above the average.
 
Personal anecdotes!
Personal anecdotes are fallacies when conclusions are loosely drawn from personal experience to refute statistical data with a quality sample size; bergus95, however, illustrated the fact that people do get accepted to 6-years with scores lower than 75. Does the data show only people with 75+ match? You made the claim not to even bother applying if you have less than a 75. Where’s your non-anecdotal evidence that people with scores under 75 should refrain from applying?
I want to just be clear, that I think people with sub 70’s should aim to take the exam one more time if they can. You will be screened out by many programs with a sub 65 as well as a 70’s score, both 4 and 6. At the highly desired programs that may be a 75. Even an 80. At the same time, many programs will review your application with a 65-70. I know this firsthand. Many of my peers who matched to 6 year programs this year had a 64-70. They were otherwise stellar applicants.

The better scores, class rank, more Externships, more strong letters from oral surgeons, more unique experiences, more likable personality, and most of all more programs applied to, the greater the likelihood of matching.

how badly do you want it?
 
Please refer to this survey-based publication in JOMS from August 2020: Does a Difference Exist in Comprehensive Basic Science Examination Scores of 4-Year versus 6-Year Oral-Maxillofacial Surgery Residents?

The authors bring up a couple of good points. Smaller sample size, but all statistically significant: "our study also showed a significant difference in the mean CBSE scores between the 4YPs and 6YPs (63.5 vs 75.3; P < .0001)."

6-year programs mean: 75.3 +- 7.1, median: 75
4-year programs mean: 63.5 +- 7.6, median: 63

Never did I claim that people with under 75 should refrain from applying. However, if you want to be considered competitive in terms of purely your CBSE, you may want to be above the average.
The question posed was what cutoff should one refrain from applying? Based off your very small sample size, One should absolutely apply with a sub 75 since the majority of OMFS matched applicants have below a 75.

To rally to your point though, this past year brought massive gains in CBSE scores of matriculated applicants. That 4 year median score is no longer the case. In just one year it has increased by a significant number based of reported numbers programs sent out to us. Same goes for 6 year programs.

I still would apply though if I had a 69. Worst case scenario is a rejection.
 
Please refer to this survey-based publication in JOMS from August 2020: Does a Difference Exist in Comprehensive Basic Science Examination Scores of 4-Year versus 6-Year Oral-Maxillofacial Surgery Residents?

The authors bring up a couple of good points. Smaller sample size, but all statistically significant: "our study also showed a significant difference in the mean CBSE scores between the 4YPs and 6YPs (63.5 vs 75.3; P < .0001)."

6-year programs mean: 75.3 +- 7.1, median: 75
4-year programs mean: 63.5 +- 7.6, median: 63

Never did I claim that people with under 75 should refrain from applying. However, if you want to be considered competitive in terms of purely your CBSE, you may want to be above the average.
I agree. The OP asked if there is a score below which one should not even bother applying, and you responded directly stating 75+ for 6-years. It’s a clearly implied claim. But yes I agree, 75+ should be the goal, but not a rigid necessity.
 
That 4 year median score is no longer the case. In just one year it has increased by a significant number based of reported numbers programs sent out to us. Same goes for 6 year programs.

I still would apply though if I had a 69. Worst case scenario is a rejection.
what programs sent out numbers? was this real data?
 
what programs sent out numbers? was this real data?
One program sent in its interview offer letter the number of applicants and average CBSE, another mentioned it in some email they sent out. This shouldn’t be hush hush. You can either email the PD or the admin and ask. Most of them will tell you.
 
One program sent in its interview offer letter the number of applicants and average CBSE, another mentioned it in some email they sent out. This shouldn’t be hush hush. You can either email the PD or the admin and ask. Most of them will tell you.
ah okay, so pretty limited data set. I had a friend who did urology and every year all the applicants compile this awesome excel spreadsheet of where they matched, their step scores and other stats for future years to have.
 
ah okay, so pretty limited data set. I had a friend who did urology and every year all the applicants compile this awesome excel spreadsheet of where they matched, their step scores and other stats for future years to have.
I wish we had that. It’s usually a self selecting group that posts.

But even the programs I mentioned stated that they received “200 something apps” I forget the exact number. That’s a pretty solid number of people. They mean applicant score was a 194 for this 4 year programs. They interviewed a quarter of the applicants. I would venture to guess for this particular program the average interviewee score had a mean of 200-205 or so. But this is just speculation based off of the numbers they provided.
 
Is there an age cut off for OMFS residency? My understanding is that most programs prefer recent graduates. What if you practice for several years and then you decide you want to apply? Will they not consider you?
Put together a solid app, and don’t look back if it’s what you want
 
Top