Pediatrician or Dentist

  • Thread starter Thread starter NP545
  • Start date Start date
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Have you shadowed both specialties?

Shadowed 3 types of doctors ~50 hours total, and 1 dentist for about ~5 hours formal shadowing + my routine dental visits (may do more)

Shadowing didn't make me appreciate one over the other though.
 
Probably dentist. Easier to own small business, makes your life far more flexible if you are your own boss or part of a group that is willing to cater to you. Peds can be very stressful and underpaid.
 
Shadowed 3 types of doctors ~50 hours total, and 1 dentist for about ~5 hours formal shadowing + my routine dental visits (may do more)

Shadowing didn't make me appreciate one over the other though.

You'll need to do more shadowing if you're serious about dentistry. There's a pre-dental section of SDN further down the forum page if you'd like answers from their perspective.
 
If lifestyle is your priority, probably dentistry. My mom is a pediatrician and loves it but it's very, very stressful, and she spends many hours working outside of work.
 
If lifestyle is your priority, probably dentistry. My mom is a pediatrician and loves it but it's very, very stressful, and she spends many hours working outside of work.

Lifestyle and $$$$. YAS

(I work a lot, but it's the non patient related business and employee crap that eats up more of my patience/soul)
 
Pediatric dentist - best of both worlds!
 
Pediatrician, I love kids. I also don't have nice teeth, can't be a dentist without a pretty grill.😀
 
I also don't have nice teeth, can't be a dentist without a pretty grill.😀

I hope this is sarcasm...

Premed vs Predent seems to be the $1,000,000 question when you like both options equally.

Pros:
med- respect, prestige, knowledge, many more
dental-flexible, independent,hands-on
ease to find job and job security? med is good for these but have no idea for dental...

Cons:
med- longer, potential governmental issues with obamacare, other reform (does this seem to improve within the next 5-10 years or do you all envision it getting worse?)
dental- not a doctor, bad rep?, possible regret?
 
I hope this is sarcasm...

Premed vs Predent seems to be the $1,000,000 question when you like both options equally.

Pros:
med- respect, prestige, knowledge, many more
dental-flexible, independent,hands-on
ease to find job and job security? med is good for these but have no idea for dental...

Cons:
med- longer, potential governmental issues with obamacare, other reform (does this seem to improve within the next 5-10 years or do you all envision it getting worse?)
dental- not a doctor, bad rep?, possible regret?

Well to make the pro/con analysis easier just throw out "respect, prestige, bad rep" on either side. That is more dependent on you than anything else and I really wouldn't expect respect and prestige from any job. More importantly, who really cares what others think of your profession if you are miserable?

Con for med: "longer". Try "never ends" instead. As a physician you are always a physician. In a restaurant, you are a physician. On a plane, you are a physician. You need to keep studying and stay up to date with important changes in the field in order to stay competent and able to give your patients the best possible care. I shadowed an oncologist last summer and I remember the stacks of journals on their desk waiting to be read, piling up from not having time to get to them. They probably won't read them cover to cover but I imagine they will eventually sit down and pick out the highlights that are important to them.

"Governmental issues". What do you mean here? Decreased autonomy, inability to practice privately, increased bureaucracy? This will all probably continue as th ACA will most likely never be repealed. Medicine is up for more reform in the future, ACA implementation is just getting started. Not all of this is bad. I would say most of it is good (braces for being chewed out) compared to the system we had before which was absolutely unsustainable regardless if it was better for docs or not.


I think you should look into both professions more closely. If you are concerned about lifestyle, $$$, and flexible hours, however, dental will win every single time.
 
Well to make the pro/con analysis easier just throw out "respect, prestige, bad rep" on either side. That is more dependent on you than anything else and I really wouldn't expect respect and prestige from any job. More importantly, who really cares what others think of your profession if you are miserable?

Con for med: "longer". Try "never ends" instead. As a physician you are always a physician. In a restaurant, you are a physician. On a plane, you are a physician. You need to keep studying and stay up to date with important changes in the field in order to stay competent and able to give your patients the best possible care. I shadowed an oncologist last summer and I remember the stacks of journals on their desk waiting to be read, piling up from not having time to get to them. They probably won't read them cover to cover but I imagine they will eventually sit down and pick out the highlights that are important to them.

"Governmental issues". What do you mean here? Decreased autonomy, inability to practice privately, increased bureaucracy? This will all probably continue as th ACA will most likely never be repealed. Medicine is up for more reform in the future, ACA implementation is just getting started. Not all of this is bad. I would say most of it is good (braces for being chewed out) compared to the system we had before which was absolutely unsustainable regardless if it was better for docs or not.


I think you should look into both professions more closely. If you are concerned about lifestyle, $$$, and flexible hours, however, dental will win every single time.

Does the ACA have an equal impact on dentistry as medicine? I always see doctors on here and also doctors I know complain about ACA, but have not really been around dentists much other than basic shadowing.

In regards to medicine, does it seem like doctors will still feel negatively about it (lower pay, insurance power increasing) in 5-10 years from now?
 
Does the ACA have an equal impact on dentistry as medicine? I always see doctors on here and also doctors I know complain about ACA, but have not really been around dentists much other than basic shadowing.

In regards to medicine, does it seem like doctors will still feel negatively about it (lower pay, insurance power increasing) in 5-10 years from now?

i don't know enough about either dentistry or the ACA to answer those questions. Will pay go down? Most likely. Will physicians ever be paupers like they were pre WW2? Probably not. Pre-dent could answer some of those questions I'm sure though, if you hop onto that forum and maybe just do a search for "ACA" and "dentistry".
 
Lol, prestige and "not a doctor" as pros for med. I can't even.

Also, obamacare is coming for us too unfortunately, however, they've mostly started off with pediatric dentists.
 
Top